LC Shake With Caution Note
Please do shake your Mean Shandy with caution. That’s the warning conveyed by the authors to you, dear reader. It may sound like something from Dick Clark’s days of hosting American Banstand, but the caveat actually pertains to the making of this lovely little cocktail and it goes something—actually, it goes exactly like—this: “Shaking carbonated liquids in any quantity presents possible hazards, so make sure the shaker is tightly sealed. Open carefully once shaken.”
- Quick Glance
- 5 M
- 5 M
- Serves 1
Special Equipment: Cocktail shaker (optional); straws (optional)
Pour the bourbon, Lemonade Syrup, and beer into a shaker with ice and shake. (You can instead use a jar with a lid or a pitcher and a wooden spoon.)
Strain the mixture into an old-fashioned glass filled with fresh ice. Garnish with the lemon slice and, if you feel so inclined, a couple straws (ostensibly for sipping the shandy faster). Cheers!
Recipe Testers Reviews
Loved this Mean Shandy recipe! We used a Rogue chipotle ale (we had nothing else on hand) and it was fabulous! This drink had a serious kick, which was a nice surprise. I was expecting it to be a "lighter" drink, but one was plenty for me, thanks to the bourbon. The lemon syrup was an amazing addition. Fun summer drink, for sure.
Oh, the sacrifices I make in the name of recipe testing. I'll have you all know that in order to be perfectly thorough in my investigation of this Mean Shandy recipe, I made a second shandy to confirm the findings of my first...hic…cocktail. Second test confirmed the first—this recipe's a winner! Boozy, mildly sweet, and slightly effervescent, it's a perfect summer sip.
Upon my first read of the recipe, I admit that I was a bit skeptical. It could be because I'm somewhat of a beer and bourbon purist, and the thought of tainting either with lemon syrup was a real stretch for me. In the end, though, the beer (a Long Trail IPA) and the bourbon (Bulleit Frontier Whisky) got along just swimmingly with the made-from-scratch syrup.
Aside from the somewhat fussy measuring involved (in the future, I'll do the math required to make a "batch" of these drinks and not make them one by one), the drink couldn't have been easier to make. I'm a fan.
Beer cocktails can be funny things. The idea of mixing things with beer may not sound that appealing, but in this case it results in a well-balanced cocktail. There isn't really that much beer in here, so the taste is dominated more by the lemon and bourbon. The beer just gives it a gentle fizz and malty quality. We found it to be a refreshing way to have a bourbon cocktail in the summer. I used Omission Pale Ale and I used the lemonade syrup recipe from this site, but went a bit easy on the sugar since I don't like my drinks too sweet. We just loved the balance of flavors. It's a fairly strong cocktail, but if you need to relax in a hurry on a summer's eve, this is just the ticket.
The "Mean Shandy" has the potential to be a really good party cocktail, one which I'm sure you could make a huge batch of for a cookout or something. I used Brooklyn Summer as my beer addition, as it seemed fitting for the theme of the cocktail. However, I wonder how maybe a slightly heavier beer (Brooklyn Lager, for instance) would've been. I wanted it to be more refreshing than it was, as is it was a bit strong and syrupy tasting. To balance the flavors, I topped the cocktail with a little more beer, roughly another 1 1/3 ounces. Luckily I had the lemonade syrup on hand already, so this probably took about 5 minutes from start to sipping. While I do typically enjoy beer cocktails, and this one is no exception, I feel it was a little heavier than I wanted it to be. I haven't given up on the Mean Shandy though; I'll revisit it.
I just had to try this, because at first I couldn't see how this combination of ingredients could possibly be good. But I'm very glad I tried it! The combination of the bourbon and the carbonation from the lager reminds me of a bourbon and soda with a much more intense flavor, and the sweetness from the lemonade syrup seems to balance it out and bring it all together. I was surprised at how refreshing this drink is. I already had the lemonade syrup on hand because I'd just made lemonade for the grandkids. All said, it only took about 5 minutes to put the drink together.
Three good ingredients make this drink great. I bought all my components, spent a few minutes prepping, and another moment getting everything in its place. The taste was phenomenal. I used a Texas Red from Rahr made in Fort Worth, Texas.