LC To Stir or Not to Stir Note
Here’s something you may not have thought to try–adding a splash of water to mushrooms in a skillet when you sauté ’em. And adding the aromatics AFTER the cooking is done, not a moment before. The recipe also, in a moment of seeming craziness, stipulates that you not stir the mushrooms. Not at all. The water works magic, the aromatics get the edge taken off their rawness by residual heat, and as for not stirring, well, that depends on the type of mushroom and the flame beneath the skillet containing said mushrooms. Do as you wish. Sturdy shiitakes could probably withstand not stirring, but more tender ‘shrooms, like chanterelles, tend to need a little toss. But why not live on the edge? Follow your whim. Watch ’em carefully and if, toward the end of cooking, you think they need a stir to cook them evenly, so be it. And if you care to toss in the garlic and shallot just a smidge sooner, we’ll look the other way.
- Quick Glance
- 25 M
- 35 M
- Serves 4
To make the pan roasted mushrooms, heat your largest skillet, preferably cast-iron, over medium-high heat. Add the oil and wait for 30 seconds. Add the mushrooms and water and cook, without stirring or, okay, stirring just once or twice, until the mushrooms are crisp at the edges and golden, about 8 minutes or maybe even 12 minutes, depending on the type of mushroom.
Remove the skillet from the heat, stir in the butter, shallots, thyme, chives, and garlic, and toss just until the butter melts. Season to taste with salt and pepper.
Recipe Testers' Tips
I used wild foraged chanterelle mushrooms, and this was a delicious way to prepare them. I was dubious about not stirring or shaking the pan while they cooked, but the end result was perfectly roasted mushrooms. I can’t wait to make them again.
We bought a wonderful selection of wild mushrooms from the mushroom purveyor at our farmers’ market. We used organic tree oysters, king trumpets, and pioppinis. We used a cast-iron skillet to cook them in. I had never added water with mushrooms when cooking them, but I will be trying that again. After just a few minutes, the mushrooms began to caramelize. I added the herbs as well as the shallots and garlic and, last, some butter, all earlier than the recipe suggests because I didn’t want the condiments raw. The resulting mushrooms were very golden, moist, and yet a bit crispy, and really delicious. This is a method that I will use again.
I found that the mushrooms started to caramelize by the end of the 8 minutes, so I would recommend perhaps stirring the mushrooms once and cooking them a little longer to ensure that they are more evenly caramelized. I used 4 tablespoons butter, and while it was tasty in the finished dish, I was left with a small puddle of butter on the plate, so I would suggest using perhaps a little less butter. Neither the garlic nor the shallot was too raw in the final dish.
Sometimes you open your fridge and need to cook up whatever is lurking. And so it went for my baby portabella mushrooms. When I looked at this recipe, I realized it was a technique I had never used and was anxious to try it. Adding water? Not stirring? Add the flavorings at the end off the heat? All of these thoughts were counterintuitive to me but I grabbed my enameled cast iron skillet and got to work. Admittedly I did not measure my sliced mushrooms, instead I used 12 ounces. I cut back on the water and flavorings a bit and in 10 minutes I had the most delicious roasted mushrooms with caramelized edges. The flavorings cooked from the residual heat in the pan (the beauty of cast iron!) which means the garlic and shallots were mellowed and went great with the thyme and chives. I used far less butter than called for just because that is how I cook. And I only stirred twice! The end product was fantastic. I actually ended up using it as an omelet filling for some farm fresh eggs. It would make a fabulous side dish for any meat, fish, or chicken.