Hog Island Grilled Cheese

This grilled cheese sandwich is a favorite among San Franciscans. Never mind that it comes to hungry diners by way of an oyster bar. At Hog Island Oyster Bar, people line up for oysters as well as for this sandwich, the restaurant’s one concession to the fruits of the land. There, they use a northern California cheese called St. George, but because that’s not widely available I’ve substituted cheddar and Havarti, which together taste very similar to St. George. A word of caution: Keep plenty of napkins on hand for this!–Laura Werlin

LC Nonconformist Grilled Cheese Note

Have you taken a gander at the ingredients for this recipe from cheese authority Laura Werlin? It relies on a rather unconventional array of cheeses in arguably excessive amounts. Not only that, she proceeds to instruct us to heat the sandwich in a pan that’s covered part of the time. Blasphemy! Or so we thought. Then we tried it…

What To Sip Note: When we called the good folks at Hog Island and inquired what they recommended sipping with their masterpiece, a very decent guy named Bob explained, “I like to recommend drinking whatever wine you like with whatever food.” Amen to that. Still, he did offer a little more for those who don’t quite trust their instincts. “There’s not any pairing that makes it stand out more. If you care for a red, maybe a pinot. If you’d like a little acidity to cut the richness, maybe try a sauvignon blanc.” Thank you, Bob. We will.

Hog Island Grilled Cheese Recipe

  • Quick Glance
  • 10 M
  • 30 M
  • Makes 4 sandwiches

Ingredients

  • About 2 tablespoons butter, at room temperature
  • 8 relatively thick slices sourdough or pain au levain bread
  • 4 ounces fromage blanc
  • 4 ounces Gruyère cheese, coarsely grated (you could swap Comté or Swiss)
  • 4 ounces Cheddar cheese, coarsely grated (up to you how sharp a Cheddar)
  • 4 ounces Havarti cheese, coarsely grated

Directions

  • 1. Butter one side of each slice of bread, using all of the butter. Place 4 of the slices, buttered side down, on a parchment-lined counter or a cutting board. Spread 1/4 of the fromage blanc on the plain side of each of those 4 slices, then top each with 1/4 of the Gruyère, 1/4 of the Cheddar, and 1/4 of the Havarti. You may need to use your hand to squash the cheese a little to keep it from falling off the bread. Top each teetering tower of cheese with one of the remaining bread slices, buttered side up.
  • 2. Heat a large skillet over medium heat for 2 minutes. Place 1 or 2 sandwiches in the pan, cover, and cook for 3 to 5 minutes, until the undersides are golden brown. Turn the sandwiches and press each one firmly with a spatula to flatten it slightly. Cover and cook for 3 to 4 minutes, until the undersides are well browned. Remove the lid, turn the sandwiches once more, and press firmly with the spatula once again. Cook for 1 minute, or until the cheese has melted completely into a quagmire of gooeyness.
  • 3. Remove from the pan and let cool for 5 minutes while you repeat with the remaining sandwiches. Cut each in—either on the diagonal or right down the center—and serve immediately. With plenty of napkins.
Hungry for more? Chow down on these:

Testers Choice

Testers Choice
Testers Choice
Joan Osborne

Apr 11, 2011

Want to give your grilled cheese a college education? Try this recipe. We really liked the flavors of the cheeses I chose (a good Swiss, sharp cheddar, and Havarti) on the sourdough bread. I omitted the fromage blanc because I couldn’t find it in our local market. I’ve never grilled a sandwich with the cover on the pan, but I was pleased to find that the bread didn’t become soggy. Flattening the grilled cheese with a spatula is the way my mom always made grilled cheese for us, so I was thrilled to see the technique used in this recipe.

Testers Choice
Susan Bingaman

Apr 11, 2011

Sometimes, all you need in life is a good grilled cheese sandwich—and this one is it. My favorite part of the recipe is the direction to let it sit before serving. It was the first time I didn’t burn my mouth because I was so excited to eat. TIPS: The nonstick pan is very important! I made the sandwich again in my favorite skillet, and it just wasn’t the same. The bread stuck to it, and the cheese oozing out didn’t develop into a golden crisp. Also, the built-up steam from covering the skillet helps melt the cheese nicely. One word of warning, though: my husband complained of palate fatigue about three-quarters of the way through his sandwich. Adding in a sweeter or creamier cheese, or maybe a less tangy bread may be the solution.

Testers Choice
Chiyo Ueyama

Apr 11, 2011

I couldn’t have tested this recipe on a better night—at the end of a particularly busy workweek, after a long drive (crawl) home in several inches of snow. Armed with a digital scale and a timer, in no time a perfect, hot meal was ready. This sandwich still has the familiar gooey doneness of the classic, but with a higher level of gratification. The Hog Island Grilled Cheese is warm and oozy inside, but golden brown and crusty on the outside. Take it to your couch, put your feet up, and eat it with your hands while watching TV.

Testers Choice
Amy Iacopi

Apr 11, 2011

My husband and I live in San Francisco and share a birthday week, so every year, we go all-out at Hog Island Oysters, ordering their oysters, salad, soup, and grilled cheese. This sandwich is awesome, as long as you keep the heat on low and watch carefully for burning. I used a loaf of pain au levain, and needed a bit more butter to coat each slice of bread than what the recipe called for. The recipe also calls for a lot of cheese, so you definitely have to pat it down so it sticks together. The first bites evoked big smiles from all of us. The cheese blend paired with the hearty bread make it a unique grilled cheese, one that’s sure to be a crowd-pleaser. I’d definitely recommend this to anyone who loves cheese. And if you’re lucky enough to live in or visit San Francisco, make sure you head over to the Ferry Building to check out the real thing.

Testers Choice
Linda Pacchiano

Apr 11, 2011

This is a delicious sandwich. I used equal amounts of cheddar, Gruyère, and a mild provolone, and I found that grating the cheeses allowed them to melt perfectly. I also was fortunate to have a freshly baked loaf of country bread. Covering the sandwich for a part of the cooking time facilitated the melting of the cheeses, and by turning the sandwich over a couple of times, the bread remained crisp. You do need to watch the heat and progress of the browning, however, especially while the sandwich is covered—for each turn, I needed a minute or two less than what was specified in the recipe. Overall, this sandwich is worth the time it takes to prep—and it’s no wonder that people line up to buy it. Highly recommended!

Testers Choice
Abigail Corn

Apr 11, 2011

This is the kind of fat and heavy food we don’t eat much of at home anymore—we even gave away our toaster to avoid temptation. But on a rainy cold night, I prepared this for the family, serving it with a large mixed salad (to clean my conscience). We all liked it too much. I used Cheddar, Gruyère, and Bulgarian Kashkaval cheese between slices of sourdough rye bread with caraway seeds. The bread slices were about 1 centimeter thick, which was too thin for this kind of cooking and this amount of cheese, so next time we’ll try it with thicker slices.

Testers Choice
Sofia Reino

Apr 11, 2011

I love the simplicity of this recipe. It’s perfect for an evening in which you don’t have much time to prepare dinner for the family. Both my husband I liked that it was smooth, creamy, and filling. Covering the sandwiches while cooking didn’t make the bread soggy whatsoever.

Testers Choice
Taylor Wesa

Apr 11, 2011

If you want a serious grilled cheese, this is it, as this recipe definitely doesn’t skimp on the cheese. The fresh sourdough worked really well, as you need a hearty piece of bread to hold all the cheese. I sliced my bread a little thicker than 1/4-inch. I used a cast-iron skillet, which gave the sandwich a nice crispy crust, even when covered with a lid. I served this dish with sliced tomatoes and edamame drizzled with oil and balsamic vinegar. If you didn’t want to eat this as a whole meal, you could cut the sandwich into finger-sized slices, and maybe top it with a tomato puree. Overall, this recipe was so easy to make. TIP: If you have a kitchen scale, use it to measure the amount of cheese per sandwich.

Testers Choice
Allison J.

Apr 11, 2011

It was worth the extra effort to grate the different cheeses! I also used the St. George cheese, replicating the sandwich made at the Hog Island Oyster Bar, but if that’s not available, the Gruyère, Cheddar, and havarti combination works well.

Comments
Comments
  1. sara says:

    This looks fantastic!! Yum yum yum. :)

  2. Brenna Schlagenhauf says:

    Hog Island serves this sandwich with a side of house cured pickled vegetables. Epicurious.com has a quick and easy recipe for curing your own (and it really is easier than it sounds). Or, stop by your local grocer and pick up a jar of ready made — I recommend picking up any brand that looks a little more home-made than the average Vlassics.

    Otherwise serve with a fresh butter leaf salad with a light mustard vineagarette to help cut the fat in the sandwich.

    I like to sip a crisp Sancerre or dry Muscadet.

  3. Lauralee Hensley says:

    I could definitely see our family eating these, along with a nice mug or bowl of tomato soup.

  4. RisaG says:

    That does sound like a lot of cheese. I can’t get Fromage Blanc locally. What could I substitute for it? I adore a good grilled cheese.

    • Renee Schettler Rossi, LC Editor-in-Chief says:

      It IS a lot of cheese, RisaG, though intentionally so. There’s not an exact stand-in for this ingredient, and honestly, if you’re worried about there being too much fromage, you could probably leave it out. The result would be melty, not quite so creamy. That said, a schmear of fresh goat cheese would be quite lovely in its place and lend the sandwich a slight tang to sort of offset all the richness. Let us know what you decide…

Have something to say?

Then tell us. Have a picture you'd like to add to your comment? Send it along. Covet one of those spiffy pictures of yourself to go along with your comment? Get a free Gravatar. And as always, please take a gander at our comment policy before posting.

*

Daily Subscription

Enter your email address and get all of our updates sent to your inbox the moment they're posted. Be the first on your block to be in the know.

Preview daily e-mail

Weekly Subscription

Hate tons of emails? Do you prefer info delivered in a neat, easy-to-digest (pun intended) form? Then enter your email address for our weekly newsletter.

Preview weekly e-mail