Fish Tacos with Creamy Chipotle Cabbage Slaw

I love fish tacos, and these were really good. I used tilapia, and it held up really well to the frying. I think that a little more salt could be used in the flour and chipotle mixture, but this was fixed with a light salting after removing the fish from the oil.

I especially liked the slaw and think that it really made the dish. The slaw held up nicely after the initial refrigerator time. The next day, it was also okay, but it did require some mixing because there was more liquid. The flavors were still there and undiluted.

If you like things a bit spicier, you could definitely increase the chipotle or add a nice spicy salsa. Although the recipe didn’t include these items, I think adding a nice salsa and even guacamole would really bring the flavors together. The tacos are good on their own, but these items would just take it to another level. I will definitely be making it again in the future.

How would I describe this fish tacos recipe? Simply delish! I used a nice Pacific cod, which was the perfect complement to the bold chipotle slaw. My intention was to make the recipe exactly as written. I must say I was on track to do so until I saw the basket of market-fresh cherry tomatoes on the counter. At the last moment I added a handful of these flavor bombs, diced in half, to the slaw. We really enjoyed the freshness and bright flavor the tomatoes added to the slaw as well as the beautiful color.

I did find that the recipe made much more chipotle dressing than required to dress the slaw. This worked perfectly for me as I used a bit of the remaining sauce to dress the tortilla before layering the pan-fried fish and slaw on the tortilla. As my kids like white extra-sharp Cheddar cheese on their fish tacos, I made half the batch with the addition of the cheese. Both versions were divine. My teenage daughter said we should have these more often.

Some augmentations that would be fun to try in the future: Add jicama for crunch and a way to tone down the sauce, should it be too spicy for your diners. Although totally out of the norm for Baja-style fish tacos, I enjoy a garnish of fresh tomato salsa on my fish tacos and, if I’m really hungry, a slice of avocado as well. I also plan to make the slaw separately to serve with other dishes—grilled/fried/baked chicken, pork roast recipes, pulled pork, and just about any seafood dish. This slaw would be the perfect zesty side dish or salad for picnics or buffets. The ingredients are available year-round, which makes this recipe good for any day of the year.

We really enjoyed these fish tacos. I made them with cod, the special at the fish market that day. It looks like there are a lot of ingredients for the slaw, but the recipe is straightforward, simple, and comes together quickly and easily.

Since there was chipotle powder on the fish, I left it out of the slaw. With the slaw only resting for 20 minutes, I didn’t refrigerate it because I didn’t want ice-cold slaw going onto my hot fish. Otherwise I followed the instructions exactly.

We liked the slaw so much that I was glad I didn’t decrease the recipe, even though we had about half of it left over. We just ate it with some juicy burgers the next night. Weeping wasn’t much of a problem, even on the second day. There was just a little liquid, which I stirred back into the slaw. Since my preference is for crunchy tacos, I tried mine in store-bought crispy shells and liked those.

We loved this slaw! We made it 2 days in a row, and we will make it again. The second time I substituted good olive oil for the mayo, and our tasters ate it all with compliments. I cannot help but futz around with this type of recipe. I’ll definitely try adding other vegetables, like jicama and cucumber. Lena will make the recipe again, too, without the red onion, which she thought was too vibrant. A delicious slaw!

I am torn. I love fish tacos, and this is not my idea of one. However… if I had to rate the chipotle slaw alone, I’d give it the highest rating—it’s that darn good. It’s so flavorful that it completely overwhelms the fish, so I’d be inclined to try it with roast pork or as a side dish.

Making the slaw is straightforward. I used goat’s milk yogurt in place of the Greek yogurt. Although much thinner, it didn’t yield a watery dressing. I added the cumin and chipotle powder, which I wouldn’t suggest omitting. If you’re sensitive to spicy foods, you could do without the jalapeño, but I like my food to bite back!

I used fresh weakfish fillets, which are delicately flavored but hold together well. I cooked them for 4 minutes on the first side and 3 on the second. Forget the cilantro; you can’t even taste it with all the other flavors going on. I ate 4 tacos all by myself. (See? I told you I was torn!)

Overall, these fish tacos were great, and making them as the recipe states yielded the perfect amount of heat. I first made a lunch version of this dish with a very good friend who’s a caterer. We both agreed the recipe was amazingly easy, healthy, flavorful, and fast. The texture of the fish was crisp on the outside and moist on the inside. It was almost like it was lightly fried, but I used only 1 tablespoon oil, so it’s much healthier than frying.

I couldn’t wait to make it again that night for my family, knowing that something this easy and this delicious would be a hit. It was extra late when we got home, and everyone was hungry. In trying to speed up an already quick and simple recipe, I cut my pound of halibut into 1-inch pieces rather than the 4-ounce fillets that the recipe called for, so each piece had much more seasoning than if I’d left it as whole fillets. This took the perfect amount of heat in the original recipe and made it way too much. Then I added the chipotle powder and cumin to the slaw which made things a little spicy, too. The combination was too much heat.

My son, who has started speaking in movie references a little too often, compared it to “Texas Pete on more steroids than Stallone.” After adding sour cream, the heat from the tacos was a little more bearable. But the real proof that the tacos were amazing was that everyone kept eating the fish and drinking milk every so often to cool off their burning tongues. I will make this again, following the recipe exactly next time. I decided to use flour tortillas instead of corn tortillas just because it’s what my family prefers.

I did not expect to like this fish tacos recipe as much as I did. I have my own idea about what a fish taco is supposed to be, but the fact is, this made for a really tasty dinner.

The slaw holds up pretty well, so it could be made a couple of hours in advance. I made it 1 hour ahead, and it didn’t get “weepy” in the fridge. The next day, however, the leftover slaw did have some excess liquid. The fish, on the other hand, does not keep well, so make just what you plan to eat in 1 sitting.

The chipotle powder in the slaw was not at all overwhelming. The slaw did have a kick to it, but that was more from the jalapeño, and will vary depending upon how much you use and how hot your jalapeño is. Lately I’ve been getting unusually hot ones.

In frying the fish, I went ahead and cut the fillets into the final-size serving pieces before frying them. This made it a bit easier to fit them in the pan, and saved the trouble of trying to divide the cooked fillets. I used snapper, as it was the best option in my market. My fillets were fairly thin, so the lowest end of the frying time given, 3 minutes per side, was perfect.

The composed taco of sautéed fish and crunchy slaw had a great balance of flavors in which no one component overwhelmed the others. A very enjoyable dish, and a nice reminder that sometimes a recipe that isn’t following the rules can be a winner.

While there are a few tweaks I’d make, based on my personal taste, I think this fish tacos recipe rates as a Testers’ Choice. I used tilapia fillets, and they were perfectly cooked at 3 minutes a side. I thought every component needed more salt, so I added salt to the fish while it was cooking and even sprinkled some salt on the corn tortillas while they were warming. I’m not a huge fan of corn tortillas, so I cooked them a little longer than probably intended by the author in order to give them a little crispiness and some brown spots.

I didn’t care for the Greek yogurt in the slaw and would try sour cream next time—I thought it had an odd tanginess that didn’t really go with the rest of the flavors. I’d also try to substitute one of the vinegar options for half of the lime juice. I did add the cumin and chipotle powder to the slaw—these spices, to me, are what made the dish. Without those flavors, the tacos would’ve been bland (except for that jalapeño!).

I made the slaw about an hour before serving, and it held together well, and even the next night, it had only weeped a little, and the liquid was easily mixed back together with the slaw. I thought the sautéed onions and peppers were a great addition, and the second night, we even added avocado.