Comments on: Asian Noodle Salad with Peanut Dressing http://leitesculinaria.com/18259/recipes-asian-noodle-salad-peanut-dressing.html This James Beard Award-winning site from David Leite offers food writing, cookbook and Portuguese recipes, giveaways, more. Sun, 21 Mar 2010 17:33:09 -0500 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.9.2 hourly 1 By: Testers Choice http://leitesculinaria.com/18259/recipes-asian-noodle-salad-peanut-dressing.html#comment-7679 Testers Choice Thu, 04 Mar 2010 23:25:48 +0000 http://leitesculinaria.com/?p=18259#comment-7679 [Elsa M. Jacobson] I made this salad as part of a Chinese New Year brunch that also included Squash Pancakes. Although I increased the recipe to serve a small army, every last dressed noodle was devoured. Author Karen Bussen introduces the recipe noting the balance of sweet and spicy flavors. For me, the balance went further: There is a balance of textures between the soft noodles and the crisp bean sprouts and carrots, as well as an attractive color balance with the addition of the bright orange carrots and the deep green cilantro. Bussen notes the chile paste could be eliminated for a milder flavor. I could have added <em>more</em> for a bolder flavor, as the tablespoon of chile paste did enliven the dish but didn't move it much beyond "mildly flavored." The two tablespoons of sesame oil had a more pronounced effect on the overall flavor than the paste. Though the recipe merely states sesame oil, I went ahead and used the Asian version, the thicker concentrated oil intended for seasoning and not for cooking. I also used a slightly thicker Chinese-style wheat noodle than the one in the photograph, and this was pleasing as there was a bit more noodle for the delicious sauce to cling to. I opted for smooth peanut butter. Many recipes for noodles with peanut dressing or sauce specify to not use natural peanut butter. Because this one did not so specify, I went ahead and used the natural peanut butter we use for sandwiches and it worked out just fine. The dish was not as oily as the Chinese-restaurant take-out version I enjoyed in New York, but every bit as tasty. I took the salad out of the fridge to bring it to room temperature before serving, though the recipe notes it can be served chilled or at room temperature. I felt the flavors would be more pronounced at room temperature and I believe this was correct: It was substantially more complex and, hence, more interesting as it warmed up a bit. This salad is easy to make, with no complicated ingredients, preparation, or lengthy processes involved. It is visually appealing, and pleasing to a range of palates. While we served it as part of a Chinese meal, it would also work as picnic or potluck food, or as part of a salad buffet, so long as nut allergies are checked out among the diners being served. [Elsa M. Jacobson] I made this salad as part of a Chinese New Year brunch that also included Squash Pancakes. Although I increased the recipe to serve a small army, every last dressed noodle was devoured. Author Karen Bussen introduces the recipe noting the balance of sweet and spicy flavors. For me, the balance went further: There is a balance of textures between the soft noodles and the crisp bean sprouts and carrots, as well as an attractive color balance with the addition of the bright orange carrots and the deep green cilantro.

Bussen notes the chile paste could be eliminated for a milder flavor. I could have added more for a bolder flavor, as the tablespoon of chile paste did enliven the dish but didn’t move it much beyond “mildly flavored.” The two tablespoons of sesame oil had a more pronounced effect on the overall flavor than the paste. Though the recipe merely states sesame oil, I went ahead and used the Asian version, the thicker concentrated oil intended for seasoning and not for cooking. I also used a slightly thicker Chinese-style wheat noodle than the one in the photograph, and this was pleasing as there was a bit more noodle for the delicious sauce to cling to.

I opted for smooth peanut butter. Many recipes for noodles with peanut dressing or sauce specify to not use natural peanut butter. Because this one did not so specify, I went ahead and used the natural peanut butter we use for sandwiches and it worked out just fine. The dish was not as oily as the Chinese-restaurant take-out version I enjoyed in New York, but every bit as tasty. I took the salad out of the fridge to bring it to room temperature before serving, though the recipe notes it can be served chilled or at room temperature. I felt the flavors would be more pronounced at room temperature and I believe this was correct: It was substantially more complex and, hence, more interesting as it warmed up a bit.

This salad is easy to make, with no complicated ingredients, preparation, or lengthy processes involved. It is visually appealing, and pleasing to a range of palates. While we served it as part of a Chinese meal, it would also work as picnic or potluck food, or as part of a salad buffet, so long as nut allergies are checked out among the diners being served.

]]>