This easy eggnog is made with melted ice cream, bourbon, dark rum, cinnamon, and nutmeg. The ice cream makes it rich and easy to toss together. A Christmas cocktail classic.
Eggnog can be a pain to make and most store-bought versions fall flat. But we can’t go through a festive season without some of this quintessential festive drink, so here’s our version of a super quick and tasty ‘nog—perfect for your next holiday gathering.—Eric Prum and Josh Williams
Easy Eggnog FAQs
What kind of ice cream should I use in this eggnog?
Whether you go with ice cream that you’ve made or from a store, we recommend one that has lots of eggs in it. We have a few with that custardy consistency on the site, including the one listed in the ingredients.
How warm does my ice cream need to be to make this eggnog?
You’ll want it to be soft enough to scoop easily, so warmer than rock hard for sure. After that, it depends on how thick and icy you want that ‘nog. Make it with very cold ice cream for something closer to a milkshake, let it melt quite a bit for something thinner. Just don’t forget to put the carton back in the freezer!
- Cocktail shaker; coupe or martini or old-fashioned glasses (optional)
- Before you do anything else, place 2 coupe or martini or old-fashioned glasses or whatever stemware you've got in the freezer.
- Divvy the creamy eggnog concoction between the chilled glasses. If you want, add a pinch cinnamon or nutmeg for garnish. Serve the eggnog without delay.
Recipe Testers’ Reviews
To me, this easy eggnog has the richness of eggnog without the heaviness. While I’m a lover of good eggnog, sometimes it can be just a little too much. I sometimes feel that I want just one more, then I regret it.
I used a very high-quality vanilla ice cream made with whole vanilla bean. I also made sure when making this eggnog to use both high-quality bourbon and rum. The total ice cream was just a little over 1/2 cup. I also used freshly grated nutmeg. I think next time I make this, I’ll start with a little less ground cinnamon and increase as needed. Can’t wait to try this easy eggnog with Irish whiskey or Irish Mist for St. Patrick’s Day. I certainly won’t keep this recipe just for the holiday season as it’s nice for any wintertime festivities.
Eggnog is a must during the holiday season. Some years I make it from scratch and others I buy it. I have a good friend who makes her milk punch with ice cream like in this easy eggnog, but I’ve never thought to do that with eggnog. It sure is easier than the time-consuming traditional method, which basically involves making a custard base.
With high-quality vanilla ice cream, the custard base is already made for you! Plus, the creaminess that the ice cream imparts is out of this world. I like the use of both rum and bourbon here—they complement each other well and pair nicely with the warm spices. Yes, as the recipe instructed, I did use a strainer to pour the cocktails into their chilled glasses; it was the easiest way in my mind to serve these delicious after-dinner drinks.
Who knows? This eggnog was so good, I might not be able to wait for the holidays to get here to make it again!
Originally published December 16, 2018