We first ate this cake in the fruitful Val di Non in Trentino, where orchards abound. Back home we didn’t know which apple variety to use, so we called Karen Bates, of the Philo Apple Farm in the Anderson Valley in California, who passed on these tips: Early apples tend to break down very easily—great for applesauce and very tender, juicy pies. Midseason apples cook up fairly tender and hold their shape, while late-season apples border on staying a little too firm and are a lot less juicy. So make your applesauce early in the season and store your late apples as long as you can. We decided on Golden Delicious for their rich perfume and the ability to hold their shape when cooked.–Melissa Hamilton and Christopher Hirsheimer
LC Did You Read The Above Note? Note
Did you read the above note? There’s some serious wisdom in there about the seasonality of apples and what to do with the various varieties in the kitchen depending on when they show up at your local farmers’ markets. Print it out and tape it to the inside of a cabinet, tuck it into your billfold, stick it to your forehead if you have to, or do whatever it takes to commit it to memory. Just don’t forget it.
- Quick Glance
- 30 M
- 1 H, 30 M
- Serves 8 to 10
Special Equipment: 9-inch springform pan
IngredientsEmail Grocery List
Recipe Testers Reviews
My husband declared with much pomp and circumstance that this cake is his favorite thing I’ve have ever baked. I kid you not. And I agree. This cake made me his kitchen superhero and that’s the hallmark of a great recipe. Delicious! I must memorize it.
This is a very plain yet very pretty little cake. Simple, straightforward preparation and simple, straightforward flavor, in which apple is the star. No cinnamon, nutmeg, or brown sugar, so definitely select tasty apples. One surprise: I didn’t expect the cake to look quite so pretty. The apples sink into the cake in places and, aided by the sugar on top, leave slightly lacy, almost crunchy edges, which are pleasing on their own and great for a little vanilla ice cream to settle into.
This is a lovely snack cake. It’s simple to make, not too sweet, and is really nice with tea or coffee, morning or afternoon.
All my tasters enjoyed this one. I heard lots of mmms while everyone was enjoying his or her slice. I found the instructions for how to place the apple slices a bit confusing, though I understood better after looking at the photo. Mine wasn’t quite as pretty as in the photo but this didn’t deter from the taste. I’ll definitely be making this one again. The zest gave it such a bright flavor.
This is a very happy cake. Even though the apples I used weren’t the best and they sunk into the cake, I still had to stop myself from going back for a second piece. The cake itself is tender and moist and stays that way for a few days thanks to those lovely apples. Don’t skimp on the lemon zest—it adds a lovely zip. Oh, and 2 large Golden Delicious were plenty for ringing the top of the cake.
Apple Cake—a simple name for a simply delicious cake. I was curious about this recipe, as for years I’ve been making “Teddie’s Apple Cake” of New York Times Cookbook fame and wanted to see how a recipe from The Canal House folks stacked up against a classic. In short, this beauty didn’t disappoint. This cake is at once simpler and fancier than Teddie’s. Simpler in that it has a pared-down flavor profile of just lemon and apple, but fancier in the way it shows its apples to the world, spiraling inward across the top of the cake. I used 3 fairly large Golden Delicious apples, sliced to about 1/2 inch at the outside edge, and they fit beautifully with only 2 slices to spare. The batter is a breeze to concoct and is easily spread into the pan. The apples, which at first seem to overwhelm the batter, nestle in nicely as the cake rises to partially encase them when cooking. In the end, the golden crust of the batter, crunchy with crystallized sugar, covers about half of each apple slice, leaving the balance exposed in a beautiful pattern. Upon cutting, the cake seems a bit dry to the eye, but once in the mouth is meltingly tender, kept moist by the juice of the apples. As for taste, the generous addition of lemon zest was a perfect sweet-citrusy complement to the fruit, and allowed the cake to achieve a balance that we enjoyed morning, noon, and night. Yes, this cake is delicious as breakfast! The recipe states a baking time between 50 and 60 minutes, but mine was done at 45, so do start checking for doneness early. For its simplicity and elegance, this cake is a must for sure.