These Portuguese punched potatoes (called batatas a murro in Portuguese), are essentially crisp-skinned, creamy smashed potatoes smothered in caramelized onions and melted cheese. Sharing optional.
Punched Potatoes | Batatas a Murro
- Quick Glance
- 30 M
- 1 H, 40 M
- Serves 2 to 4
Bring a large saucepan of salted water to a boil, add the potatoes, and cook until tender, 20 to 30 minutes. Drain and let cool slightly.
Preheat the oven to 430°F (220°C).
Let the potatoes cool for about 10 minutes and then lightly smash them with your fist or the bottom of a heavy skillet. Place them in an ovenproof dish with the garlic and bay leaf, drizzle with 2 tablespoons oil, and gently turn to ensure they’re thoroughly coated. Season with salt and white pepper and bake until golden brown and crisp, 25 to 30 minutes.
Meanwhile, in a skillet over low heat, warm 1 tablespoon oil and then add the onions and season with salt and white pepper. Cook gently until very soft and translucent, about 20 minutes.* Try squeezing a piece of onion; it should be very soft and taste sweet. Increase the heat and let the onions caramelize and turn golden brown, stirring to stop them from sticking, about 5 minutes more. Remove the cartouche, if using, and set aside. Add a splash of sherry vinegar for a little bit of acidity that cuts through the cheese.
Take the potatoes out of the oven and scatter the onions and spoon or scatter the cheese on top. Return the dish to the oven and cook until golden brown and bubbling, 5 to 10 minutes. Remove from the oven and serve right away, sprinkled with a little cracked black pepper.
*HOW TO SPEED UP COOKING BY USING A CARTOUCHE
To hasten things along, you can cover the onions with a traditional French technique known as a cartouche (and pronounced “car TOOSH”) during cooking. It essentially traps a little more moisture and heat. Begin by cutting a large square of baking parchment slightly larger than your skillet. Fold it to make a triangle. Hold the triangle with the thin point over the center of the skillet. The end should extend slightly beyond the edge of the skillet. Unfold it, crumple it, and dampen it lightly with water, and then place it on top of the onions and cover with a lid.
Recipe Testers' Reviews
Crisp potatoes, sweet onions, and melted cheese…what’s not to love? This dish hit all the right notes and could easily become part of my go-to comfort food repertoire. And the good part is that it doesn’t feel too anything…neither too starchy, too oniony, or too oozing with cheese, but with just the right amounts combined to create a satisfying, soothing, warming side.
And the splash of vinegar in the onions was just right to cut through the rich cheese. I might not want to eat this on a hot summer night, but give me a cold, snowy winter day and this could easily be what I would want on my plate.
I used grated Gruyère, which worked extremely well with the other ingredients. I wouldn’t have wanted any more cheese than what was called for in the recipe.
The onions required about 20 minutes to become soft and translucent and another 20 to caramelize. I did not use a cartouche for this step, preferring to stir and watch them instead, and I did try the squeeze and taste test to confirm texture and flavor.
Makes 4 servings using enormous self-control not to eat it all myself.
It’s not just the Portuguese who favor the potato, onion, nd cheese combo, though I’m intrigued they’re interested in the stinky cheese spectrum. I wasn’t able to locate the queijo da Serra, or any Portuguese cheeses, unfortunately, and I wanted to go with the stinky idea, so I passed on the idea of Gruyere and went with the idea of a washed rind. I found a lovely seasonal from Belgium, Spring Chimay. It was nice and pungent and there was an aroma surrounding me on the train home and in the fridge where I kept the cheese overnight.
To cut to the chase, and then I’ll backtrack with some details, I could be the voice of this recipe: “I sometimes eat a whole bowl of this…,” and my fellow taster felt the same. However, the cheese virtually disappeared. When I placed it on the potatoes, it looked like a lot. When I took the potatoes out of the oven, with the cheese melted, it did not look like enough. We agreed that it could definitely use MORE cheese! And that double the cheese might not be too much! These could be eaten by the bowlful or divided but certainly not more than four servings.
With a salad, it could be a vegetarian lunch entrée. Even served alone, a green garnish would be visually appealing. We took out a variety of microgreens, which added a little sweetness, a little spiciness, and a little crunch.
A definite yes to the cracked black pepper atop, while still hot: cracked, and not too fine.
The melty cheese will never be better than right as it is pulled from the oven. Serve right away. We barely got the potatoes moved to plates before we were splitting the (four?!) servings two ways!
This was such an elegant and simple dish. I wouldn't necessarily call it completely no-fuss because there are a few steps that take a little time, but there isn't anything remotely difficult about it. It's comfort food at its best, and also makes for a great way to use up some aging potatoes and onions in the pantry. Leftovers are lovely heated up in the morning with some runny egg!
We loved these cheesy potatoes draped with sweet strands of onion and discovered a new cheese in the process.
I was pleased to be able to find the queijo da Serra at the cheesemonger’s in our local market. While it has a distinctive, strong taste, it is not overpowering. My husband typically doesn’t care for overly strong cheeses but had no objection to this cheese at all. It takes some time to prepare the dish, but the recipe itself is not difficult and the payoff is well worth it. It would have been great to have leftovers from this, but the recipe does not produce a particularly bountiful yield and two of us finished almost all of the potatoes as part of a meal with sausages and kale.
This is comfort food at it’s finest, a definite addition to our side dish rotation. It’s the simple ingredients, layered for flavor that makes it so special! It is also versatile in that it can go with almost anything, even just a side salad, and it’s component parts can all be prepped ahead.
We enjoyed this with salmon and a Sauvignon Blanc.
With a few minor tweaks, the recipe produced a great-tasting potato and onion combination. I especially enjoyed the texture differences between the crisp potatoes and the soft onions and gooey cheese.
I was inspired to try these punched potatoes by David's recent visit to Portuga. The food just looked fantastic!
I was surprised at how simple this recipe looked yet how delicious it was. I couldn't find queijo da Serra so I had to use Gruyere. I was reluctant to use any other type of cheese since I wasn't sure what this was supposed to taste like in its original form. Next time I will try Mont d'Or.
I didn't use the cartouche, I didn't feel like I needed to speed up the process since I was cooling the potatoes at the same time anyway. I kept the flame low and slow for sweet, tender onions.
I didn't think the cheese was going to be enough but once I shredded it, it was plenty. I found that the only problem with the Gruyere was that it made the dish a tad bit salty. I would dial back the amount of salt I use on the potatoes next time.