For some, the perfect egg sunnyside up requires no accompaniment aside from the basic, fundamental technique, as outlined in Lucinda Scala Quinn’s recipe, and a sprinkle of crunchy, coarse sea salt. For others, there’s comfort to be found in the reassuring sameness of what’s served on the side time after time. And for the rest of us, well, just about anything goes. Wild mushrooms sautéed in duck fat. A schmear of aji Amarillo paste. Crisped leftover polenta. A bowl of Captain Crunch. Curious, or perhaps just insatiably voyeuristic, we asked chefs, cookbook authors, home cooks, and just about anyone who would talk to us about what they prefer on the side, on top, or underneath their perfectly cooked, sunnyside-up eggs—whether for breakfast, brunch, lunch, dinner, or a late, late supper. The responses show creativity, versatility, and, at times, more than just a little free-spiritedness.
In the interest of surprising and inspiring, here’s what we gathered, along with a few other mentions that we just like to contemplate—and, one of these days, maybe even recreate.
Eggs, sunnyside-up with toasted brioche.
—From the menu at Sunny Side Up Café in Sayreville, NJ
I’m not a toast man. I like them with either bacon or sausage. Obviously, I mean bacon or sausage from pork that’s been fattened on acorns and out in the woods eating bramble roots.
—Joel Salatin, owner of Polyface Farm, in Virginia’s Shenandoah Valley
LC Note: Salatin owns and operates a family-run, über-organic, environmentally friendly, non-GMO, local-minded farm where his pasture-raised hens eat nothing but grass and grubs and produce uncommonly rich-tasting eggs. His sustainable farming practices have been featured in the documentary “Food, Inc,” Michael Pollan’s The Omnivore’s Dilemma, and Gourmet.
One of the A16 staff favorites at the end of the night is an egg poached in whatever our zuppa or minestra for the day happens to be. We heat up the soup in a shallow sauté pan and gently poach the egg in its liquid. When it hits the bowl, the egg is essentially sunnyside-up. Right now, we’re featuring a zuppa from Puglia called cecamariti or “husband-blinder” zuppa. Basically, it’s served so piping-hot that it blinds the husband as he eats it. The soup has a variety of dried beans as well as fresh ceci beans in it, and it’s the perfect zuppa for adding an egg. We don’t have it on the menu, but we all love to eat it.
—Liza Shaw, chef and owner, A16 in San Francisco
Pass the Bottle Opener
A stout, preferably one with some oatmeal and coffee in there, which is obviously a good choice for breakfast. I like Founders Breakfast Stout. It makes a second version, which is essentially the same beer, but aged in bourbon barrels. It’s called Founders Kentucky Breakfast Stout. Another is Beer Geek Breakfast by Mikkeller. It’s also a coffee stout. And sometimes I like hash browns, although that’s not a daily thing.
—Josh Knowlton, who works at Bierkraft, a lovely little emporium in Brooklyn that carries more than 1000 beers
“’The Great Equalizer.’ It has been said of many things, including education, death, and the three-point line. But what holds this title in my kitchen is none other than the humble egg, cracked into a hot, oil-slicked skillet, and fried. Unless you’re a sucker for cold pizza or day-old Chinese takeout, ‘leftovers’ is a word not typically associated with breakfast. But in the early-morning hours, these suppers make a stellar second appearance under the sunny canopy of a fried, runny-yolked egg.
The fried egg works its magic without prejudice. I’d be hard pressed to finger a best of these egg-capped dinners reborn. The fried egg doesn’t play favorites, and neither do I. The sorriest heaps of leftover sautéed vegetables have made the fiercest comebacks; the merest of kitchen scraps have found their second winds, all thanks to the power of this equalizing ovum.”
—Excerpted from Sweet Amandine
Not For Everyone
I love a dab of fermented black bean chili sauce and sprigs of fresh cilantro!
—Tom Douglas, chef and owner of Dahlia Lounge, Etta’s, Lola, Palace Kitchen, and Serious Pie in Seattle
Kind of Elegant
“‘Eggs,’ declares Fran McCullough, having given the question more thought. ‘My favorite is Judy’s [Judith Rodgers, author of The Zuni Café Cookbook] eggs with crunchy breadcrumbs, which is kind of elegant in a very humble way.’
Adding buttery crisp breadcrumbs to your eggs lifts them from the ordinary but without straying from the basic ingredients. It’s only the form that changes, but that changes everything. Converting a slab of bread into rough little crumbs and then getting them crisp and delicious takes that tiny bit of extra care that transforms the ordinary into something that is, as Fran says, ’kind of elegant.’ Add some asparagus and a glass of Sancerre and you have a fine little supper for any night of the week, one you could even share with others.”
—Excerpted from Deborah Madison’s What We Eat When We Eat Alone (Gibbs Smith, 2009)
Wine List, Please
I would probably say my go-to wine is Chenin Blanc from the Loire Valley. It has a nice minerality and a touch of richness. As it ages, Chenin Blanc becomes honeyed and more viscous, playing off the richness of the yolk. I would say no to a Grüner Veltliner or a Sauvignon Blanc. You need more complexity, something with a clean acidity to finish it off. Something that will meet the egg halfway and not overwhelm it, like the Pithon-Paille Chenin Blanc, Anjou Loire France 2008.
—Claire Paparazzo, wine director at Blue Hill NYC, who imparts advice to diners every evening at Dan Barber’s Manhattan outpost
LC Note: The menu changes seasonally at Blue Hill, but almost always includes something sunnyside-up. Its current egg incarnation, which Paparazzo pairs with the Chenin Blanc mentioned above, is a “Root Vegetable Burger,” described on the menu as “sunny side up farm egg, Stone Barns butter lettuce and red cabbage ketchup.” In previous seasons, when ramps and speck were involved, Paparazzo has relied on a Domaine Mosse Anjou Les Bonnes Blanches 2008. When local mushrooms made an appearance, Francois & Denis Clair Santenay, Burgundy, France 1er Cru Clos de Tavannes 2006.
Simple. Pure. Perfect.
I love really simple food. When I go to eat eggs for myself, I like them with the yolk that is rare. I usually toast some bread and I like to dip it into the yolk. I have really great memories of eating eggs in Italy as a child, with the yolk really loose.
—Massi Boldrini, chef and owner of Riva Cucina in Berkeley
Seeing is Believing
Foods With Sunnyside-Up Eggs On Top
Eggs On Virtually Anything
It’s a vast subject, of course. I live off of fried eggs, partly because I’m so busy, and they’re so quick. I tend to put eggs on things. What I put them on tends to be what’s around. Often leftovers, whether a few bit of mushrooms or whatever’s around. I love eggs on cooked or raw greens, either as an instant breakfast or dinner, especially dandelion or arugula that’s dressed with good olive oil or sherry vinegar.
One of my all-time favorites is eggs on pasta with Parmiggiano-Reggiano. The Parmiggiano is a very good intermediary as it fuses with the warm yolk to make a lovely sauce that’s sort of carbonara-ish. Eggs cooked in duck fat are really sensational. I’ll often add some minced rosemary or thyme to the pan and the herb makes a little fragrance around the egg, which can be nice. Roasted or sautéed onions are inexpensive and easy. And potato chips are swell, in lieu of toast, if you have nothing else. Although toast of, course, is always wonderful.
—Sally Schneider, author of The Improvisational Cook and creator of The Improvised Life.
Our weekend brunch used to feature a wok-fried egg with pork belly, Pullman bread, and green mango salad. I wish we still had it on the menu, it was probably one of the best brunch-type dishes we offered. It was essentially eggs, bacon, and toast, but it had a little bit of spice from the sambal udang kering and a little sweetness from the salad. I would love for that dish to come back.
—Joe Tangnui, general manager of Fatty Crab, in New York City’s West Village and Upper West Side
Medium-Rare, Hold the Cheese
On a hamburger. That’s definitely my favorite accompaniment. I was vegetarian for most of my young adult years, so I didn’t have eggs at all. Then in graduate school in Charlottesville, my favorite burger place had a burger with an egg on top. It had all the regular stuff—cheese, bacon, tomatoes, lettuce, mayo—just with an egg on top of all that. It just seemed right.
—George Weld, owner of egg in Brooklyn. It’s a casual little restaurant where diners can add a fried egg to their burger for $1.25
Other Egg Affinities
Asparagus, bacon and pancetta, basil, bell peppers, especially green, bread, butter, capers, caviar, cheeses (Comte, Emmental, feta, Gruyère, Havarti, mozzarella, Parmesan, Roquefort), chervil, chives, chorizo, cream, cream cheese, créme frâiche, dill, garlic, ginkgo nuts, ham, herb, especially fines herbs (i.e., chervil, chives, parsley, tarragon), leeks, marjoram, mushrooms, olive oil, onions, parsley, pepper, potatoes, smoked salmon, salt, sausage, scallions, shallots, spinach, tarragon, thyme, tomatoes, and truffles.
—Excerpted from The Flavor Bible by Karen Page and Andrew Dornenburg (Little, Brown and Company, 2008)
Your Egg Affinities?
What do you consider to be the perfect accomplice to the perfect egg? A swipe of aji Amarillo paste? Crisped leftover polenta? A bowl of Fruit Loops? The morning paper? Divulge, please.