Hoosier Sugar Cream Pie

The recipe for sugar cream pie traveled across the prairie in covered wagons with the earliest settlers of the Indiana Territories. According to pie lore, it was a great favorite of pioneering farm wives who, to avoid washing utensils or a bowl, would throw the few staple ingredients in an unbaked pie shell and mix with their fingers before rushing back to their work in the fields.

At Hoosier Mama, we prebake the pie shell and use utensils, but the basic recipe—cream and sugar thickened with a little flour—remains unchanged. The flavor is wonderful—somewhere between crème brulée and melted caramel ice cream, depending on the exact recipe. Recipes are closely guarded and passed down from generation to generation, with each family claiming its recipe is best. Our recipe, somewhat controversially, calls for both white and brown sugar.

It’s a homely pie by any standard and it languished in the pie case until we started handing out samples. Now it’s a customer favorite.–Paula Haney

LC Crack Pie Note

Talk about the sum being exponentially more than the parts. This pie is quite, quite similar to the much ballyhooed Crack Pie sold by the much, much, much more ballyhooed Momofuku Milk Bar—part of the David Chang kingdom—in New York City. Seriously, folks. You have got to taste this pie. One bite and you’ll understand the moniker.

Sugar Cream Pie Recipe

  • Quick Glance
  • 20 M
  • 5 H
  • Makes one 9-inch pie

Ingredients

  • 1 single-crust blind-baked All-Butter Pie Dough Shell
  • 1/2 cup granulated sugar
  • 1/2 cup dark brown sugar
  • 2 tablespoons all-purpose flour
  • Pinch kosher salt
  • 2 cups (1 pint) heavy cream
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla extract or vanilla paste
  • Confectioners’ sugar, for dusting

Directions

  • 1. Preheat the oven to 400ºF (200ºC).
  • 2. Place the pie shell on a rimmed baking sheet. Set aside.
  • 3. Combine the granulated sugar, brown sugar, flour, and salt in a medium bowl. Mix with a whisk or your hands to break up any clumps and to combine ingredients. Gently stir in the heavy cream with a wooden spoon or spatula. Do not overmix. (Whipping the cream will prevent the pie from setting.) Stir in the vanilla extract or paste.
  • 4. Pour the filling into the prepared pie shell and bake for 20 minutes. Rotate the pie 180° and bake for 20 to 25 more minutes, until large bubbles cover the surface. The pie will not appear to be set when it comes out of the oven.
  • 5. Let the pie cool to room temperature, then put it in the refrigerator to chill for at least 4 hours and up to overnight. Dust with confectioners’ sugar before slicing and serving. (The baked pie can be stored in the refrigerator for 3 to 5 days. Some Hoosier Mama Pie makers at the bakery like to throw leftover Sugar Cream Pie slices in the freezer and snack on them frozen.)
Hungry for more? Chow down on these:

Comments
Comments
  1. Testers Choice Testers Choice says:

    [Lila Ferrari] You definitely don’t have to be a Hoosier to enjoy this pie. Super easy to make—your favorite baked pie crust, cream, and sugar. The baking was the longest part of the recipe. I chilled the baked pie overnight and served it for dessert the next day. The slices were easy to get out of the pie pan, which was a nice change from leaving half the crust in the pan. I was half (maybe three-quarters) expecting the filling to be very sweet. Not only was it not overly sweet, but it had a nice caramel flavor from the brown sugar and long baking time. The filling itself wasn’t rigid but soft and it didn’t weep or flow when cut. The crust was flaky and rigid, which gave a nice crunchy contrast to the soft filling. I think the confectioners’ sugar dusting was just to gild the lily, so to speak. A dollop of unsweetened whipped cream might be good with the pie also. But this pie can definitely stand on its own.

  2. Testers Choice Testers Choice says:

    [Natalie R.] This is a very unique pie. The flavor and texture are reminiscent of a combination of crème brulee and chess pie. It’s so creamy yet sweet. I followed the directions and didn’t whisk the cream and sugars for very long—it was about 30 seconds, just long enough to combine all the ingredients, but that was all. I was concerned the filling would come out grainy, but the end result had a light yet creamy feel. The pie emerged from the oven with what looked like a layer of clear butter on the surface. It was a bit disconcerting. Once my pie cooled to room temperature, I placed it in the refrigerator overnight and it was completely set when we were ready for dessert. The baking time was spot-on and the recipe was easy to follow. This one will make it to my dessert table again.

  3. Testers Choice Testers Choice says:

    [Adrienne Lee] This was the perfect combination of taste and ease. The ingredients come together in absolutely no time. I followed the instructions and didn’t whip the mixture; instead, I gently stirred in the cream. The baking time was just right for my pie. Actually, the pie set up a little sooner than 4 hours. The texture was smooth and the flavor was great. I’d make this pie again.

  4. ruthie says:

    Ooh! This is very like a Mennonite recipe I got years ago, but that uses canned milk (plain evaporated) rather than cream. I use it as a base for an apple tart sort of thing, using only abut half the filing, with apple wedges sprinkled with cinnamon and ground coriander set on top of the filling before baking. They sink in a bit, and it makes a nice slightly rustic dessert for after a simple meal.

    I do like cream, though. ;) I may have to give this version a try.

    • Renee Schettler Rossi says:

      Nice! And who’s to say, ruthie, that you can’t serve this with a nice apple compote of sorts using your spices on the side?

      • ruthie says:

        Too sweet and heavy for me as a whole pie. The half filing with apples is my antidote…. ;)

        I wonder if it would set up if you used buttermilk. There’s buttermilk pie, right?

        • Renee Schettler Rossi says:

          Ah, gotcha, ruthie. Makes perfect sense. And yes, what you suggest is essentially buttermilk pie, at least in theory. Although I wonder if the proportions of the ingredients would be the same due to the different viscosity and acidity of the buttermilk compared to milk. I just checked, and this cookbook—which is brilliant, by the way—uses different proportions of the basic ingredients and also sneaks some lemon juice and nutmeg into the filling. It also uses a different technique for combining the ingredients. In short, I’d suggest you seek out a buttermilk pie recipe. If we may be so bold, we’d suggest you splurge and get yourself this book. We’re over the moon for it.

  5. Being a Hoosier, I can safely say that any Sugar Cream Pie is worth eating, but I have NEVER had one with brown sugar … I sense an experiment coming on! However, someone may need to roll me in to work tomorrow.

    • Renee Schettler Rossi says:

      Hah! The author cops to this blasphemy in her note above the recipe, Michael. And we gotta say, we haven’t had the real deal from Hoosier Land, but we are squarely in favor of this version. Really curious to hear what you think!

  6. Susan says:

    Just finished baking this amazing pie for Thanksgiving. One question, why blind bake the pie crust? I had to cover the edges while it was baking with the filling.

    • David Leite says:

      Hello, Susan. Any custard pie, nut pie, etc., all of which have a very liquid filling, need to be blind baked, otherwise the bottom crust will be soggy. When you make this again, and I know it’s a “when” and not an “if,” cover the edge of the pie with foil strips or this handy dandy pie shield, which is what i use when my crusts start getting too dark.

      • Susan says:

        Definitely a “when!” This was the favorite of all the Thanksgiving desserts!

        • Renee Schettler Rossi says:

          Woohoo, Susan! Love to hear that! Many, many thanks for letting us know! (It’s just crazy good, right?!)

  7. Jamie says:

    The recipe I have been waiting for! I love when something is both so homey and so spectacular. And another cookbook on my wish list. Thanks, guys!

    • David Leite says:

      Jamie, its a killer pie–and “killer” in all the right ways. A friend of mine who shall remain nameless (you know who you are, Ellen) is not a baker in the least, but she pulled this off without a hitch. Easy-peasy and sensationally good.

Have something to say?

Then tell us. Have a picture you'd like to add to your comment? Send it along. Covet one of those spiffy pictures of yourself to go along with your comment? Get a free Gravatar. And as always, please take a gander at our comment policy before posting.

*

Daily Subscription

Enter your email address and get all of our updates sent to your inbox the moment they're posted. Be the first on your block to be in the know.

Preview daily e-mail

Weekly Subscription

Hate tons of emails? Do you prefer info delivered in a neat, easy-to-digest (pun intended) form? Then enter your email address for our weekly newsletter.

Preview weekly e-mail