This pastéis de nata recipe makes as-close-to-authentic Portuguese custard tarts with a rich egg custard nestled in shatteringly crisp pastry. Tastes like home, even if you’re not from Portugal.
These Portuguese custard tarts are facsimiles of the true pastéis de Belém pastries from the Antiga Confeitaria de Belém (below), where they churn out more than 22,000 pastries each day. When you make that many a day, you get damn good at it. There are all kinds of reasons why the original pastéis de nata from this pastry shop are so freaking good. Secret recipes, teams of folks who do nothing but make the pastry dough or whip up the filling, ovens that blast at 800°F.
In order to translate the pastéis to the home kitchen and to ovens that that hit 500°F if you’re lucky, these pastéis are smaller than the original. and the tops may not brown quite as much as the authentic pastéis in the picture, which are from the confeitaria. Still, that hasn’t stopped the flood of rave reviews below. The secrets to making spectacular authentic Portuguese custard tarts at home are few and simple.
When making the pastry, make sure the butter is evenly layered, all excess flour is removed, and the dough is rolled very thin and folded neatly. As for the custard, you’ll need a thermometer to accurately gauge the custard. These are best eaten warm the day they’re made. Originally published June 26, 2004.–David Leite
A Little Visual Aid
The tremendously delightful and charming London pastry queen Cupcake Jemma uses my recipe to maker delicious Portuguese custard tarts.
Video: How to Make Pastéis de Nata
Video courtesy of Cupcake JemmaPastéis de Nata | Portuguese Custard Tarts
Special Equipment: Mini-muffin tin with 2-by-5/8-inch (50-by-15-mm) wells; If you prefer the classic larger tins from Portugal, you can purchase them at Portugalia Marketplace.
Ingredients
Email Grocery List- For the pasteis de nata dough
- For the custard
- For the garnish
Directions
Make pastéis with these classic forms
These are authentic Portuguese queijada forms traditionally used to make the famous Portuguese pastel de nata. The forms are made of sturdy aluminum for durability. Made in Portugal.
Dimensions: Each form is approximately 2.50 inches wide x 1 inch in height.
Package Contains: 12 Forms
12-pack pastel de nata forms, $20 on Portugalia Marketplace
Recipe Testers Reviews
According to my Portuguese dad, I can make these pasteis de Nata again and again and again! I am pretty chuffed with how they turned out since I had doubts throughout the entire process of making these traditional tarts. First of all, Pasteis de Nata are the epitome of the classic Portuguese sweet treat. So no pressure!
In following the recipe, when mixing the flour, salt and water in the stand mixer, my dough never achieved the soft pillowy stage I was hoping for or rather thinking what is would be. My dough did pull away from the sides slightly, but remained sticky, hence I feel I should have added more flour which I didn't at this stage. Doubt started to set-in! When working with the dough on the work surface, I needed to add a very generous amount of flour to stop the dough from sticking. At this stage I probably added so much flour that I actually increased the amount of flour added to the dough significantly.
I found working with the dough a test of extreme patience! I remained calm (yet doubtful) and just kept working with it gently. I was never able to achieve the 18-by-18-inch square, no matter how hard I tried. It was closer to 14 inches. The custard seemed quite thin and even though the recipe mentioned it would be so I had my doubts it would firm up into a creamy custard. While the tarts baked, the butter bubbled and oozed out of the dough and over the edge of the minis tin causing lots of smoke in the extremely hot oven. I baked the minis for 9 minutes and the custard was set and the pastry was golden brown. I expected the custard to have a brown speckled appearance (like the ones you buy commercially), but it remained an eggy yellow. For the larger tins, I baked the tarts for 15 minutes and they too remained an eggy yellow with a golden brown pasty.
To my surprise, the pastry was super flaky and crispy and it had that perfect crackly crunch that is the true mark of a great pasteis de Nata! And the custard? It set and was creamy, sweet, and deliciously perfect.
When my Portuguese mom said they tasted just like the pasteis de Belem (the most famous and original Portuguese Custard Tarts), then I knew we had a winner! Talk about the best compliment ever! It was quite a bit of work to produce these little gems, but the end result was definitely worth the effort!
HUNGRY FOR MORE?
If you make this recipe, snap a photo and hashtag it #LeitesCulinaria. We'd love to see your creations on Instagram, Facebook, and Twitter.
Hi David,
Thank you so much for the recipe! I’ve made this a few times now and everyone loves it.
I just wanted to ask, if I prepare the custard a day ahead, do I need to take it out of the fridge and to get it at room temperature before I bake it?
Thank you,
Lillian
Lilian, I do. Especially if I’m making the smaller version, which I really do these days.
Thank you for that. I also have another question. My oven only goes up to 250°C. So I found that in order to get it to slightly brown on top I need to bake it for at least 20 minutes in a standard muffin tin. I’ve noticed that after the custard starts to cool it deflates a lot and goes wrinkly. My question is, does it deflate and go wrinkly because the custard is over baked? Do you know why this happens? Please let me know as I’d like to get the custard to look smooth and shiny. Would my oven be hotter if I use 250°C fan forced? Do you know if I can bake these at 250°C fan-forced with less time? Thanks for your help!
Lilian, you’re most welcome. You want to have that wrinkly surface! If you look at the second photo on the recipe, that’s taken at the famous Confeitaria de Belem in Portugal. They’re wonderfully wrinkly. If you have a convection oven, you absolutely can use it. You would cook it less time or at slightly less temperature.
I wanted to try this recipe as I’ve eaten shop-bought tarts which were delicious but knew making your own tends to be soooo much better. I was really pleased with my first try at these. I don’t really ‘do’ pastry as such but found this recipe very helpful. I was thrilled with how the pastry turned out. The disappointment for me was the custard. I found it too sweet for both mine and my husband’s sweet tooth. I also found that after cooking, the custard seemed to have split? There was a sticky glaze over the top of the tart so not sure if I did anything wrong?
Helen, congratulations! These little creatures are not easy to make. As to the custard, it should have a sheen to it and yours look perfect. If there is a goopy stickiness on top then that’s not correct.
As far as the custard splitting, I don’t see where that’s happening? Do you mean inside?
For the custard
27 g all-purpose flour for 44 pieces?
George, yes. That just helps thicken the custard and stabilize it Remember there are 6 egg yolks that thicken it, too.
Hi David, I’d just like to say that Im a novice baker who attempted this with no stand mixer, folding went totally wrong (I almost threw all the pastry away in frustration as it stuck everywhere) no thermometer and an oven that only goes up to 275 degrees c. Still turned out pretty damn good. Will improve on the folding technique and make this again. Thank you so much for sharing.
Amanda, I would say they are indeed damn-fine pastries! Congratulations!
Hi David, thanks so much I made some today and they are delicious. Like others my oven only goes up to 250, but seemed to work well enough. I found Cupcake Jemma’s tutorial really helpful too (I’m a visual person!)
Bea, you are more than welcome! Those look fabulous.
Thanks for the recipe, I found the pastry really tricky but am happy with the end result!
Mel, you are more than welcome. I’m working on another version of this recipe that in some ways is far easier and I think closer to the original.
this recipe is excellent! this was my first attempt, and i think it went well. i had a lot of doubts, my oven only goes up to 250 and i thought i failed at the pastry but i kept going and it turned out ok! quite flaky and you could even the spiral in the bottom, i will definitely make again!! they are so tasty.
Florence, those look awesome!!!
Hi! I don’t have normal milk – do you think almond milk would work for the custard?
hanna, no, I don’t think that would work. So sorry…
I went out and got the milk – they turned out great!! Thank you for the recipe :)
Superb, Hanna!
made these several times! i find the more butter you put in the pastry the taster it turns out.
Wonderful, Emma!
Sounds amazing! Is there a way to make them ahead of time including the custard and just bake them fresh as needed?
And how big should the squares be for a cupcake size?
Suzanne, yes. you can make the custard and the dough and keep them in the fridge. As to using a full-size muffin tin, I’m not sure. I’m guessing here, but 1 3/4 inch? Try one and see it if fits.
I only had semi-skimmed milk, not whole. The custard seemed a little thin to me, thinner than I was expecting, maybe whole milk would have made a difference. My own only goes upto 250c and they seemed to cook pretty fast. I checked on them quite soon after I put them in, they were actually bubbling and sligtly browning. My fears were realised and the custard seems sort of lumpy or split. Any idea why baking custard sometimes splits it?
These taste really good. I admit I used my own rough puff pastry which involves folding but with grated frozen butter.
Any help on why my custard split will be very much appreciated
Nina, the extra fat in the milk would help it. Also, do you have an oven thermometer? If your oven is running hot, it can cause the custard to curdle. One thing to realize is the custard won’t be smooth like a panna cotta or crême brulée. Those are cooked at a lower temperature and using a bain Marie. That being said, they look fantastic.
Thank you David! Yes, I think you’re right and I am going to give them another go this week. I have baked custard before, in a bain Marie and yes – makes sense that would be smooth. I am going to try these again this week. Do you have any advice on making them a touch less sweet? If it was to reduce the sugar by a quarter, would it make a difference to the success of the recipe sweetness aside?
I am going to check my oven temp!
Hello, Nina. I’m working on a version that’s less sweet. Yes, you can try to reduce the sugar by a quarter; others have done it successfully. And less sugar and it could affect the chemistry.
I am absolutely love this recipe. It is delicious.
Only problem I am having is that my filling is bubbling over and causing the pastry to stick to the tin and burn. I have tried filling them less but they still seem to bubble over. Do you have any tips?
Claudia, try filling them even less. The baked custard should be below the rim of the pastry; yours are domed above, which means too much filling.
Hello!
When making the tarts today, the pastry curled in on itself causing the custard to spill over and the shape was just very wrong. I tried multiple times but every time, the pastry pulled away from the sides and curled in. Please help!
Vista, it’s really hard to give an answer without seeing a picture or being there. You might not be pulling the dough up high enough. Is your pan nonstick? Are you making the mini version or regular size?
I am making the regular size ones. I used a nonstick pan and I tried pulling the dough up to several different heights (up to 1/2 inch above). Could the nonstick pan cause the curling in? Hopefully, you can see in this photo what I am referring to. The pastry pulls away from the pan, and falls into the centre.
Vista, I can see that, yes. Two things might be going on: 1.) The pan. It might just be…TOO nonstick. 2.) You might be excessively pulling the dough when shaping. Try another tin–regular (not nonstick) and once you have shaped the shells, put the tin in the fridge for 20 minutes.
What happened? Please help.
Thank you in advance
Sadness, they don’t look too bad at all! Don’t be hard on yourself. What I see is that you didn’t bring the pastry high enough up over the lip of the tins. That can help prevent the custard from flowing over.
Hi! Can we make this recipe without a stand mixer?
Chia, sure. It just means using a lot of muscle to make the dough.
Hi David,
Found your recipe last year and always wanted to make these Pasteis. I live in Australia, my mother lives in Lisbon and with these travel restrictions I thought I’d make them as an ‘across the world’s connection. They came out perfectly and taste as good as Pasteis de Belem. Many thanks
Dominic, I’m delighted you enjoyed the recipe. And I’m glad you can make that connection back to Lisbon. One suggestion: The sides of the pastry seem very dark. Consider placing a thin baking sheet two racks below the rack on which you bake the pastries. That will keep the undersides a little lighter.
I’m midway through cooking these and have realised I don’t have a sugar thermometer. Any suggestions on how I can ensure the sugar syrup reaches 100c? Thanks!
Will, I gather you’re probably already done with these. If not, you’ll need to follow the directions/cues for what’s called the thread stage of candy making. You can determine the thread stage by dropping a spoonful of the sugar syrup into a cup of cold water. If the syrup drips from the spoon and forms thin threads in cold water, you’re set.
Thanks David! I actually decided to hold fire (pastry stage completed, hadn’t started custard yet) as I managed to get a thermometer on Amazon that will be delivered later. Cheers
They were worth the wait and tasted amazing! Thanks David!
Will, excellent!! How did you get the elusive brown on top?
It seems my oven is more powerful than I realised!
Ha!
Wonderful, will!
Hello, I’m really excited to try out this recipe! However, I noticed that my oven doesn’t heat up to 290°C :( will it be okay if i bake at 250°C?
Chiara, that’s low. You definitely want it above at least 260°C.
Hi David, I have been craving these for ages and finally made my first attempt (because the muffin tray took ages to be delivered)! Thank you for the recipe, I’ve halved the amount, used slightly above 480°F (250°C), top 1/3 of a convection oven, and a muffin tray for about 16 mins. I was amazed by the result, but here are some of my reflections/questions:
– I’ve cut the sugar by 1/4, still, a tad too sweet > < would further cut on sugar affect the custard's texture drastically?
– I’ve never made laminated dough before, but these came out rather crispy (bordering on crunchy), rather than flaky. I could see butter bubbling all over the pastry and around the filling in the oven, even though I actually didn't use up all the butter required, it almost felt like the pastries were getting deep-fried in there. They were very tasty, but just wondering if the dough was supposed to act and taste like this? or did I do something wrong? I might have accidentally rolled the dough thinner than in the video (which also made the dough more vulnerable to tears when rolling and turning), would that have made the difference?
– very important to let the tarts hang out to cool! burning my mouth was worth it, but letting it rest helps the custard set;)
Ellie, so glad you liked them! Cutting the sugar any more will affect the chemistry. It will take longer to get to the right temperature for the custard, and too much water will evaporate.
Making the dough is very hard, and I applaud you for doing it! Just to give you an idea of how they make this in the shop in Belém: The 1-inch log that you end up with begins life the size of a tree trunk that’s more than a foot in diameter! It’s pulled and pulled and pulled until it’s 1-inch in diameter. So there are a gazillion more layer than we can make at home. That’s part of the issue.
This recipe tries to hew as closely as possible to the original technique. Now you can make a French laminated dough, roll it up, and tug and tug until it’s1-inch in diameter. It’s not “authentic,” but I won’t tell if you won’t!
Hi David!
I really really wanna try out this recipe but I don’t have cinnamon sticks. I only have ground cinnamon. Can i use that as substitute?
Mikee, you sure can. A few taps–not much–is all you need.
Thank you so much for this recipe David! They are absolutely amazing! My oven only goes up to 450F so i baked them for a few extra minutes. Baked this right in time for mother’s day and my mom loved them! Thank you!! :)
Mikee, they look amazing! And please pass on my Mother’s Day wish to your mom. (Lucky her for having such a great treat!)
Hi i just wanted to aske before making, it says on the recipe that it makes about 40 but in the video the same measurements are for 24? just wanted to clarify this as ill be making it this weekend :)
Krupi, in the video, she uses larger muffin tins. The recipe calls for mini tins. You can use either.
These turned out really good. I cooked them for 17 mins at 525°F because my oven doesn’t go higher than that.
Utah, that is excellent!
Thanks for sharing this amazing recipe. These are pretty much the most delicious things I have ever tasted.
And Rick, that is a damn fine photo!! congrats.
Thank you for sharing this recipe. I am surprised at how easy these are to make. I will definitely be making these again! YUM!
I’m going to try this recipe next, but I’ve been using a slightly different one I had originally found in my previous (failed) attempts. I can never get the dough to roll out nicely a second time after buttering and folding. Maybe I’m just not pressing out the air bubbles well enough, but whenever I start rolling that second time, the edges where I’ve folded the dough over always burst, pushing butter everywhere and causing my dough to become a sloppy mess. Any tips for that step in the process? Thanks
Billy, you want to make sure that you’re not using too much of the butter. And make sure that the butter is evenly spread.
Thanks so much for the recipe! They’ve become quite popular in my household.
However, my dough never turns out right. It often burns at the top, and it doesn’t get as fluffy and flaky as puff pastry should. I find it difficult to do the lamination process because the dough is so sticky. Any tips for how to improve this? Thank you!
Laura, you are more than welcome. As far as tips to making the dough less sticky, make sure to use a fine coating of flour. Granted, it is a tough dough to work with. The puffiness has to do with the even application of the butter and properly folding. As far as the burning, how much above the lip of the pan is the dough? And how close to the heating element is the pan?
These are the best part of quarantine. Thank you for bringing Porto back into my life.
Lynn, my pleasure. I know how we all can have even more saudades de Portugal in quarantine!
How easy would it be to make the pastry manually, I don’t have a dough hook?
Vic, not a problem. Cooks 300 years didn’t have a dough hook either!
Thank you for the recipe. Of all I’ve seen, this seems the most authentic so I’m going to make these tonight with my daughter. Getting fat during lockdown!
Kelley, I hope you and your daughter like them!
Hi David, would using corn starch as opposed to flour make the custard more creamy?
Tania, no, it wouldn’t make it creamier. They act the same in the recipe.
I made this and the finished product had more of a puffy look than the glazed look in your pictures. Any tips? Thanks!
Laurn, do you have any pictures? Did the puff go down?
Yes i do! the puffiness went down but they did not look glossy.
Laurn, honestly, they look perfectly fine! Did you store the filling at all before using?
This was very helpful!!! I’m so happy that I finally found the recipe. Thanks, love x
Afnan, you’re more than welcome!
A great recipe, thank you! A lot of effort (and mess) but a very nice *sometimes* treat :-)
A coeliac friend was wondering about making them gluten-free. Do you suppose they’d go ok with a GF flour blend for the pastry, and a cornflour in the custard?
Rebecca, I’m delighted you enjoyed them!! We’ve not made them using gluten-free flour, so I can’t assure you 100%. But there are some pretty impressive 1:1 GF blends these days. I do think you can use cornflour (cornstarch) for the filling.
hi, I ran out of vanilla extract, is it possible to do without? :(
kathryn, sure! Desperate times call for desperate measures!
Hi there, I made your Pasteis de Nata this afternoon, they were terrific but we found they’re a little too sweet. How can I reduce the sugar without spoiling the consistency and texture of the tarts? I know if I reduce the sugar, the syrup won’t be the same and will reach 100C far quicker. Thought you might have an idea. Thank you.
Kindest regards,
Maricha
maricha, I’m delighted you enjoyed the pastéis. They are a bit sweet. Some of the commenters reduced the sugar by 1/4 without any problem. Do let me know how they turn out!
I have been wanting to make pasteis de nata since my trip to Portugal in the Fall, but thought it would be too complicated to make them. I was pleasantly surprised. These are HEAVENLY!! Thank you so much for this recipe. The video was very useful! I added an extra tablespoon of water to the dough because it was a bit thick. Otherwise, I followed the recipe as is. This recipe is a keeper for sure! 👏😍
Lic, you’re more than welcome! I’m thrilled you decided to try the recipe.
Any recommendations for storing them? I know they are better the same day, but I can’t eat all of them in one day. Haha.
Luc, what? You can’t eat all of them in one sitting? What’s wrong with you?!! 😉 To revive them, place them in a 300°F oven to warm them. Don’t put them in the microwave, as it will nuke them and change the texture of the custard.
Soooooo Good!!! My avo said they were better than her recipe, which is saying a lot since she has been making pasteis de nata for decades.
A taste of Portugal :)
Wow, Santana! Such a compliment. Please thank you avo for me!
Hi, David, after the dough is made and stayed in the freezer for a few hours, can I shape the dough into the tins and then freeze them (without the custard of course)? I am trying to minimize the process on the day of the actual baking. I am little scared to try them because of the high temperature required. But have invested in the special custard tart mold and made the dough, so no turning back.
tanya, we’ve never tested it that way, but I believe you can. Wrap them tightly. I would use them within a few days of freezing. Also, make sure they’re defrosted to room temp before baking.
hi there. Quick question – why do you place slices of the rolled-up pastry into the muffin pan, and then squash it flat – why not simply unroll the pastry and cut rounds and put into the cups? what will the difference be?
nadena, if you cut rounds you’ll have just a few layers. By rolling it and carefully, pushing your thumbs in the middle and running them up the sides, you have hundreds of layers. It makes it more crispy.
I am so happy to have the recipe. I will definitely try is soon.
Let me know what you think, bilinmeyen!
I tried similar custard tarts at Carousel Bakery in Toronto’s St. Lawrence Market last January and I’ve had major cravings since. A few weeks ago I just tried to search for a recipe and these popped up, and I’m so happy I gave it a chance!
I knew I was getting myself into a project but it paid off. I would recommend becoming familiar with the recipe and instructions, and also watching the video by Cupcake Jemma to get a feel for the steps, just so you know how things should look like.
I split the recipe to make on two different occasions. I froze one log, and defrosted it overnight in the fridge when I needed it (and made a fresh half batch of custard accordingly). On the first attempt I made 12 one-inch pieces to go in a standard size muffin tin. I was left with 3 empty shells as my math was likely off and I probably overfilled the others. The ones that did get filled with custard were delicious, nonetheless!
The second time around I used the standard muffin tins again, but I only rolled the log enough so that I had just a bit more than enough to cut 10 equal one-inch pieces. This was much better and easier to flatten the dough in the tins as there was more of it. I only filled each pastry half way with custard which was enough for all 10. As they baked, the exposed parts of the pastry shrunk down and settled in the perfect place to meet the custard.
This was one of the more difficult things I’ve made but just so incredibly amazing. My family absolutely loved them. They have the perfect balance of warm custard and flaky pastry. It is a little time consuming, especially if you’re like me and need to check and recheck the steps to make sure you’re doing it right. Just follow the directions as they are written, trust the process and yourself (even if the smoke detector goes off, haha). Breathe and it will work out. I would highly suggest this as a weekend baking project if you want to challenge yourself!
Navroop, this may have been your first time making these, but they’re killer looking! I think you need to teach me a few of your moves. Gorgeous!
You are too kind David, thank you! This recipe is going up there as one of my all time favourites!
De nada, Navroop.
Wow, an excellent report on this delicious treat and useful comments too.
I recently consumed dozens of these delights while holiday making in Cape Town. I hope to test out your recipe as soon as i get home.
I hope you like it, Ludweed.
First time making these gems, they are fabulous. I don’t think the oven was hot enough as I didn’t get the coloring on the top, Plus the custard seemed to recess into the pastry somewhat. I will make more today and try less time and using the broiler for a minute or two. Your instructions were perfect.
Huzzah, huzzah Wendy! I’m so happy you enjoyed the recipe. Let us know how batch two turns out.
Quick question- does the amount of butter needed 2 sticks of 8 oz (= 16 oz total
) or just 8 oz of butter? The recipe calls for 2 sticks of unsalted butter (8 oz), but 1 stick of butter is usually 8 oz.
Thank you!
Jennie
Hi Jennie, and thank you for asking! Where we are, in the US, sticks of butter are 4 ounces each. And so the parenthetical, as you read it, is for the total amount. We understand it can be confusing and appreciate you clarifying!
Excellent recipe! This is my first attempt at making puff pastry and it was a huge mess with butter all over the place. But it tastes yummy despite the appearance haha although I would cut back on the sugar the next time. Thanks for sharing the recipe!
Liam, these are OUTRAGEOUSLY beautiful! Congratulations. It’s not an easy recipe. And it’s funny–I had already cut back on the amount of sugar. We Portuguese have big sweet tooths!
Hi David. I am Portuguese and living in the Netherlands. We will have this international breakfast and I was kind of challenged to make this wonderful. After some searching, I decided to give this recipe a try. Could only work with the dough with 300g flour and 210g water. After baking the crust is absolutely amazing! Tried the filling twice, to cut the sugar by 1/4 – flavour is even better in my opinion. I still have two things I want to improve:
[1] While baking, the butter in the crust starts bubbling and one of the sides get burned;
[2] The filling is awesome inside, but on top I still think it kinds of “talha,” so it does become as smooth as I would like.
My oven only gets up to 225C and has only 3 positions. I baked them on the top position, with the fan not working. I am also using a normal size muffins tin and cooked them for 12min + 3 min with the broiler.
I researched a bit and I’ve done several trials on timing using only 2 pastéis: from 12 to 17 and they all come out the same, in terms of filling. I think it is because the muffin tin is too close to the source of heat, so the filling top gets overcooked.
Any proposal on how to improve these two topics? Thank you so much for the amazing recipe!
Ana, so glad you like these! It may sound nutty, but flours from various countries are different. So the flour-water ratio is always different.
1. Do you mean the same side on all of the pastéis burn? If so, that’s an oven with uneven heating and/or hot spot.
2. I’m not familiar with the term talha. What is it?
I’m looking for some advice. I set my oven as high as it would go (500F+) and baked in the top third of the oven. I used grey-ish metal regular-sized muffin tins. at 15min, the crusts were burned fairly badly and the custard did not brown. I tried lowering the heat for the next batch to 475F. Crusts were better but then the custard did not set properly. I was starting to think there was something wrong with the custard recipe having too much liquid but none of the other commenters reported this. What is the likely culprit? Do I need more egg yolk (i.e. bigger eggs)?
Edwin, what size tins are you using–mini or regular size? What size eggs are you using?
Regular-sized muffin tins. The eggs are large to extra-large. Sorry I don’t have a weight to be more specific. The recipe says “generous 1in pieces” for the crusts of regular muffin pans but I found with this size didn’t fill the whole cup. Either my pan is somehow deeper than “normal” or I’m making the crusts far too thick. I expect if I made the crusts thinner the burning would be worse right?
Edwin, the instructions to cut a generous 1-inch is for the mini pans. You would need more for the standard muffin tins. That might help the burning. If you’re using extra-large eggs, you might be adding up to too much liquid. Another thought: Try letting the filling come to room temperature before using it. Lastly, do you have oven thermometers? Your oven might be running too hot, which could cause the burning.
Bom Dia David:
I am a first-generation American of Portuguese descent. My father came from a very small village near Carragal do Sal, not far from Coimbra. I have used your recipe for the Natas from your New Portuguese table. I used the frozen puff pastry recommended in the recipe but had difficulty fitting the dough into the Nata cups, even with wet fingers.
I remember seeing a video of the dough at Antiga Confeiteria de Belem and their dough was just sitting there in a big blob with the workers easily cutting off pieces and fitting them into the cups [the dough appears very soft and pliable]. I am sure that the recipe for the dough is a state secret, but perhaps with your expertise, you could come up with something close to it. It is difficult for me as I have arthritis in my hands, so the softer the dough the better.
I just discovered this recipe which is different from the book and I might give it a try.
I have used your book many times and find the recipes easy to follow, but I need to find a way to make the dough as they have at Antiga Confeiteria de Belem.
You can help make that happen.
Obrigado.
Joe, the Confeitaria uses a special baking fat that’s similar to margarine so it’s stable at room temperature. You can try margarine, but I would place the muffin tin in the fridge after living with the pastry and before filling it, otherwise, I fear the pastry will slump down the sides.
Hi David,
Love the recipe, and even more love how enthusiastically you reply to everybody. Here are my efforts. Pretty happy overall although the pastry was quite brown in the outside and underbaked inside. Maybe too thick? I put them back in for 5 mins but think that just made the outside browner. I still ate three before letting them cool at all (yes, I badly burnt my mouth)
Look forward to trying them again.
Ed
Ed, oooow! Mouth burn sucks! Glad you like the recipe. My guess regarding the dark crust is a.) the dough was too thick, and b.) you used a dark pan.
I made this recipe and although the tarts were absolutely delicious, the custard curdled slightly.I don’t have a non-contact instant-read thermometer, but the bases of the tarts were pale and not cooked like the sides.
I’m determined to do these again and get them right. I’ll post another picture when I do them again; I’ve eaten all of the others already!!
Patrick, it sounds like your oven isn’t hot enough. You can purchase inexpensive oven thermometers (I use 4 at a time) to make sure your oven’s correct. Keep at it, though. They’re worth it!
Hi David, I’m going to try again. I did use my pizza stone in the oven to try and get some heat radiating upwards to cook the bases quicker than my first attempt. The one oven thermometer that I do have read 550F when I put them in, although my oven is terrible! (live in a rental with very old fan oven)
Patrick, one thing you can do is blast the oven with your broiler so that the baking stone gets very hot. Then turn the heat down and slide in the pastries.
This recipe is so incredibly good. You have to do just what the recipe says (not my strong suit) and follow it on blind faith, because it sure doesn’t seem like it’s going to turn out while you’re in process, but once it’s done they’re brilliant. And your kitchen is full of smoke. But it’s worth it.
Excellent, Helen! I’m delighted you enjoyed it. (Smoke and all!)
I’m wanting to try this in my commercial wood fired pizza oven. Any tips before I give it a go? I usually keep it at 650 – 700 degrees but can reach 900.
Wow, Danielle!! Wow. I can’t say for sure, as this recipe was developed for the home oven. But a few things come to mind: 1.) Watch carefully. 2.) Use a regular muffin-size tin. Mini-tarts, which this recipe calls for, would be incinerated!
I’m stumped as to what happened. The tarts turned out well, taste wise, but the filling all deflated, and each tart looks empty. While they were baking in the oven, they looks good and had puffed up nicely with only a little spillover, but nothing unexpected. As they cooled, the custard deflated to the point where each tart looked like the filling had fallen out.
Any thoughts?
Rick, it looks as if there was some spillover or adhering to the sides and lip, which is unusual. What was your oven temp?
My oven would only let me go up to 425. I also baked them in the middle of the oven.
=R=
Rick, that could be the culprit. The temp was lower than required, and the custard got hot but didn’t set properly. A possible workaround: Blast your broiler for 20 to 30 minutes to get the oven really hot, turn the heat to bake at 425, and see if that helps. In Portugal, the ovens they use are 800°F.
OK thanks. I’ll give that a try. Should I perhaps bake them on the upper rack, closer to the broil elements? I’m so afraid of burning them.
Rick, the broiler wouldn’t be on when you cook them, just the regular oven! In your case, I’d bake then in the upper third of the oven.
OK. Thanks David. I’ll give that a try on the weekend. I’ll let you know how they turn out this next time. :)
Excellent, Rick.
great recipe! the instructions are well written with lots of detail and extra information…… i tried this recipe for the first time and got great results. my oven gets to 280C and i put them on the top shelf (not just the top third). i added cinnamon for the last butter fold so the spirals have a bit more definition, it also means i don’t have to sprinkle with cinnamon for serving. Ive tried other similar recipes that use shop bought puff pastry and the result is often soft pastry cases that shrink are only good for about 30 minutes after cooking. When i saw this recipe i had to try it and making the pastry really makes all the difference. really crisp and kept well for at least 24 hours (they may have kept longer but they were all gone by this time). i used the 12 hole muffin tin size which is about 21/2″ in diameter and about 11/4″ deep, i think this size gives 2 nice bites and its gone.
it is a lot of effort but really great product. i think i’m going to scale up the recipe (x3) and then freeze batches of both the custard and the pastry. The pastry will be OK but what do you think about freezing the thin custard?
Chris, I’m mighty impressed with your first endeavor!! These are hard little suckers to make. Yours look fantastic!
Hi David, I have asked on another thread but would love your feedback on how to consistently achieve the caramelization on the custard consistently? Is it to do with the temperature or the sugar content?
Hi, Julia. The temperature is everything. When I visited the original pastry shop in Portugal, I discovered their ovens reach a temperature of 800°F. That allows the pastries to cook quickly and become mottled with brown spots. Because no home oven gets that high, it takes longer for the spots to form, and the custard overcooks.
What some people have done is when the pastries are just about done, they turn on the broiler. But that can sometimes char the outside.
Making them larger, as Molly said she did, does help. Because it means the custard is in the oven longer. And because there is more filling, it doesn’t overcook.
Couldn’t wait to try making these for the first time! Didn’t use all of the butter (maybe even only half!), but crust still came out fairly crispy and flakey. Oven doesn’t go up so high, but just baked longer – couldn’t get the nice golden top, but maybe I’ll torch the next time. My custard wasn’t quite right in texture – but I will keep trying! Only complaint is how sweet it was! Sadly, too much so.
T A, glad you dove into this recipe. What was different about the texture? You can cut back on some of the sugar, but the Portuguese are known for their achingly sweet sweet tooth!
This recipe for pasteis de nata is truly one of my go-to, no-fail recipes. Turned out perfectly on my first try and basically every time since. Much more beginner-friendly than it seems – I had no experience with puff pastry OR custard before this – and the results always get at least one happy dance from my family. And these get the official seal of approval from my Portuguese friend who goes to Lisbon a couple times a year!
I’ve made them about ten times in the past year and a half, and the only time I’ve had an issue was when I didn’t follow the instructions – like when I used heavy cream instead of milk, because that’s what I had in the fridge. Still good, but not as smooth a custard. Sometimes I end up with more pastry dough than custard, but again, that’s from me not measuring when I cut :-) Just follow the recipe and you’ll be good. If your oven has trouble getting those characteristic browned bits on the surface of the custard, try broiling for a minute or two.
Kimberly, they look fantastic! And sometimes I use cream when I’m out of milk. As the Portuguese say, não faz mal.
Is it ok to use puff pastry? Would it make a difference to the amount of custard or would the recipe stay the same?
Laura, traditional puff pastry is to designed to puff up, obvs. That can cause the filling to overflow as it’s pushed up. If you want to try it, roll it out, coat it wil a very thin layer of butter, and roll it up as in the directions. That should help a bit.
Hi, I had a question—I haven’t baked much before and I was wondering how important the muffin tin size is? What size specifically would you recommend? I’m not entirely sure what the measurement in the recipe refers to, depth or width? Thanks so much!
Andrew, the recipe as written calls for mini-muffin tins with wells 2 inches wide by 5/8 inch high. As you can see from the photos in the comments, many people have made them in standard tins with no problem. They just had to cook them longer.
I’ve just made my first attempt with this recipe and would call it a success-in-the-making. A couple of questions: 1) I found the taste quite a bit sweeter than the pasteis de nata that I ate on a recent trip to Lisbon. I’m wondering if anyone has tried cutting the sugar back when making the custard? And, if so, by how much? 2) I think my custard was too gelatinous. Could this also be a problem of too much sugar? (I’m fairly new to baking.) Thanks for your help. And thanks for the recipe. As a novice baker, I found the directions clear and easy to follow.
tlupick, I think you can safely cut back on the sugar by one-quarter. I’m not sure what you mean by “gelatinous.” Do you mean eggy? It’s possible the eggs were overcooked. Was the filling weepy?
Thanks for your quick reply. “Gelatinous” like my custard almost had the consistency of jello or an especially sticky jam. I’m going to try making the custard again tonight with the 1/4 less sugar you’ve suggested. Thanks!
That’s unusual. I wonder if they were baked too long, tlupick. Let me know how the new batch goes.
We’re just about there. My second batch is much better. And, though I’m not exactly sure how, we seem to have corrected the gelatinous problem I encountered with my first batch of custard.
I did end up making a few recipe modifications throughout:
-for the custard, reduce sugar by 1/4
-for the custard, after adding the sugar and water to the milk mixture, whisk vigorously for several minutes (as long as 5 to ensure a custard with a proper consistency); add the egg yolks, whisked vigorously for several minutes again
-cut dough into pieces 1.75 inches long (1 inch in diameter)
-shape dough up to the top of the baking tray, pour in 2 tbsp custard mixture
-15 minutes baking, 2 minutes in the broiler
-let sit for 20 minutes
For me (and my specific muffin tray and oven and all of that), these modifications appear to have made all the difference. My second batch of pasteis de nata is a huge improvement on my first. I still need to work on my pastry crust. But I think that will just take practice. This is a great recipe. thanks for sharing.
tlupick, I’m delighted that 1.) you took another swing at it and 2.) it was a success! And, yes, it’s just a matter of practice. If I haven’t made them in a year or so, I feel all thumbs.
Thank you for the helpful tips and a bit of the history on these delicious tarts. Love your honest writing style!
Thank you, Joanna!
Hi David !! Cannot wait to try this recipe. My husband and l lived in Portugal for 5 years, and these little tarts were taste of heaven when sitting outside early morning with a relaxing with a cup of coffee. I am in bed at the moment whilst being unwell, and my husband has just brought in this beautiful delicacy with a coffee, and it brought back so many lovely memories of Portugal that l just had to look up a recipe, and here l am. I can see that the ingredients call for “cup,” what size cup would I use? I have looked at your other mouthwatering recipes that call for a “cup.” I thank you in anticipation of a reply, an l cannot wait to go shopping for some of the ingredients. Thanks David
Maria, I hope you feel better. A “cup” is a standard measuring cup (8 fluid ounces/236 ml). I hope this helps!
Hi! This recipe looks amazing, my boyfriend is Portuguese and I’d love to make this dish for a family dinner. Is it an absolute must to make the dough? It seems quite intimidating. I was wondering if store bought pastry dough would work? If not, any tips for making the dough?
Ashley, if you read through the comments, you’ll see some people used storebought puff pastry. I’ll admit, I don’t like it with storebought. If you can, try to find DuFour puff pastry. It’s really good. As far as tips, roll out the storebought dough very, very thin, spread a thin layer of softened butter, and roll it into a log. If you make the dough, the best tip is to have patience! The good thing is you use room-temp butter, so the pressure to work quickly is removed.
Thank you, David! I may attempt to the dough as I’d like these to be as close to traditional as possible.
My oven only goes to 500, I did read another comment that stated her oven also only went to 500, do know how much longer of a cook time I should plan for at 500?
Oh, good, Ashley. I think you’ll be rewarded with great pastries. As far as your oven goes, it depends upon how accurate it is. Some people turn on the broil for a minute or so to get the blackened mottled tops. Some keep the pastries in an extra 2 to 4 minutes. My suggestion would be to bake two and experiment. Once you know the best way to bake these for your oven, you’ll be set!
Great idea, thank you so much for all of your help! Very excited to make these.
You bet, Ashley!
Great Recipe. First try came out awesome, with flaky dough. To people checking the comments: my custard could have been drinkable. It was this liquidy. Also, an oven at 450 and 4 extra minutes works fine. I recommend this recipe to anybody who can use their hands to form dough: otherwise use store-bought croissant dough.
Milan, thanks, and thanks for the tip!
I followed the recipe without any changes, except that my oven can’t reach 550°F, so I set it at 500°. I made some mini and some regular sized pastries. I baked the mini ones for 9 minutes and they remained lightly colored and eggy on top, with none of the brown spots you’ll find on authentic pastries. They also had a somewhat undercooked bottom. This is almost certainly because my oven wasn’t at a high enough temperature. The regular size pastries I baked for 20 minutes, and they have some dark spots on the surface and the pastry looks much darker. The bottom is also baked thoroughly. So if you’re like me and your oven won’t reach 550°, bake them for an extra minute or two (or three) to achieve those dark spots and a thoroughly cooked pastry. Both the undercooked and the perfectly cooked pastries tasted wonderful, though, and the custard set in both, it’s just the appearance and the bottom of the pastry that was different!
Molly, I’m delighted they turned out! And thanks for the tips. I’m sure readers will benefit from it!
Hi Molly, do you believe that the higher temperature are key to creating the brown spots on top? This is something im struggling to achieve consistently. I’ve done some research and there isn’t much information on it yet.
This is yet another real deal recipe by David Leite! These natas couldn’t be any more delicious. The filling is simple to make and turns out so creamy, while the crust is perfectly flaky. What a superb combination of textures! These pastéis are fun to make and even better to enjoy amongst friends. Cheers!–
Kristy, these look fantastic. And they are, indeed, a delight to eat!
I just made these this morning (started last night), and they came out perfect! I followed the recipe exactly (except for the oven temp, could have sworn it said 500 but I did change it to 550). I had no problems with the oven smoking, but for some reason, the smoke alarms did go off every time I opened the oven door. My son visited Portugal a few years ago and he said they were very close to those he had there. All in all, very happy with the recipe and will definitely make these again!
Joyce, I am utterly delighted that you enjoyed the pastéis de nata. I have a theory of why your alarms kept going off when you opened the oven door: They smelled how good the pastries were and wanted some!
I’m more of a cook than a baker, but /when/ I bake, I like to make slightly more complex things. This one has been on my list forever, so I finally decided to give it a spin! I made a few small mistakes along the way (the biggest of which was probably not owning offset spatulas and which has now been rectified), but despite that they came out really nice and everyone who got one loved it!
Thanks a lot for this recipe!
Tobias, congrats! The pastéis look great. You are more than welcome for the recipe.
Do you perhaps have a video of making this?
Erika, I know, I know! It’s on the list of videos to create. We’re moving as fast as we can, but it’s just The One and me when it comes to videos!
10/10! This is an easy to follow recipe. I was glad to find the recipe had the measurements in grams and not just cups. They tasted amazing and you must eat them the day you make them. We had some left over but you lose the crispy pastry when eating them the day after. I used a normal muffin tin and this was fine. I need to make sure next time that I bring the pastry up higher in the tin. This was my first attempt at making them and I will defiantly be making them again. They taste so good fresh out of the oven. A supermarket cannot compete with oven fresh baking!
Claire, these look fantastic! You made them in full-size muffin tins, which is harder. Brava. And, yes, they need to be eaten the same day. They lose some of their specialness (and crispness) the next day. All in all, double brava!
Experienced baker here, but one who’d never tried baking these, in spite of LOVING them on a recent trip.
I have the mini tins, but opted instead to bake these in an old, well-seasoned steel regular-sized muffin tin. I’ve made puff pastry in the past and this pastry is definitely different–using warmish butter seemed strange to me after jumping through hoops at times, keeping puff pastry’s ingredients COLD.
I followed the recipe to a T, however, and these turned out transcendently good.
A few tips for questions people had in these comments…
–If you aren’t using whole milk (I only had 1%) add a tablespoon or two of melted butter to the custard mix.
–If you have a convection setting in your oven, set the temp at 500 degrees on convection and stick with using a rack set about 8″ from the broiler element.
–After cutting a 1 1/2″ piece off of the pastry log (no rolling it to make the diameter smaller), set the rounds on a piece of plastic wrap, covering them with another piece of plastic. Then, press down on them with a flat, round meat pounder (a heavy glass would also work, I imagine). Doing so definitely made the rounds easier to mold into the larger tin.
–Use PLENTY of flour when rolling out the dough… throughout the process, keep putting flour underneath it, using a pastry scraper to lift the dough.
This recipe is fabulous.
Diane, wow. Just wow! The tips are superb, and your passion and excitement are infectious! I hope others jump on the pastéis bandwagon now!
Thanks so much for this recipe, David!
I just ordered the proper tins (Amazon, 20 for $12) and a batch of the dough is in the freezer. I’m on a Pasteis de Nata tear here (reminiscent of my canele binge a few years ago…but that’s another story) and am dying to know how the shape will have an impact on the results.
A couple more things…I realized yesterday that the crust kind of reminds me of palmiers, especially the crunchy bottoms. That was kind of an “aha!” moment.
As well, I forgot to mention the time it takes to make the bigger tarts (about 15 minutes).
Diane, how did the new tins turn out?
David, they were PERFECT! The angled sides and, I think, the fact that heat was circulating more efficiently around the sides, made the crust of the pastry on the sides a more uniform color and even crunchier than they were coming out of the muffin tin…my husband said they were “better than Belem’s” and my brother-in-law’s face, when he chomped into the pillowy custard enveloped in that pastry, looked like he had seen The Divine.
Another thing I discovered was that, once totally cooled, you can put them in a container and refrigerate them (though I only refrigerated them overnight) and re-heat them at 225 for about 10-15 minutes successfully! There didn’t seem to be any degradation in the texture of the crust, which was my main concern.
This girl is a happy one for having stumbled on your recipe (as are the neighbors!). Thanks again for posting it.
Diane, I pronounce you my Cook of the Month! You really dug in and made these (sometimes finicky) pastries perfectly! Congrats!
David
Great recipe but a bit too rich in butter I think. When I made them the melted butter spilled out of the moulds into the pan below. I used individual small moulds instead of a cupcake pan.
Paul
Paul, that’s a pretty standard ratio for the dough. If you use individual tins, put a foil-lined baking sheet beneath. That’s what they do in Portugal, because these do tend to leak.
I would love to make these but I don’t have a stand mixer. Can I use a hand-held mixer?
Catherine, you can, but it will take longer for the dough to form.
Well, I cautiously decided to make 1/6 of the recipe amounts as a trial run, hoping to present a huge plateful at a Christmas party this weekend. The amount of pastry I had made 8 mini muffin size, but I seemed to have a lot of custard, so they were all too full! Despite bubbling over they can’t out of the time easily and are (or should I say were!!) Superb!!! My partner and I ate 3 each with our coffee, and only guilt prevented us from eating the final two!
The only negative was that I think my bottoms were a bit thick. I found it quite hard to judge this as you push the pastry into the tin. Interestingly, before today, my partner always said: “I hate custard tarts!”
Thanks for a fabulous recipe, and not nearly as daunting as I anticipated.
Looloo, sorry for the overflow, but it seems as if the end justifies the means! Enjoy a whole batch next time!
The recipe is amazing!! Taste-wise and looks wise. I made these in standard sized muffin tins and cut the dough log into 1/2 inch pieces rather than 1 inch pieces. I found 1 inch pieces made the shell too thick and the inside was soggy. I also added a half handful more flour as I found the dough to be quite sticky and not smooth as described. Finally, after resting the dough ~30 mins – 1hr, I used it but only filled the shells halfway full as less “rested” dough shrinks slightly more. I’d recommend making one or two to test and adjusting the amount of dough and filling based on how your first two tarts turn out.
Diane, I’m delighted you liked the recipe. If you’re making the pastries in a standard muffin tin, try cutting the dough roll between 3/4 of an inch and an inch. That would help. The dusting of flour is fine. And brava on suggesting the test pastéis. I often do that, too.
I really loved this recipe and these Pastèis are very similar to those from Pastèis de Belém! The dough is challenging because it is sticky and requires quite a bit of flour to work it. I had to knead mine in the mixer for longer time than instructed to achieve the dough pulling from the sides of the bowl. These are known for being difficult, but the result is a super flaky and crispy crust. I prefer to use the metric measurements in general for accuracy. My oven reaches 550 F and I got beautiful brown spots. I also love that once the dough is prepared, you can refrigerate or freeze and the custard and baking process are very easy and simple. I was in Lisbon last year and was able to find the traditional baking cups and this recipe yielded 24 of those. I just divided each log into 12 so they are thicker. The instructions on shaping the dough are good, and I was lucky I have a video of the bakers in Lisbon shaping it, so I had an idea of how to do it too! I am making these again to practice working the dough. They are the perfect pastry to bring to holiday events as they are easy to share and so so delicious! Thank you David for such a great recipe!
Laura, the pastéis are perfect! And the swirl on the bottom is masterful. Superb in every way. >>Envious!<<
Hi! I have enjoyed learning about pasteis de nata and their history! I read through the comments and did not see a question like mine. I have a convection oven that heats to 550* F. I was advised that coated/treated ovenware should not be used at this high temperature because the coating could flake off and compromise the food (make it unhealthy). Is this for older ovenware or a kitchen myth? I appreciate your guidance!
Hi, Suzan. Most of the warning concerned older types of nonstick pans and usually pans that came in direct contact with heat, such as skillets. I’ve used my baking pans for years, and they have never flaked.
Hi, I’m a bit confused with step 5 and 6. If I have a square dough and fold the right 1/3 of it over first, then fold the left 1/3 over, I should have a 6″x18″ rectangle with the opening end on the right. I don’t see how the fold would be facing me if I turn the dough 90 degree to the left? Shouldn’t it be facing away from me?
Hi Momo, let’s see if I can clarify. Standing in front of the dough, imagine the square is divided into three vertical columns. Take the right column and fold it over to center column. Then take the left column and fold it over the center column, too. Now you have one column with folded edges on the left and right sides, and the opening on the top and bottom. Does that help?
I just cooked a trial pastry before I made the rest this evening. It stuck to my muffin tin, can I lightly grease the tin for the rest?
Kat, yes you can. Are you using a nonstick pan?
Hello! I am interested in making this recipe but my oven only goes to 500°F. May I still use this recipe and bake it for longer or will the custard not set?
Mproco, you should be fine at 500°F. Just please don’t turn on the broiler, otherwise, the tops will be completely burnt. You might need to go a bit longer, but lower the temperature to 375°F or so.
Have wanted to make Pastéis de Nata for a while now but have always been a bit too intimidated as they seemed a little complicated. However, I found this recipe easy to follow, with detailed step by step instructions, and was very happy with the outcome! They tasted delicious and looked authentic! I will definitely be making again in the future.
Lucky, they look sensational! I’m so happy you got up the nerve to make them–they’re worth it.
I loved the pastry and the custard was creamy and well set. I did however want more flavour into the custard. How could I enfuse more flavour into it. Would you suggest more lemon rind, cinnamon stick via the hot milk or via the syrup. Thanks for the advice.
Louisa, yes, all of them would be fine. Perhaps let the syrup steep longer and then refrigerate overnight.
Loved this recipe! I was craving these tarts after my holiday in Portugal and this recipe gets so close to the real thing (and, I’m not the best cook, but the recipe was easy to follow!). Thank you!
Vicki, you are more than welcome. So happy you and yours enjoyed it!
I made these for my husband’s birthday, and they are incredible! Thanks so much for this beautiful recipe.
I made them in standard muffin tins, which made 20 tarts. I baked them at 240°C/fan assisted (465°F/convection) for 16 minutes then turned them halfway through. Perfect!
When making the pastry, I was very worried about how it would turn out because it is very fragile and tricky to work with. But I needn’t have worried…just be as delicate as possible and put the pastry cases in the fridge for 30 mins before filling with custard and putting them into the oven.
Ellie, what a great present. Please wish your husband a very happy birthday for us!
Hi I’m going to make the custard but instead of making the pastry for the tarts I’m going to use Crossiants cut and pushed into small patty tins do you think the temperature should be as high?
Thanks sandy.
Sandy, we’ve never tried it that way, so I can’t be of much help. I know you won’t get the same quality or experience as you would with the recipe, or even using storebought puff pastry. But report back with your results!
I just made these as a labor of love for my son and fiance, who recently ate them non-stop in Portugal at Antiga Confeitaria de Belem and everywhere else. They couldn’t stop raving about them and when I saw this recipe, I promised I’d attempt them. Well, I made them this week and yesterday we ate them when they visited for the weekend. The tarts were amazing! My son rated them 4 1/2 stars compared to the originals and 5 stars for overall enjoyment!
I followed the recipe exactly. On Wednesday I made the dough. It was very time consuming but not difficult. It took more than 1 1/2 hours to keep rolling and rerolling. The trickiest part was rolling it to the 18″ dimensions. But I did the best I could, then cut the log in half, wrapped and froze them. On Friday I made the custard. I don’t have a thermometer so figured that once the sugar had disolved in the water, it was done.
Thursday night I put one dough log in the refrigerator to defrost. Sunday morning I put it all together in a 12-cup mini muffin tin and baked the first batch. I baked each batch for about 11 minutes at 500 degrees for the custard to brown a bit. I let it cool a few minutes, and then we sprinkled confectioner’s sugar and cinnamon on top. They were amazing!!
My son and future daughter-in-law now consider themselves experts on Pasteis de Nata. My son said “It was pretty close to the original except for the crust, which was a bit more crispy. The custard was very close to the original, a bit sweeter. Delicious!”
They, my husband and I ate all 20 (the 2nd log is in the freezer) and had a wonderful breakfast! Don’t be afraid to make this. It’d a long process but definitely worth it, especialliy since you can make the dough in advance and freeze it. The custard made more than enough since I had leftover for the 2nd dough log (I halved the custard recipe since I was only making 20 tarts). I plan on making only 1/4 the custard recipe and freeze it with the remaining original extra custard and hopefully it will freeze well so that my younger son and girlfriend can try these when they visit!
Thank you for this recipe! If you attemtp it, please don’t change it – follow it exactly and you will be pleased!
Paula, wow! I love your comment, your thorough baking, and your input. Thank you so much for adding more info to this recipe and this wonderful pastry.
It was only a few years ago when I tried pastéis de nata for the first time and instantly fell in love with them. Being intimidated by their temperamental preparation, I never thought about making them myself. That was until I clapped eyes on David’s recipe.
I’m not afraid of detailed recipes when it comes to baking as I prefer to stay alert every step of the way. Since the preparation of any kind of dough almost always puts me in a state of mental affliction, I feel much more confident when I have a thoroughly laid-out guidance to dough-making. I humbly list David’s pastéis de nata under this category of recipes.
Pre-baking notes:
– Following the dough preparation steps to the letter with much perseverance, I had no problem carrying out David’s instructions. The dough turned out great. I was a little clumsy placing the cut dough pieces in the cups, so they baked a little out-of-shape but I’ll do better next time.
– For the custard, I prepared a little more than necessary because I had something different in mind. I wanted the custard to overflow so that it would create an imploded structure that’s reminiscent of the Yorkshire pudding! In order to do that, I filled the cups 5/6 full with custard, instead of 3/4 full. So it’s approximately a tablespoon of extra custard for each cup.
Baking notes:
– The only technical problem for me was the baking temperature. The highest temperature my oven could provide is 500°F, whereas the recipe calls for 550°F. That’s why I had to improvise a little. After 15 minutes of baking (I used a regular 12-cup muffin pan), I checked the pastries and they weren’t quite done yet, so I baked them for another 7 minutes. After 22 mins of total baking time, both the dough and the custard were well done.
Post-baking notes:
– The dough puffed a little more than it should. The next time I make these pastries, I’ll do the fork trick and see what happens.
– The overflowing custard idea worked great. I obtained pastéis shaped like tiny edible bowls into which a choice of topping (I prefer a scoop of vanilla ice cream) would perfectly fit!
– The custard recipe is so good that the baked pastries had this amazing shiny look as if they were glazed!
– And the taste is… legendary. The ethereal smell of the baked flaky dough virtually announces the commencement of a delicious Saturnalia for taste buds. The frenzy of simple but elegant flavors is crowned with the regal quality of vanilla. It’s truly spectacular! I hope to enjoy more soon :)
Baris–wow, wow, wow, wow, wow! These are the most gorgeous homemade pastéis de nata I’ve seen. And your baking notes are super helpful. Thank you for adding to the knowledge of these wonderful pastries.
Fiddly recipe but grea result. I needed less water than the recipe states to get the dough to form.
RB, great to hear it. If you’re not in the U.S., chances the flour is slightly different, requiring less (and in some cases more) water.
Hello, sir. I am a young home cook. I have made flaky-type Hong Kong egg tarts before, which are like Macau egg tarts, but less of the scorched exterior. (<Macau egg tarts are Portuguese egg tarts but kind of reinvented by the Chinese.) So I was wondering if I could use the type of tin I used for those tarts. Those are basically fluted tart tins made of very thin aluminum. Also, I’m curious if I could lower the sugar to 150g and add some vanilla extract to the sugar syrup. Thank you for this amazing recipe, sir! Sorry to bother you with so many questions even before I made the tarts.
Hannah, first: Stop calling me “sir”! I feel so old when you do that. You can call me David.
Yes, you can use those tins. You will most likely have to bake them a bit longer. (If you check out this comments above, others have done the same thing.)
And I think lowering the sugar should be fine. I haven’t done it; my only fear is it might affect the consistency of the syrup.
Wonderful recipe! I made a half batch as written and was amazed by the result. The tarts looked and tasted like those I ate in Lisbon. Two comments: for my mini muffin tin using thinner slices of the log produced a more pleasing ratio of crust to custard – 1/2″ or slightly less was perfect for me; I can’t believe with all the corrections and suggestions you received for this recipe, no one pointed out that 220 F is not the same as 100 C.
mark, thanks for your comment. And I’m glad you found the right ratio for you between crust and custard. But I am confused: 220°F equals 104°C. We just rounded down 4°.
I made hundreds of custards for an event using your fabulous recipe… I made several batches of custard along the way. Some of the batches seemed to curdle slightly when cooked, although the unbaked custard when poured was fine… did I over bake them, or do you have another suggestion?? They still tasted delicious… Many thanks x
Sophie, what exactly do you mean by curdle? I’m rethinking the custard recipe a bit, after my second visit to Belém. And…those look INSANELY good!!
I have a small stove and it only goes to 500°F. I assume I just need to bake a little longer?
Jean-Guy, just a bit more. Chances are you won’t get many of the classic brown spots on top.
Amazing! Pastry is much better using cups not grams. I get 20 with a standard muffin tray. Made 4 times now.
Lee, superb!!
Hi there
I’m in the UK, can you please put the measurements in grams/ounces? It’s really hard to convert and I’m confused by the recipe.
Hello, Karen. The recipe already contains metric measurements. Right after each ingredient.
Wowee what a cracker of a recipe! We have an annual Eurovision party with super foodie people, so the pressure’s always on to make something awesome and this recipe did not disappoint with this year’s theme Portuguese food. Although fairly complicated, the recipe was written very clearly. We cooked in a wood fired oven starting the first batch at 300 degrees (C) and the last batch was at 220. The first batch took 4.5 mins and the last batch 12 mins but they were all awesome. We made 2 1/4 inc (6cm) tarts as we had the extra heat from the wood fired oven. They were received with rave reviews. Thanks!
Sheridan, I’m just delighted by your review. And I’m green with envy over your wood-fired oven.
Hello David,
I tried making these beauties, and boy they didn’t disappoint. However, I found them too sweet. The next time I make them, I will reduce the amount of sugar and hopefully achieve the desired results. I took the liberty to share your page with a group on facebook.
Liz, Portgueuse sweets are usually quite sweet. You can cut down on the sugar. Please let me know how much you use and how it turns out!
My son and his Portuguese girlfriend stayed this weekend and we made these together – huge success!! The pastry was crisp and flaky, and the cinnamon custard was delicious. I had my doubts whilst making them but they turned out beautifully and were very authentic. Thanks for a great recipe!
Frances, I couldn’t be happier. Estou muito feliz que a namorada do seu filho tenha gostado dos pastéis.
This recipe is great, I have had them in the famous cafe, and while it will never be the same it is very close. Close enough that when ever my Portuguese family are in town I have an obligation to make them. They even purchased some tins for me from Lisbon.
I have made them till now in a traditional oven (full-sized tins) at high altitude 4500 feet at 475°F for 14 minutes and have had mixed results. Even the mistakes are great to eat! :)
Now in a convection oven that cooks at 550°F, the first batch baked for 14 minutes, and the dough was soft and not crispy. I did not thumb this batch, so I can not say if they were as thin as they could have been. The tops got that nice “burn.”
Next batch had thin bottoms and baked at 550°F for 15 minutes. I hope to get this dialed. Thanks for making this recipe public. :)
One line that I remember from the baker in Lisbon is, “The dough must be so thin, like bible paper!” good luck there, ha ha. I get it thin but not that thin.
Barrymore, convection ovens will always do a better job of browning the top. That’s what they have in Lisbon. I didn’t mention that in the recipe, because when I developed it, few people had convection settings. I think I shall add it. And if you have a soggy bottom (or rather your pastéis do), it usually means that dough it too thick. So glad you liked them.
I made these for Easter and they were a big hit! I had been too intimidated to make these previously but they were actually pretty easy. I used a scale to weigh ingredients and used a mini muffin pan. Per my oven thermometer, my oven got up to 600 degrees and I still didn’t get the burn marks on the custard! So I cheated and used a torch! Our Portuguese family was very happy! Will definitely make these again.
Jana, hurrah! I’m thrilled that you liked them so much and that it worked for you. Yes, I’ll admit: It is a bit of an intimating recipe–but only from a distance. When you get into it, it’s fun and the results are delicious!
As far as not getting a brown top, try this next time: Place a baking stone above and another one below the rack the pastries will be baked on. Let the oven and stones heat up. Give this a good long time, as the stones need extra time to heat up. This creates an intense mini oven that mimics what they have in Belem.
Hi David,
My husband was born in Brazil, and we always buy pasteis de Mata when we visit Newark, NJ. We decided today to try to make our own. We are so impressed with ourselves! Thank you for the great, easy-to-follow recipe. We had no shrinking dough, no boil overs, and no regrets!
Theodora, so delighted you and your husband enjoyed the recipe. And the pastries look amazing!
I work at a bakery and constantly see them pumping out Portuguese tarts every day and they’re always so popular. So, when I had some egg yolks left over from a recipe I decided to give this recipe a try. Since I was short on time, I used store-bought puff pastry but applied some butter in between layers as I was rolling it out. When they came out of the oven, the tops were a lovely golden brown and the pastry was golden as well. A few of the bottoms were a little doughy due to me not thinning them out enough and the custard spilled out of a few, but they were delicious. I plan on making them again soon so this time I’ll be sure to thin out my pastry as well as pull the dough all the way up the sides.
Sarah, that’s excellent. May I ask what bakery?
Over the years I have tried various recipes for the Portuguese custard tarts and decided that I’m better off just buying them. Even when they did turn out, they were too time-consuming. When I saw this recipe some time ago, I thought I’d like to give it a try. I was looking for a recipe that I could flavour with juniper berries for a dinner party with venison as the main. These tarts were familiar to my guests, so I thought I’d go for the wow factor and switch up the cinnamon stick for crushed juniper berries. I also used shallow fluted tart tins and ready-made puff pastry that I always keep in the freezer for last minute preparations. The yield on the filling was 8 tarts. I loved that I could keep the filling refrigerated until ready to use as well as the preprepared tart crusts. My oven doesn’t heat above 500°F, so I baked these for 17 minutes. What an amazing velvety, creamy, tasty filling dotted with just the right scorch to identify as inspired by pastéis de nata! Can’t wait to make these again with the cinnamon in the mini tins and serve them to my Portuguese family! Perfect filling recipe for Portuguese custard tarts!
Ilda, wow, what a story! And I love the juniper berry addition. Do you have any photos by chance?
Phenomenal. I love baking and I usually only make recipes that receive 4.5 stars and above on over 1000 reviews. And this recipe makes the cut–simply fantastic. My husband and I have been going to the Italian Centre and we often sit with a hot cup of tea and enjoy one of these. But I thought I’d give this recipe a go at home and it surpasses those in the Italian Centre. Thank you for sharing.
Catherine, THAT’S what I love to hear!! Delighted you enjoyed it so much. Obrigado.
Can’t wait to try this recipe. I’ve tried others in the past, which weren’t so great. Gonna buy the ingredients today and hope it all turns out well, so I can surprise my family. We grew up with these having these as a weekly treat now living here in Florida we cannot get them. Only when we go back home to Massachusetts for vacation we get to enjoy these. Thanks for sharing your recipe.
Christina, I hope you and your family like them.
Hi there.
So this is the third time I’ve attempted to make Pastel de Nata. My puff pastry is so puffed that they look like big bite custard canapés. The first time I burnt them, the second was a success but didn’t have much of a puff.
It seems like this time it rose for all the attempts. Any ideas why it did so?
Beverlie, sorry, but I had to laugh at your comment. Thank God I have a lot of hair because I pull some out every time I make these.
Just know: This is a finicky recipe. The reason why your puff puffed so much is that you made it EXTREMELY well. It means your layers of dough were well laminated with butter. One thing you can do to prevent this is to prick the dough with a fork or toothpick before adding the filling. It allows steam to escape.
I finally decided to give these tarts a try since moving to Minnesota and realizing I could not find these here anywhere. I was a bit nervous attempting to make these but this recipe turned out exactly the I had hoped. I had a bit of difficulty of working with the pastry – it stuck to the table quite a bit even quite a bit of flour. I was afraid I wasn’t going get those layers because my folding technique wasn’t all that great, but after baking them I managed to see all those great layers. This recipe was great! I loved it!
Also as a side note for those making it in the reg, sized muffin pans – I kept mine in the oven for 12mins and they came out perfect.
Thanks for the recipe!
Ashely, Brava! These little suckers aren’t easy to make–especially in full-size muffin tins. Thanks for your timing note, too. Do you happen to have a photo, perchance?
this recipe was amazing.
So delighted you enjoyed it, Sheila.
I see you say you need mini muffin tin with 2 inch by 5/8 inch wells. Can you clarify what that means. I have regular muffin tins that measure 2 5/8 inch’s in diameter. I think mini muffin tins are much much smaller than that. So is what I have correct? I just measured the top of the muffin tin well from one side to the other and it measured 2 5/8 inches wide.
Hello, Dan. Sure. The tins are 2 inches in diameter but only 5/8 inch high. Many readers here have made them in larger tins, and that’s fine. (I often make them in the original individual tins.) Just make sure to cook them a bit longer.
Hi David, I want to make these for a friend’s birthday, but I only have a standard sized muffin tin. In your recipe, you direct to roll the dough to an inch in diameter and 16 inches long, and to cut it into scant 3/4-inch pieces. Do you have any recommendation on dough dimensions and cooking time for a standard muffin sized tin versus the mini muffins?
Cara, it’s been a long time since I made them in a regular-sized tin. But go with 1 1/2 inches. (Your yield will be less, of course.) Then increase the baking time. Some of our readers have found 16 to 17 minutes is best.
Thank you! One more question…I saw you said the dough can be made the day before and refrigerated, do you think the dough would last a few days in the fridge if I had to make it a little more in advance?
Cara, absolutely! I’ve kept it in the fridge for up to a week. The custard can be held the most two or three days.
Just made these today. The first bite into my test pastry immediately took me back to Portugal! Since I live at an altitude of 4000 feet, the cooking time varies slightly where I am, but in general following the recipe as written worked pretty well. I had to experiment with rack position and baked in a slightly larger muffin tin at 500°F, although I had some issues getting the bottom to brown due to my inconsistent gas oven temperature. It seems that straight out of the fridge my dough was already the right length and diameter, so after my first batch I decided to skip rolling a bit thinner and went straight to cutting the pieces (1 inch for the larger tin size). This helped maintain the crispy, chewy crust, since I handled the dough less. The custard also can jiggle very slightly when you take it out so that it doesn’t overcook. Thanks for sharing the tasty recipe! My whole family enjoyed the pastries.
Lynn, I’m delighted you enjoyed them so much. And all the way up in the air!
After tasting the originals my daughter and son-in-law brought me as they flew home through Portugal, and deciding they were the best thing I’ve ever eaten, I was on a quest to find a recipe I could bake in my Kansas kitchen!! After searching I found this recipe and finally today gave it a try.
Although this first time through I cheated and used refrigerated puff pastry dough, I followed the custard recipe and baking according to how it is written with the exception that my oven would only go to 525 degrees. The thin custard made me nervous, but I trusted the process.
I did bake 12 pastries in regular sized US muffin tins, which seemed a perfect amount to accomplish the crust explained in the recipe. Although a few of mine I must have gotten too thin on the bottom as some filling drained through, I refilled and popped in the hot oven.
After 11 minutes at 525 degrees these beautiful danishes came out of the oven browned beautifully, shiny and even a few browned circles like the original!! After a very short cool, and carefully taking them out of the pans, it was finally time to try them!
With a steaming cup of coffee we all very, very much enjoyed them and my daughter and husband insisted they were better than the originals. I however, enjoyed every bite, but know by cheating with the purchased puff pastry they were not what they should be and could have been close to the first perfect one I tasted if I had made it myself.
Thank you for this fantastic recipe!! Next time I will honor these great, special pastries and follow the recipe all the way through!
Kris, so glad to hear they worked well for you! I love these!
Hi, David. Just to say that I made the Portuguese tart recipe recently, and it was a hit. It was the strangest dough I have ever worked with, and I was quite skeptical it would turn out but it was really light and crispy–so amazing. It was quite sticky and I think I’ll give it another try at some point as I’d make a few adjustments in my technique. Making a custard with sugar syrup was also new to me and could not believe the custard was able to set in the 9 minute baking time. I’m glad I stuck with it. I baked them in a standard 12 cup muffin tin and was able to make about 26 tarts overall.
TG, your tarts look amazing! The dough is different, I agree. I’m continually trying to perfect this recipe for readers, so I would love to know what changes you made to it. We can compare notes!
Can these tart be frozen raw? And then cooked at a later stage?
Nadine, alas no. I have seen some people who freeze them after they’re baked, but I can’t imagine they are any good. Even the famous pastéis from Portugal are just meh the day after baking. These are best made and eaten the sam day.
Thank you so much for this recipe! My husband lived in Portugal for 2 years and craves the food! I made these for his birthday and he was in heaven. Thank you for the detailed instructions that made making them so easy! I will be making them again (probably for his birthday every year!)
Andrea, you are so welcome!
I’m very excited to make the recipe, I’m in the process or re-reading and unstanding the recipe.
My one question is about the butter, this is the first time I have seen a pastry using room temperature stirred butter, could you tell me what this process is called?
To me it almost seems like phyllo or filo dough with butter spread!
Ogi, there’s really no name for using room temp butter. This is a take on French puff pastry, which uses a cold block of butter.
Do you know of other recipes that use this method.
I have worked with all kinds of pastry dough but always using cold butter or pliable, I have never used temperature room stirred butter that you spread onto the dough! I am still having a hard time visualizing the process, do you have a video?
I am just very intrigued, do pasteis de nata recipes (including the dough of course) use this method?
Ogi, it’s the ONLY recipe I know that uses it. I don’t have a video. (I know, I know, I keep promising). Imagine spreading soft butter on white bread. I use a small offset spatula and carefully spread the butter over the thinly rolled pastry dough.
Total success on the first try – 500 degree convection oven, one half the recipe worked perfectly, the pastry was flawless, beautiful golden custard with brown spots too. The Belem custard tarts are a tad better but these will keep us happy much closer to home.
Willis, I couldn’t be happier! Thanks.
Do you have this recipe in grams instead of cups? I measure everything and would love to know the measurements in weight thank you!
Ogi, we’ve added the metric equivalents to the recipe and we retested it using these amounts and it worked perfectly. So you can make the recipe, using the metric amounts, with confidence.
Thank you for an authentic recipe for Pasteis de Natas that doesn’t use phyllo dough!
You’re welcome, Maria.
Hi David,
Pastéis de Nata are my absolute favorite pastries in the whole world (closely followed by Apple Strudel)! :) I’m not Portuguese but I grew up eating these pastries at our local Chinese bakery in Peru! In fact, I always identified this type of pastry with China and not Portugal. But I, later on, learned that these egg tarts were introduced in China by Portugal. Chinese food is extremely popular in Peru (where we call them “Chifas”), but Chifas didn’t sell pastries. For that, you had to go to a Chinese bakery! Unfortunately, I can’t remember what they were called in Spanish (you would just point them with your finger at the counter and you would get them!). Another Chinese pastry that I loved was the “bow ties” or “corbatas” which were really yummy but sticky because they were glazed with some kind of dense syrup. When I moved to the States I learned that Pastéis de Nata were originally from Portugal and, lucky for me back then, there was a Portuguese grocery store close to my apartment…so I indulged in them as much as I could! One of the reasons I bought your cooking book was because of the recipe for the Pastéis de Nata. I need to bake them again! :)
Wonderful, Susy. Thank you!! And enjoy them treats.
Hi David,
When you say to cut the log in half, you mean to slice it crosswise and not lengthwise correct?
Thanks,
Stephanie
Exactly, Stephanie.
Hi David,
I did it! I made the pastry with your recipe, except I used pure cream, no milk, vanilla bean, cornflour (cornstarch) instead of flour, and it all worked. The pastry isn’t as nice as yours but it was my first time making puff pastry, so it may get better?
I rested the dough overnight and used aluminum pans. I had the oven on the highest heat and cooked them for 15 minutes. I watched them and they looked like the wanted a longer time to cook. Here they are.
I grow a vanilla bean orchid, fresh vanilla beans on tap. See picture. They are expensive to buy but so easy to grow. Even a cutting they grow well. We have been to New York from the Sunshine Coast Queensland Australia many times and adored our time there.
I started reading your site and every stroke has the reader gaining personal growth. Amazing.
Since the death of my mother, I look at items I buy or hold dear, they are all about triggers of our memories. Things you can keep, that stay with you renewing precious memories from those no longer with us.
It is amazing that when you search the web for a recipe, you get a journey from an author with such depth and a soul that is so generous.
Thank you, David.
Kind regards
Janine
My, Janine. Those are handsome pastéis de nata! I’m sure with a bit of practice, the pastry will be perfect. And I’m jealous of you having a vanilla plant. Alas, it would never grown here.
Thank you kindly for your words. It means a lot to me. I never wanted to have have a site that was only recipes. I wanted to connect with readers in a different way, a more personal (and sometimes non-food) way.
Hi David I have just finished making the Portugese custard tarts unfortunately I had pools of butter and the pastry fried instead of puffing I did follow instructions (I thought ) very well but something definately went wrong! Do you have suggestions on overcoming this with the pastry, the custard tasted great
Thanks Tony
Tony, was the dough thoroughly, completely chilled? Is your oven correctly calibrated? If your oven is cool, it would cause the butter to melt before the pastry had a change to puff a bit.
Hi, David – Thanks for answering. The recipe in your book does call for “blind-baking,” (filling the shells with rice or beans to pre-bake them) though it doesn’t use that terminology – Therefore, I assumed you had used this technique. In the most recent effort, the pastry was thicker after blind-baking, therefore didn’t hold as much custard. Maybe, I need to be sure to pay more attention to form-fitting each piece to the muffin cup sides, then pricking well and freezing before blind-baking. Nothing burned this time – I blind-baked at 350, then baked with the custard at 425, then broiled for a couple minutes to get some brown spots. Custard tasted great right after baking, but was a little overdone after it continued to cook on the counter. Put them in the fridge as I am trying to determine if I could make a day ahead of serving. Somewhere I read that it is possible to Reheat a bit before serving (Was that you or someone else??). What did you mean when you said that people found the heavy cream “easier״ to use than milk? How about light cream?
Ah, now I understand!! I added the blind baking instructions in the book because it calls for packaged pastry. (My editors felt the recipe would be too long if we included the pastry recipe, too.) There’s no need to blind bake with this recipe. The handmade pastry should be very thin as you pull it up the sides. Also, you’re using full-size tins versus the mini tins, which does make a difference. Regarding making a day ahead, I find they never come out the same. I prefer to let the handmade dough and custard sit overnight in the fridge and then assemble and bake them the day of if I’m in a rush. And about milk vs. cream, some testers found it easier to burn the milk rather than cream. If this doesn’t give you the answers you need, please drop me an email with your telephone number and we can chat. david [at] leitesculinaria [.] com.
Thanks again for your help. I think I had better blind-bake as I am using the packaged puff pastry. Maybe I can do that and then let the shells sit on the counter overnight and fill and bake on the 31st. How long would you feel comfortable about letting the finished custards sit unrefrigerated? Did I mention that these are for our annual New Year’s Eve dinner party at which we serve dishes inspired by the year’s travel (2016 included Cuba, Portugal, and Spain!). This is one of three desserts – The chocolate salami is done and in the freezer; the Pasteis de Tentúgal is a snap to make – I tested once and was happy with the result. Only P de Nata has given me fits – great test for whether or not your oven browns evenly!! I may have to chicken out and do them ahead. I did slightly reheat one tonight – Not bad and it would solve the problem of how long to leave unrefrigerated after baking. Interesting answer about the milk vs. cream. Maybe light cream is the answer. What do you think they use in Belem? I would love to chat with you – Will send you my phone number by email with a copy of this post.
Sounds like a divine dinner, Kathy. To make pastéis de nata well takes a lot of practice. And, if I am to be entirely frank, no cookbook recipe I have ever tried (and I have tried a gazillion) comes truly close to the original. So don’t be hard on yourself.
When I visited the Confeitaria de Bélem, I was told it’s the custard is a secret recipe. I can say that the custard that goes in the shells is thick. Much thicker than this recipe. But this version came from a former chef at the Portuguese restaurant Alfama in NYC, who is from Lisbon.
Once again, thanks! I think I will concentrate on 1) making sure the shells are really thin; 2) making the custard thicker (Hope this is not a mistake); 3) Watch the baking like a hawk to avoid burning.
And I think you’ll be very happy! I haven’t received an email from you yet. Have you sent it?
I did send it. Maybe it is in your spam folder. I will send it again and maybe we can compare notes AFTER New Years. Just made the Tentugal – Did I say it was a snap? Well, only if you live in a humid climate. It must have been a little bit humid in Denver last week. Today, however, is very dry and I could not work fast enough and uncover the filo, one sheet at a time, before it would totally dry out! So they are tasty, but not as pretty as last week’s.
Got it, Kathy! Happy 2017!
The Pasteis de Nata were very good. Attached is a photo. I decided to make the custard using mostly half-and-half cream and cornstarch instead of flour—this created a thick custard which I refrigerated overnight and baked in my prebaked shells which had sat on the counter overnight. I left the finished tarts on the counter until dinner time, when our New Year’s Eve guests polished off quite a few! Even the next morning, the leftover custards were smooth and thick though the crust had hardened. Someday, when I am not creating an entire dinner, I may make the dough from scratch.
David, I also made your codfish and shrimp fritters for appetizers, but didn’t get a chance to photograph them before they were all gobbled up (a huge success). My husband loves the milk mayo (we have a lot left of that).
Kathy, they look great! So happy everyone loved them. And I love that you made the codfish and shrimp fritters. They’re one of my favorites. Happy 2017!
Hi David, can I used half cream half milk? Also can I scrap a vanilla bean and add that instead of the vanilla extract.
David, what a kind generous person you are. Thanks for all of your amazing tips I am in Sunshine Coast Queensland Australia. I will attach a photo when I bake these.
Thank you.
Janine, I think you certainly can on both counts. I had only one way of making these until all of our wonderful readers came to us with variations. Looking forward to seeing your creations. And, thanks for the compliment.
Hi, David – I am experimenting with making these pastries in preparation for a New Year’s Eve party next week. Used commercial puff pastry. Made them once in mini pans and did not like the result except that they did brown on top. The effort in regular muffin pans was better, but custard did not brown so I broiled for a couple of minutes – Then the custard was browned with the spots, but overdone a bit and the pastry was burned on edges. In both cases, I “blind-baked” the pastry shells, pricking the bottoms and using the technique with beans to keep the shell in place (have done this with pie shells for years). Next time I think I will have to bake them at a lower temp (350 F maybe) so that they don’t brown and later, when under the broiler, burn. Do I need to cook the filled tarts in regular muffin tins for less time or at a temp lower than 425 F so that they don’t overcook? Of course, I am comparing the results to what we had last fall in Portugal – Not there yet, but I will probably be happy if the pastry doesn’t burn and the custard is not overlooked! Oh – and I have your book “The New Portuguese Table,” in which the recipe does call for heavy cream instead of milk – Any comment on that?
Kathy, as I’ve said to others, this recipe is a tough one!! It’s so delicate and complicated. On top of that, you’ve made so many changes that unless I go through a series of batches recreating what you did, I really can’t give you a definitive answer!! I’m so sorry. I’ve never blind-baked the pastries. One suggest is trying a baking stone. It will allow for more even heating. Do you have a brulee torch? That might help direct the browning to the custard and not the pastry. I used cream in the cookbook recipe because people found the cream easier to use. Either is fine.
Hi, I’ve always been too afraid to even try to make these, but finally dared with this recipe, and it was a glorious triumph (in my humble opinion)! Thanks.
But I’d like to join the call for a metric version, especially for the pastry: All the converters I use result in too liquid a dough for the pastry (260gr flour and 200 gram water). At the moment I’m just adding flour until it seems stiff enough… And does one really need 225gr butter? I found 200gr plenty.
Similarly for the filling, 260gr sugar makes this very sweet, and I’m no sugar minimizer.
All I want for Christmas is the metric version, please, I’ve been a good boy.
I have a suggestion that I’m sure will improve this in any oven, but especially in ordinary kitchen ovens (max. approx. 240 C): Heat the oven on the maximum for at least 40 minutes with a “pizza steel/oven” or similar heat accumulator. Place the tin directly on the steel, and see the pastry crisp up even right at the bottom, I frankly don’t think it is worth baking this otherwise in a normal kitchen oven
Andre…and you didn’t take notes as you cooked so you could figure out the metric?! (Just joking.) After the holidays, we plan on tackling this. Right now all our kitchens are bursting with recipe testing as well as recipes for our families. But hang in there, it’s coming!
Hi David
Do you have a video of this recipe, I’m a newbie at baking and just a little confused about folding the dough. Would be grateful if you can help, thanks.
Susan, I don’t. But there has been such a call for one, that I think I might have to make one!
That would be a great help if you can, I love eating these but not great at making them.
Can this be frozen once baked and if so for how long?
Nadine, nah. The texture of the custard and pastry will be less than ideal. Sorry.
Hi David! Thank you for the recipe. I just had a question.. it’s it 1 1/3 cups of sugar and 2/3 cups of water? Or is it 2 1/3 of water..? I want to make sure the ratio is exact. Thank you!
Hey, Jay. For the custard, it’s 1 1/3 cups sugar and 2/3 cup water. I’m not sure where you’re getting the 2 1/3 cups of water from. Can you tell me?
Hi, David. Great recipe! The method for the puff pastry though was a little bit too advanced for me. Butter kept seeping out because it was probably hot in the house. The result was the pastry did not have layers and didn’t puff up so much. Do you think rough puff pastry method can be used? Also, I was wondering if I can use a vanilla bean instead of extract. Thanks!
Rodney, yes, rough puff would work. Just make sure to do the rolling process because it creates the characteristic spiral. And yes, vanilla bean would work, too.
Dear David, is there a way to get the list of ingredients in grams? The converter on the page was of no help unfortunately. I bake a lot but I use scales- it’s easier and accurate. Scales are commonly used by home bakers across Europe. I can not even imagine trying to measure butter by spoon :) but being serious: not two cups of flour will weigh the same, as you know. Some flours are densely packed, some are not…
Marta, many thanks for your query. We completely agree with you that weights are vastly more accurate for baking. We’ve been including metric equivalents in our recipes for many months now but this recipe was developed prior to that using (you guessed it) cups and spoons. We’re retesting the recipe, using our metric conversions, and as soon as we have the amounts perfected we’ll drop you a note. Should take us no longer than a few days. Many thanks for your patience!
Thank you. I’m looking forward to revised recipe. I recalculated the recipe using on- line converters but I’m not sure if the end result was perfect. The dough was very pliable and soft, too soft to handle properly. Also my oven’s top temperature is 250C, What would be ideal baking time? I’d suggest adding slice of lemon rind as well as cinnamon stick while making custard and using a bit more salt in the dough.
Marta, was the dough pliable after it had been properly refrigerated? It shouldn’t have been.
As far as baking time, we didn’t test the recipe at 250°C, so you’ll have to watch carefully. My guess is an additional 3 to 4 minutes.
Many people do add lemon to the custard. That wasn’t what I was taught, but it is lovely!
Hi! I bought a couple of boxes in Lisbon as gifts and I couldn’t give them out today. Should I refrigerate them for tomorrow or just leave them?
Thanks!
Antonia, they can be refrigerated, but you might get some puddling of liquid (sugar) on top. Just blot them with a paper towel. I always like to reheat them in a warm oven before serving again.
Hello David,
A group of us are off to Lisbon and the Algarve next week and we had a planning dinner last night. A friend had told me about these tarts so I decided to make them and after surfing the net decided your recipe would be the closest to the real thing (which we’ve never had!)
I used commercial puff pastry and some smallish but not mini-muffin cups and despite my not reading your directions properly the tarts turned out not bad. In fact the others loved them! I just have a couple of suggestions, things that I found later by scrolling through the comments, that would be helpful if you added them to the directions: explain that the custard will be runny, but that it will firm up in the baking. (Other recipes require a thick custard so it becomes confusing). Also, you respond to one query by saying the dough should be paper thin, but you talk about 1/8″ in the directions. I think you could change that 1/8″ to 1/16″ as it makes a pretty thick base. Finally, as to the size of muffin tins, that is a challenge. I have several mini-muffin tins but they are smaller than your dimensions, so I had to go to one very old pan with smallish cups and one regular modern pan. There really wasn’t any difference in how they baked, other than I had to bake them for about 11-12 minutes. The hard part was figuring out how much pastry for each tin. I realised I had put too much in, but even so, the tarts were yummy. Thanks!
Hope, thank you so much for this. I’m so happy you enjoyed the tarts!
Hi David! Thanks for the recipe, I loved them. I have one small question though, mine didn’t turn out “shiny,” the custard comes out of the oven opaque…What could I be doing wrong?
Maira, I wouldn’t worry about it. But tell me, did they set up shiny when cool?
I just made these in standard muffin tins and they turned out PERFECT. I halved the recipe and got 12 muffin-sized pastéis. Read in the comments a bit, so I made sure the bottoms were thin and pricked with a fork. I pulled the dough up around the rim of the tins so it wouldn’t slide down too much, which worked fine, they shrunk just the right amount. About 7 min on 250°C, then 6-7 more on 225. Browned them a bit with one of those Créme Brulée -broiler thingies. My flatmates are already demanding more, so I will definitely do this again! Thank you!
Laura, you are more than welcome. So happy you and your flatmates like them! And what an excellent picture!!
Hi David!!
Greetings from Singapore. I tried your recipe, and I really liked the cinnamon blend to it. I think I didn’t do great on the crust, but I can definitely try again. If I’m making the crust and custard in advance, how long can in keep them in the fridge? Should it be kept freezed or chilled?
Appreciate all your help!
Arianne
Arcane, thanks of the kind words. I admit this recipe is a hard one. You can keep the custard mixture and dough in the fridge for a few days. The dough can be frozen up to 3 months. You shouldn’t freeze the custard mixture.
Thanks for your prompt response David. I’m looking forward to my next trial session. Thinking of blending in a little lemon and cream cheese for some of my folks who love ’em this way. But I’m gunna keep the lovely cinnamon definitely. =)
Arianne, not sure how it will work with the cream cheese, as it will change the consistency and chemistry of the custard. But let me know how it turn out!
Hi David! I can’t wait to try your recipe. My son is going to Lisbon early next month for some music festival. I am definitely asking him to bring me some pasteis tins. Can you suggest of other related stuff I should ask him to bring! When are you going to make a video of this recipe?
P.S. The website belongs to my son (junior), feel free to visit.
Eddie, hope you like it. I can say that what your son will have at the Confeitaria de Belém is a million times better than any recipe I have ever had from a home cook. The pastéis are divine. As far as related cooking items, how about a cataplana?
Hi David, i have not tried this recipe but i was just wondering if the 3-TBS flour for the custard was a typo or thats how it really was.
Luis, nope, that’s not a typo. It’s 3 tablespoons. Good luck!
Hi Dave,
Thank you so much for your recipe. Everyone at my son’s graduation party loved your tarts. I couldnt believe they turned out so well given it was my first try. I have one question though, the instructions said to roll out the dough into 18 in square but there was not enough dough to do that. The most I could do was 10-12 inch. Also, for anyone who wants it less sweet, I reduced the sugar down to 150 grams and it was still delicious!.
anh, so happy to hear they were such a success! Congratulations, and on your first time. About the dough square, my only advice would be to keep rolling. It takes time and patience, but you do get there.
Hi David……Do you have a recipe for Lemon Torte cake? (the one that looks like a rolled up pin wheel?)
Hi Susan, not a reliable one, and that’s what most important to me. If I find a good one, I’ll pass it on.
Hi David,
When storing the custard for later use in the fridge, do you warm it again prior to filling the pastry and baking it?
Hello, Peter, nope. Just ladle and bake.
Hi, David I’m making these for a school project. How do I ensure that they will turn out great and be tasty for my class? I’ve read some other comments about the dough. How do I make sure that does not happen to me?
Hi, Jessie. Unfortunately, there’s nothing I can say except follow the directions very, very carefully. To be extra sure, why not make a batch before the project, that way you can know exactly what the whole process is like.
David, do you ever use lemon at all for your pasteis? I’ve had some amazing ones in Portugal and I always taste a tiny hint of lemon in there. But I could be wrong I guess, I’m no expert.
John, I don’t, but some people do use a bit of lemon zest in the custard.
Hi David, can I make the pastry without any kind of mixer? Is there any other alternatives for not using mixer at all? I don’t want to buy pastry in supermarket but I don’t have a mixer. Many thaks before, Monika
Monika, you can mix the dough with a wooden spoon. That’s how it was done years and years ago.
Thanks a lot, David. Will try out this recipe next weekend :)
You bet, Monika.
Thanks for the recipe, I can`t wait to try it!
Could you clarify how much confectioner’s sugar to use? I don’t see an quantities listed.
Cheers!
Rob, that’s “to taste.” The sugar and cinnamon are sprinkled over the finished pastries.
Ahh, it’s used as a garnish. I saw it listed with the ingredients to make the custard, and thought it was added in with everything else.
Thanks for your quickly reply.
Rob, excellent catch. I’ve amended the recipe to reflect your comment. Thanks!
Hi David,
I am hoping to make the pastry tonight however, I have re-read the instructions (& read basically every comment) but I am still struggling with understanding what you mean here:
4. Brush the excess flour off the top of the dough, trim any uneven edges, and, using a small offset spatula, dot and then spread the left 2/3 portion of the dough with a little less than 1/3 of the butter being careful to leave a 1 inch plain border around the edge of the dough.
5. Neatly fold the unbuttered right 1/3 of the dough (using the pastry scraper to loosen it if it sticks) over the rest of the dough. Brush off any excess flour, then fold over the left 1/3 of the dough. Starting from the top, pat down the dough with your hand to release any air bubbles, and then pinch the edges of the dough to seal. Brush off any excess flour.
So I butter 2/3 of it, and then stretch the unbuttered 1/3 out so it covers the other 2/3 and roll? Sorry – I just cannot get my head around this point. I’ll have to youtube puff pastry recipes online to see if anyone uses a similar technique.
Thanks
Claudia.
Think of a letter, Claudia, that’s folded in thirds, but instead of the folds being horizontal, they’re vertical. (Have the top of the letter to the left, the bottom of the letter to the right.) Butter the top and middle sections of the “letter.” Fold the bottom third over the just the middle third. Now fold the top third over the bottom third–the same way you fold a letter. So now you should have a folded letter of dough that has three layers of dough with two layers of butter: dough, butter, dough, butter, dough. Better?
Thanks for the clarification David. We got there in the end (two of us figured it out haha). My dough is in the fridge now and I am going to make the custard tomorrow night. I think my dough came out all wrong though… Maybe there wasn’t enough flour because the butter kept bursting through the dough and it was very, very sloppy and sticking to everything and hard to work with. I didn’t use as much water as the recipe called for as I had read the reviews.
This is my first time ever making puff pastry so I expect many mistakes to be made. Do you have any tips for me? I’m in Australia so not sure if there’s a difference in cups to volumes?
Claudia, I won’t mince words: This is a hard recipe, especially the dough. It takes practice. You do want to make sure things are nicely dusted with flour; that’s make fiddling with it easier. Also, try rolling it out on a floured nonstick sheet, if you have it, and when the butter gets obstinate, slide the whole thing in the fridge for a few minutes.
David, thanks so much for the recipe. We were in Portugal last October and loved these!! We try not to overdo the sweets, but these tarts were so great we could not–and did not–resist!
You are more than welcome, Pam!
Hi David,
Wow! You have a lot of Q&A from people…so I apologize if this is a repeated question.
I will be going to Lisbon in a few weeks and am really looking forward to having A LOT of Pastel de Natas!!!!! So my questions to you are:
I know your recipe calls for All purpose flour, however, for true authentic Pastels de Natas do they use a specific flour that can be bought in Portugal or London? And, can you freeze the pastels for another day? If so, how do you recommend thawing it to obtain the crisp?
Wonderful blog by the way… very informative.
Kind regards,
Caliclare
Caliclare, I’ve not heard of the Portuguese using any particular type of flour. I’ve always be instructed to use all-purpose. And I wouldn’t suggest freezing. These little bad boys won’t do well in the freezer. And if I may, I suggest you try the pastéis at the Confeitaria de Belém. The original. And if you try to make these after you go, realize they won’t the same. It’s hard for a home version to live up to the great ones at the Confeitaria.
Hi David
I have been making these delicious custard cups for a while and I just have a question I’m hoping you can maybe give me some guidance. Lately if I save them from one day to the next they seem to crack in the center and look like they are old. Is there a reason this is happening. Any advice would be greatly appreciated. Thank you.
Sally
Sally, that’s not uncommon. Sudden cooling can cause them to contract and crack. So can overbaking. (Have you check your oven’s temp?) The thing is, these little jewels are best eaten the same day. They’re never as good as they are on the day you make them, hot out of the oven.
HI David,
I’ve made lots of different types of baked custards before. I recently learned about pastel de nadas and stumbled upon your blog. I wanted to try out the recipe, but as I’m reading it, it says to make a soft candy syrup. This is the first time I’ve heard of making a custard by cooking the sugar to the soft thread stage. Could you please tell me the purpose of this step?
Hi Cuong, from what the chef told me, you want the syrup temp high enough so that when it’s added to the milk-flour mixture it will cook off the flour flavor and makes the mixture warm enough, but not so warm that it will then cook the eggs.
Hi David,
Thank you so much for this recipe! I just attempted it for the first time, and it turned out pretty well, but I had a few issues (apologies in advance for the long post).
When making the dough, after adding the butter, folding, and rolling again, the butter squished out of the edges. I think this may have been because of air bubbles. I tried to get them out but I guess I didn’t get all of them. Is this normal?
Also, I found the pastry to custard ratio was higher than I would have liked. I think this is because of the mini muffin tins. I couldn’t fit much filling into each pastry. I was thinking of trying again with a full-sized muffin tin and was wondering if anyone has had success with full-sized muffin tins.
I also had an issue with butter dripping from the pan and smoking up my oven. I’m not sure if this is because the butter wasn’t fully contained in the layers of dough (see above)? The dough itself turned out pretty perfect–very similar to the authentic ones–so I’m inclined to think there was nothing too wrong with it.
Finally, a few of the natas lost most of their filling as it spilled over the top. I’m thinking this could also be fixed by using a larger muffin tin. Thoughts?
Thanks!
Melissa, first let me say the pastries look pretty damn good! Brava. Let me try to address your concerns the best I can.
1. With the squishing out of the butter, the air bubbles can cause that as well as getting the butter too close to the edge. Step 4 says to get the butter to 1 inch of the edge. This instruction takes into consideration the fact that it will spread when rolled again. If this begins to happen again, let the dough with the butter spread on top sit in the fridge for a bit. Also, your kitchen might be too warm.
2. Because it can be hard for larger pastries to cook all the way through before burning on the bottom is the reason we call for the mini-muffin tin. (As the LC note above says, the ovens in Portugal get up to 800 degrees, which flash bakes these.) Some folks have had success with regular-size muffin tins. Read through the comments for some tips. But also, you might be putting in too much dough for the size of your mini tins. Don’t worry about using all the dough. The raw shell itself should be thin on the bottom as well as the sides, getting slightly thicker at the top.
3. The butter dripping from the pan happens to me, too. Since they came out well, I wouldn’t worry about it.
4. The filling spilling over the top is most likely due to the bottoms of the dough shells being too thick. It expands, causing the custard to spill over.
gave these a bash now. only had two eggs, so had to apply some math to get the ratios right. the custard is runny like yellow milk, but i checked some comments and saw that’s normal. i didn’t do the dough, because as usual i don’t read a recipe a day or so before i try it. i ended up using a half roll of puff pastry, which turned out to be too much, sort of – i cut the slices a bit thick, so the pastry is about 5mm or so over the top. if i cut them thinner, then i think i would have been able to make a few more as there’s a little of the “yellow milk” left. :) i got about 12 out of it. i also think my muffin tray is a bit smaller than the one you suggest (it’s the only one we have).
i’ll have to try this recipe a few times to figure it out. i’m also quite keen to make the dough as well. i’ll give it another bash in a few weeks and do the dough on saturday so i can bake on sunday.
30 minutes later….
took them out the oven, let them cool down while i washed up the entire house (i tend to make the flour go EVERYWHERE) and finally made a coffee and sat down. took a bite and oh man, they’re nice. better than the shop’s ones i think. perfect for like a party snack seeing as they’re so tiny. great recipe. will definitely be doing this again.
(my wife’s engrossed in her writing, so she better snap out of it soon or else she’s going to end up only having the two i put on her plate… or i might also steal those and claim she was just imagining that i was baking)
wernich,
I’m happy you liked the pastéis. And you seem like a nice, decent guy, so I’m not going to chide. (But, dude! You gotta read the recipe! Think how much better they’d be.)
When you make them again, and I hope you will, tell me how they come out. And I certainly hope your poor wife, who was slaving over her writing, got to have a few.
i can’t believe it’s been this long since i made these the first time. this time i followed the recipe properly and even made the dough. i made the dough on sunday and then monday and tuesday turned out to be late working days, so only got to make it now. taking the effort to make the dough and not just use a roll of puff pastry certainly makes a difference. so crispy and flaky and makes a mess everywhere when you take a bite – perfect!
i’m super happy with how they turned out. even taking some to work tomorrow to show off… i mean share.
wernich, thanks. And you have my permission to show off. Show off gloriously!!
I just recently returned from a vacation in Portugal and ate these tarts at various bakeries including the quintessential Belem tarts. When I returned home I immediately had to make them myself and decided to try my luck with this recipe.
I used normal sized muffin tins and extended the baking time to 17 minutes. Many thanks for sharing this recipe!! I am so pleased with the results!!! I have been sharing them with my husband, family, friends, coworkers–and they all enjoy them!! I am being requested to bring them to parties and potlucks and they always go fast!!
Deb, you are more than welcome. I’m so happy you enjoy the recipe!
Hi David,
There is a high population of Portuguese people living in my community. I have had Pasteis de Nata at my local farmer’s market and instantly fell in love. I made puff pastry for the first time ever few days ago and went searching for recipes to try. I found this one and decided to give it a go (I love your site, been here many times). They came out absolutely fantastic. Your right, my oven did not brown the tops at all, but it didn’t matter much because they were still delicious. When my son came home his eyes nearly popped out of his head because he loves this dessert. I have never been to Portugal so I cannot compare but for me, I just wanted to say that, this recipe was amazing. Thank you for sharing with us!
Lynne, that’s wonderful to hear. So glad you and your son enjoyed the recipe! Any pictures, perchance?
what does “milk, divided” mean” ty.
Sure thing, Lisa. Take a look at steps 9 and 11. Step 9 calls for 1/4 cup milk while step 11 calls for the remaining 1 cup of milk. Together that’s 1 1/4 cups milk.
I am so confused regarding the pastry dough. The measurement were so exact, yet when I added 3/4 water plus two tablespoons to the 2 cups flour less two tablespoons, I ended up with very, very wet batter that could not be worked with. When I checked with other recipes they seemed to be using much less water which formed into something you could hold in your hand like pie dough.
It did not clean the sides of the mixing bowl and was more like a really thick cake batter.
I dumped half of it out and added more flour and now am waiting the 15 minutes before adding the butter/margarine. Hope it works!.
Jean, the dough is definitely not like pie dough. The directions refer to it as “soft pillow dough.” I just made a batch, and you can see it here. When poked with a floured finger, it holds the indent. I think you used too little flour or too much water.
Thanks for your quick reply! I could not wait and made a batch tonight. The pastry was nice and cold anyway.
I cooked them 10 minutes at 300C and got some tiny dark spots on the tops. After cooling down I tried one. the pastry is nice and flaky (although i will use even less water next time for the dough) but the custard overcooked and the taste is only sweet. I can’t find anything back of the lemon peel (I added instead of vanilla) let alone the cinnamon. Will tweak a bit, but there’s a start.. :)
tim, I think it’s great that you’re diving into this and have a good start already.
A few thoughts: Perhaps knock back your oven to 260°C/270°C? Also, is your oven calibrated?
Also, try cutting the sugar by a third. That should help. But know that this is truly a sweet treat.
as a baker your recipe makes me suspisious but I gave it a try.
The flour in europe is not as strong as in the US so for euro bakers put less water. The amounts giving here makes for a really wet dough, more a batter than a dough.
The soft butter makes it very easy to smear on the dough. It worked remarkably good.
The custard is extremely sweet but I guess that helps making the dark spots on the custard.
I did not really understand your custard making. I mixed the flour and milk. Heated the other part of the milk and mixed with the former. The sugar must just dissolve. It’s a pity the cinnamon stick is only in the mixture for such a short time. I left it overnight in the custard to infuse a little longer.
I used the following metric recipe.
230 g flour AP
150 g Water
2 g salt
225 g butter (soft)
Custard:
30 g flour
300 g Milk (divided into 60/240 gr)
270 g sugar
150 water
6 yolks
Pastry is in the fridge now. Will come back tomorrow. Thank you for this recipe it was hard to find a ‘good one’.
tim
tim, curious to see how it turns out.
Yes, European flours are very different than US flours. As far as the custard being sweet, the Portuguese like their desserts very, very sweet. It’s a hallmark of their cookery. A bit less sugar wouldn’t hurt the recipe.
Regarding the method of custard making, I try to be faithful to how I learned the recipe. The mixing of the small amount of milk with the flour is to make sure there are lumps. (But…I suspect this might be a step that was used when the chef may have used cornstarch; as you know cornstarch needs to be dissolved in a liquid before it added to our recipe.)
One last thing, the image is from the Confeitaria de Belém. They will look more like those in the comment from Rosa.
Oi David, thanks for the recipe! I was wonderful if it were possible to freeze the mixture for the pasteis themselves?
Dani, you’re welcome. I’m not really sure if you can do that. Freezing uncooked eggs changes their texture. I do know that people freeze the whole cooked pastry, but I find it becomes soggy when reheated.
Finalmente! Depois de muitas tentativas encontrei uma que fica bem em casa! Se bem que nao usei a calda toda… Obrigado pela receita!
Você é mais que bem vindo, Tina. Estou feliz que funcionou para você.
I’ve been making these since spending a summer in Albufeira and returning to the states a few years ago. I feel like it gave me a good start. I use muffin tins since that’s what I have on hand (I’m kicking myself for not buying tins while I was there). But I only use 3/4 cup sugar (per batch I usually double the custard – so 1.5 C for double the custard). Because made as is this was WAY sweeter than the Pastel de Nata we ate there. And part of what I love about them is how unsweet a pastry they are.
Hi Elizabeth, so glad you liked them. Traditionally these are a very sweet dessert. The Moors are responsible for introducing ultra-sweet eggy desserts to Portugal. And the bakery where these originated in the 1800’s still makes then quite sweet. I wonder if there’s a regional difference in Albufeira becuase it’s such a tourist destination?
I know this question is absolutely ridiculous but just simply love the custard from the Natas. Is there anyway to get the custard without having to make the dough?
Bryan, sure. But you can’t bake it. You’d have to spoon it from bowl and eat it.
Hi,
I have seen some recipes using heavy cream instead of milk. Witch one is more appropritate? And if it is milk, should it be whole milk ?
Can’t wait to make those !!
Thank you
camilla, it is a bit confusing, as “natas” means cream in Portuguese. But the recipes that I have, and have studied, use whole milk.
I’ve had this recipe saved as a bookmark for a long time, as I love these tarts, but for some reason never got round to trying it! I had tried some other recipes which never got near the real thing, so I suppose I had almost given up. We visit Portugal every few years as we have a family flat there opposite an incredible bakery, which we buy tarts from of course.
Anyway, just back from our last visit and I decided I needed to give it a go. It worked amazingly well! The pastry was so crisp and the custard just right. I didn’t expect such a good result in a normal domestic oven.
So, thank you! I will be making more of these (dangerous!).
Emily, what a delight to hear. I’m so happy that you enjoyed them. They’re one of my favorite. This dessert is extremely hard to do justice to, especially in the home oven. Brava to you!
Hi David, I grew up in Hong Kong where these are a serious local specialty (because of the closeness of Macau). Despite the fact that the area where I now live in Argentina had a big Portuguese immigration about 50 years ago, there isn’t a single place I can buy these and I never imagined I could make a decent version myself. But then I tried your recipe yesterday and they were AMAZING! Thank you so much! The pastry came out super flaky, the filling just right. Thank you thank you.
Victoria, you are more than welcome! I’m so happy you enjoyed them. They are a favorite around here, too.
Hello David,
I wonder if I can use a vanilla pod if I don’t have any vanilla extract?
Best regard
Ulla
Hello, Ulla. Sorry for the late reply; I was abroad. You really can’t use vanilla pods, as you won’t get the same flavor. But you can make your own vanilla extract with this recipe.
Thank you so much for this recipe! I went to Portugal a few years ago and had these in Belem, and was so happy to find the recipe on your website! I made them for Christmas Eve this year and even though I was sick and run down, I didn’t find this too complicated. They were a huge success! Such a lovely and simple dessert!! Thanks again!!
Jenna, how wonderful to hear. (Not the sick part, but that you found them easy to make and that they were a hit!)
Hi David,
I found your recipe a year back and always wanted to try making it because these are my favorite desert to buy when I visit my family in Portugal. My aunt has always discouraged me because apparently they are extremely difficult. Since I am a pretty decent cook I decided to try them tonight. I used the proper tins from Portugal and found that I needed to dot the dough with the fork a little because the pastry did blow up a bit in my trial run. I also found that the temperature was a little bit too high because my oven automatically turns 500 f to broil… I lowered it to 475f and found that it fixed the problem. Thank you again and I will look for your book!
Vanessa, you are more than welcome. And thanks for your tweaks. They might be able to help others–and that’s what we’re all about!
I can’t wait to make some of these! I was looking at a magazine that had a picture of delicious looking Portuguese Custard Tarts and when I Googled for a recipe, I found yours. Apart from my delight at finding it I’m loving reading the questions and your lovely responses! Thank you!
Catherine, thank you for your lovely words. I hope you like the recipe. These are mini pastéis, as the recipe says, so the final product is a bit different from those glorious ones at top, which are from the bakery in Portugal!
Well. I’m a baker at heart.
Born to bake, forced to work :) Anyway, I don’t have much time to fuss around and try recipe, adjust them to my liking and so forth…
So, when I find one that works the very FIRST time, I think it’s great! This recipe is wonderful!! came out perfectly, exactly like I wanted it and how it’s supposed to be. Easy step by step instructions make less intimidating.
The only bad thing: the little tarts are bite size and tend to disappear quite fast… Nice problem to have!
Thank you David! I’ll make this recipe many times more.
Rosa, first, the picture is gorgeous. Second, I adore you. I want to marry you–I don’t care if you’re already married. We can work it out. (The One won’t mind too much.) All kidding aside, thank you for the kind words. They went right to my heart.
The crust of the ones I made were quite hard and I don’t know why. I need HELP PLEASE!!!!!
Whitney, just to be certain: They were hard not crunchy? A few things. 1.) You used the correct amount of water? 2.) Did you refrigerate the dough the full amount of time? 3.) When you sliced the logs, did you notice an even spiral of butter and flour?
If the answer to all of those is, “yes,” you might not be used to working with puff pastry. In that case, I’d suggest using commercial puff pastry instead. Simply roll out one sheet, coat it with a thin layer of butter (so it will adhere), and roll it up as specified in the recipe. Chill it and cut into the correct size pieces.
I needed to make a Portuguese food for my 4th grader to share with his study group when they did country reports. I was all set to make Caldo Verde (a personal favorite — also easy!) but the kid lobbied for these instead. They were a huge hit! One of my son’s friends even asked me if I would make them for him for his birthday.
It was my first try at making puff pastry and your directions were great. I did have some trouble with the dough tearing in spots because it was so thin, but just kept finessing it, and it all worked out in the end. I felt like a genius when it baked up with the thin layers showing around the edges of the tarts!
I used my thumbs to begin shaping each slice of dough, as directed, but found that my pointer fingers worked best for getting it nicely shaped. Short fingernails are a must for this.
I somehow got 45 mini tarts out of this and still had a full cup of the custard mixture left over. I poured it into a well-buttered loaf pan so that it made a layer about 3/4 inch deep and baked it until set (about 10 minutes), oven temp turned down to 400°F, after all the tarts were out.
Thanks for a delicious, successful recipe!
emmegebe, how wonderful to hear! I love when kids are introduced to food at an early age. Do you by any chance have pictures?!
David,
I’ve been using your recipe for a while now and I’ve got to say it is an absolute winner. Over the years I’ve eat more than my fair share of natas and the ones I make using your guidance are simply brilliant.
Every time I make a batch I am struck by what seems to be little short of magic.
I remember the first time I followed your guidance and I must admit that I was really sceptical about the custard – it just seemed too liquid and I couldn’t see, even in a really hot oven, how it was ever going to firm up. You will know that never were doubts quite so misplaced, the custard was fantastic (and so was the pastry!)
I’ve had a real good search through as many nata recipes on-line and in cook books and none I’ve seen come close to yours.
So you have my unending thanks and admiration,
Natan