This pumpkin macaroni and cheese is easy and creamy and rich. What else would you expect from a skillet full of pasta, Cheddar, pumpkin, bacon, and sage? Comfort food at its most indulgent with a smidgen of conscience-appeasing healthfulness.
Each autumn, it goes something like this in our house:
“Hey, The One. What do you want for dinner?”
“What about lunch?
“Dessert? Let me guess: Something pumpkin.”
I can’t win with this man. But I have gotten good at serving him all kinds of pumpkin dishes: Pumpkin Soup, Braised Short Ribs with Pumpkin Orzo, Pumpkin and Sage Pasta Hats, and my famous Pumpkin Cake With Maple-Cream Cheese Frosting.
This year, though, I wanted to surprise him with something different. I had exhausted just about every pumpkin recipe on this site, and then it hit me: This man is a massive cheese ball. (I mean this in the very best way possible.) He loves cheese. On top of that, he literally, truly says, at least once a week, “I could eat pasta every day.” So I did a little math.
Cheese + pasta + pumpkin = pumpkin macaroni and cheese.
No, it wasn’t a huge leap, but it was a huge ass success. He loved the creaminess and the subtle-but-not-too-subtle pumpkin flavor that doesn’t distract from the sharp Cheddar cheese. And as he was shoveling forkfuls of the stuff into his mouth, he kept asking, “What’s that tang?” Then he’d cluck his tongue trying to guess it. (I knew he’d never figure it out. It’s cider vinegar. Just enough to brighten the flavor and complement the cheese.)
And since it’s near Thanksgiving and everyone will be wondering, What in the hell am I going to do with all this leftover turkey? I have just one answer: Bury chunks of it in this dish. And then make The One proud and serve a chocolate dessert afterward.
Pumpkin Macaroni and Cheese
When it comes to this pumpkin macaroni and cheese recipe, or any mac and cheese recipe, call me wild and crazy, but I prefer unusual pasta shapes. Yes, yes you can go with old school elbow mac that we all had as kids in this pumpkin macaroni and cheese, but I say go a little wild. Several pasta shapes that are relatively easy to find that I like include gemelli, campanelle, caserecce, and cellentani. Will this pumpkin macaroni and cheese recipe succeed or fail because of your pasta shape? No. Will your choice of a snazzy shape dress it up a bit? Absolutely.–David Leite
Pumpkin Macaroni and Cheese
- Kosher salt
- 1 pound cavatappi elbow macaroni, or small pasta shells
- 5 tablespoons unsalted butter plus more if needed
- 1/2 cup panko or fresh bread crumbs
- 8 ounces bacon preferably maple cured, roughly chopped
- 1 medium onion halved through the root and then cut into half moons
- 2 garlic cloves sliced
- 15 sage leaves roughly chopped
- 1/4 cup all-purpose flour
- 1 1/2 cups whole milk
- 2 cups heavy cream
- 2 1/2 cups shredded sharp Cheddar cheese
- One can solid-packed pumpkin
- 2 tablespoons (30 milliliters) apple cider vinegar
- 1 tablespoon thyme leaves
- 1/8 teaspoon freshly grated nutmeg
- Freshly ground black pepper
- Preheat the oven to 350°F (177°C) and adjust the oven rack to the middle position.
- Bring a large pot of water to a boil and toss in 3 tablespoons salt.
- While the water is coming to a boil, melt 1 tablespoon butter in a 12-inch cast-iron skillet over medium to medium-high heat and stir in the panko. Season with salt and pepper and cook, stirring, until the panko are coated with butter. Scrape the panko into a bowl.
- In the same skillet over medium heat, fry the bacon until crisp yet still chewy, 5 to 10 minutes. Transfer the bacon to paper towels or a brown paper bag to drain.
- If there’s enough fat in the skillet to cook the onion, great. If not, add a tablespoon or two of butter to the bacon drippings. Cook the onion over low heat, stirring often, until softened and golden, about 20 minutes.
- Add the garlic and cook for 3 minutes more. Scrape the mixture into a bowl.
- Meanwhile, dump the pasta in the boiling water. Give it a stir to prevent it from sticking and cook it for 2 minutes less than specified on the package. (Trust us. The pasta will continue to cook in the oven.)
- While the pasta cooks, melt the remaining 4 tablespoons butter in the skillet over medium heat, add the sage, and let sizzle for 1 minute.
- Dump in the flour and whisk constantly for 1 minute. Raise the heat to medium-high and slowly pour in the milk, still whisking continually. Repeat with the cream. Whisk in 2 cups cheese until it melts.
- Drain the pasta and dump it into the skillet and stir to combine. (Alternately, you could dump everything in a 9-by-13-inch baking dish.) Top with the remaining 1/2 cup cheese and then sprinkle with the buttered panko. Bake in the oven until bubbling and the panko is lightly browned, 25 to 30 minutes.
- Let the pumpkin macaroni and cheese rest for about 10 minutes and then bring it to the table and scoop it straight from the skillet.
What You Need To Know About Reheating This Pumpkin Macaroni And CheeseThis pumpkin macaroni and cheese recipe makes A LOT of macaroni and cheese. As in, ample. Enough for leftovers, even. This simple fact is epic because, like all casseroles, this dish actually improves with age—but only if you reheat it with care. Shy away from the temptation to plop it in the microwave as the fats in the sauce separate and all manner of nasty greasiness will ensue. Instead, cover the dish of macaroni and cheese and slide it in a warm oven or scoop the macaroni and cheese into the top of a double boiler and gently heat until it’s warmed through. If your leftover pumpkin macaroni and cheese seems a touch on the dry side as you warm it, just stir in a little whole milk.
Recipe Testers’ Reviews
This pumpkin macaroni and cheese recipe is amazing. The addition of pumpkin gives such a warmth to the macaroni and cheese although it doesn’t taste like “pumpkin. So don’t think sweet. Think a rich, cheesy sauce with a beautiful, deep orange squash-like taste wrapped around little pasta shells.
This dish is a little time consuming. The cheeses I used were extra-sharp Cheddar and a little sharp white Cheddar—a favorite combination of mine. After adding it to the flour and milk mixture, it created a lovely cheese sauce that looked amazing. The pumpkin rounded out the creaminess and mixed perfectly with the cheese sauce. The It was bubbly and looked great! The final outcome was a beautiful creamy macaroni and cheese with a wonderful hint of pumpkin. Again, don’t think of sweet pumpkin.
This an amazing recipe and you really should try it!
This is wonderful cold weather comfort food at its best. That’s the short and sweet review for this recipe. There is nothing I would change here. Other than the lovely flavor and texture, I loved the weight measures, even for the onion!
The sauce had a very nice consistency. It was thick and creamy and coated the elbow macaroni perfectly. Out of the oven it is perfectly cooked with a bubbly sauce and great texture. The flavors work so good with a great balance of sharp cheese (I used a mixture of Cheddar and Gruyère that I had on hand), caramelized sweet onions, and herbs, all rounded out by a touch of cider vinegar.
This can easily serve 8 as a main or even up to 12 as a smallish side dish.
This pumpkin macaroni and cheese recipe was so good that we all had second helpings. The flavor was very good. The texture was creamy, even though the pan went into the oven uncovered. The panko provided a nice crunch.
The sauce was very thick but held itʻs own in the oven—that is, the whole casserole remained moist. I used a 13-by-9-by-2-inch pan. I think this was very involved for macaroni and cheese. I think Iʻd look for ways to simplify the recipe somehow. I might also look for ways to cut some fat and still retain the flavor and texture.
This pumpkin macaroni and cheese recipe makes a sophisticated version of a classic macaroni and cheese that’s well worth the extra effort. Fall flavors of pumpkin, sage, and thyme complement the cheese and tender pasta, and the panko made a light, crisp, buttery topping. The sage and thyme come through very well in the sauce.
The bacon produced a lot of drippings so there was no need to add any additional butter to the pan for the onions. In fact, there were enough drippings after cooking the onions and garlic that I could have substituted that for 2 tablespoons the butter in the roux. The sauce, once made, was quite thick. When I make this dish again, I might decrease the amount of cream to match the milk. The sauce, while delicious was a little heavy, for my personal taste. Also, I would use all the bacon in the package as there were only 3 slices left. Things can always use more bacon, right?
Other than a couple minor tweaks for personal preference, this is a lovely recipe as written.
Oh my. I’m not a fan of overly cheesy mac and cheese, but this pumpkin mac and cheese is fabulous. It’s rich but not heavy and the pumpkin and sage really give it a great depth of flavor. My sauce was a lovely, smooth consistency. The finished product was very creamy. It’s really rich. We served it as a side dish with smoked roasted chicken.
I used elbow macaroni but next time I would use small shells. I actually used 2 different pans—one for the panko, sage sauce, and the rest of the macaroni and cheese and another for the bacon and the onion. Felt like a lot of dishes but it was a lot cleaner.
Originally published November 10, 2019
What You Need To Know About Reheating This Pumpkin Macaroni and Cheese
This pumpkin macaroni and cheese recipe makes A LOT of macaroni and cheese. As in, ample. Enough for leftovers, even. This simple fact is epic because, like all casseroles, this dish actually improves with age—but only if you reheat it with care. Shy away from the temptation to plop it in the microwave as the fats in the sauce separate and all manner of nasty greasiness will ensue. Instead, cover the dish of macaroni and cheese and slide it in a warm oven or scoop the macaroni and cheese into the top of a double boiler and gently heat until it’s warmed through. If your leftover pumpkin macaroni and cheese seems a touch on the dry side as you warm it, just stir in a little whole milk.