Lime frozen yogurt with black pepper is a perfect summertime treat. A light refreshment after dinner or something sweet that won’t weigh you down during those long, hot afternoons. Black pepper may sound unusual and counterintuitive, but trust us, it works.
Adapted from Sabrina Ghayour | Simply | Mitchell Beazley, 2020
Why I didn’t think of this recipe years ago is beyond me. Simply put, if you want something to refresh your palate after a heavy meal and give you just a hint of sweetness and plenty of satisfaction, then this is for you. It’s probably the most surprising little sorbet you could try–it sounds like it shouldn’t work but it really, really does.– Sabrina Ghayour
WHY WOULD YOU PUT BLACK PEPPER IN FROZEN YOGURT?
So, you might be taken back at the suggestion of swirling a little bit of black pepper into your lime frozen yogurt but it’s actually a truly inspired idea. Black pepper is primarily used in savory dishes for a touch of heat but it has sublime floral and fruity undertones. And the creamy fat in the yogurt tamps down the spiciness a little bit, leaving you with a flavor profile that works really well with the lime frozen yogurt. Use whole black pepper that you’ve ground freshly for the occasion, it makes all the difference.
☞ Contents
Lime Frozen Yogurt with Black Pepper
Equipment
- Ice cream maker
Ingredients
- 2 cups store-bought or homemade Greek yogurt
- 1/2 cup confectioners’ sugar
- Finely grated zest and juice of 1 fat lime preferably organic
- 1 teaspoon freshly ground black pepper
Directions
- In a medium bowl, combine the yogurt, sugar, lime zest and juice, and pepper.
- Pour the yogurt mixture into an ice-cream maker and churn for about 15 minutes, or according to the manufacturer’s instructions. This frozen yogurt is best served straight from the ice-cream maker.
Show Nutrition
If you make this recipe, snap a photo and hashtag it #LeitesCulinaria. We’d love to see your creations on Instagram, Facebook, and Twitter.
Recipe Testers’ Reviews
As the recipe mentions, this is a refreshing frozen yogurt. I feel like it would make a great dessert after a spicy meal. The only funky part was finding crushed peppercorns now and then in my mouth when eating it. I added a pinch of coarse salt, which I add to all ice cream recipes. I also appreciate that this didn’t make a whole quart of frozen yogurt, I like the scaled-down amount.
Bright refresher with a crisp balance of lime and creamy yogurt, and the accent of black pepper that makes this lime frozen yogurt with black pepper completely enticing. The black pepper and lime seem to boldly go in independent directions, yet together create a delicious tension. The math-inclined side of the household described it as orthogonal (at right angles), a word I’ve never used to describe food before. These are such intense elements, yet together they build an accord with the creamy tartness of the yogurt that I don’t think you’d get with milk or cream.
This recipe comes together with so little work, the biggest decision is to make sure your ice cream maker bowl is in the freezer the night before. I almost always have Greek yogurt on hand as well as limes. No worries about if you should use full fat, it delivers a creamy result with non-fat. I did sift the powdered sugar so there were no lumps and tossed the zest and pepper in a bit of the sifted sugar to help make sure the zest didn’t clump.
Normally my ice cream maker takes about 20 minutes, but I think I’d stop short of that next batch, maybe 15 minutes, as getting the last frozen layer out called for some creative persistence, but after one taste I wasn’t about to leave any behind. Although this seems like a small batch, I think the refreshing intensity works so well I’d serve it as a palate cleanser in smaller portions. Two small scoops in a cortado or affogato-size cup were a perfect cooler on a triple-digit summer day.
HUNGRY FOR MORE?
If you make this recipe, snap a photo and hashtag it #LeitesCulinaria. We'd love to see your creations on Instagram, Facebook, and Twitter.
This was a fantastic ending to an Indian dinner party. I made especially for a dinner guest who can’t eat eggs, thus this simple frozen yogurt fit the bill. The black pepper was unexpected and surprising, and I’ll make it again.
Thanks, Linda! Can’t wait to hear what you make next.
This recipe was very quick and easy to make. I made mine with 2% Greek yogurt and it came out very creamy. The black pepper is much more subtle than I expected, but goes very well with the lime. I ate a small bowl right away, and then put the rest in popsicle molds to enjoy later.
I’m so pleased to hear that you loved this, Tara. Love the popsicle suggestion!
THANKS!
You’re very welcome, Rainey. Happy shopping!
Not convinced that lime yogurt with pepper is something I need but I think I do need that green bowl. Is that something that’s available?
Good news, Rainey! Though not exactly the same, we found something similar.
Right, Rainey? It’s quite spectacular. (As is the frozen yogurt!). I’ll check with our product specialist and see if she’s seen anything similar.