Easy caramel sauce. Did three words ever comfort you as much as these?! The promise of ridiculously rich, thick, gooey caramel goodness is sufficient to win us over, more so than even the sweetest of sweet nothings whispered in our ears.
Simple and simply indulgent. That’s what we think of this easy caramel sauce. It’s so darn simple—seriously—that it’s perfect even for random weeknight cravings that can be satisfied simply by scooping something sweet by the spoonful.And while dribbling it over pie may make you murmur and moan in ecstasy, this lovely little caramel sauce has also got countless other applications, including ice cream. Shortbread. Apple slices. Pear slices, too. Banana slices probably wouldn’t be terrible, either. And, of course, there’s apple pie, which takes us back to where we began with this whole easy caramel sauce escapade. We sorta like how that came full circle. Originally published October 25, 2013. –Renee Schettler Rossi
Easy Caramel Sauce
Ingredients
Email Grocery ListDirections
Recipe Testers Reviews
I’m all about recipes that require little thought, can be made quickly for a dinner party, and always impress. And it doesn’t get any easier than this easy caramel sauce recipe for a good caramel sauce. One pot, no prep, minimum watching, and barely any cook time—it’s nearly instant gratification! I used dark brown sugar because it’s what I had on hand and heavy cream because it’s what I thought I needed. Anyway, neither thing caused any problems. I plopped everything in a heavy cast-iron saucepan, applied heat, and stirred. I boiled it for exactly 2 minutes and then let it sit on the stove. After about 20 minutes, I sliced up a fresh Honeycrisp apple and we all dug in. Rave reviews all around! It was thick, perfectly sweet, and smooth. The honey gave it a nice flavor I hadn’t had before. The extra went into a Mason jar for tomorrow…now to think about what deserves this special stuff. This will definitely be going in my recipe file.
This easy caramel sauce is a very nice recipe to have on hand. It does up very quickly and the results taste like you’ve been standing at the stove for much longer than 5 minutes. I found the honey overtones in the sauce to be very pleasant, although I might decrease the amount of honey a little next time according to my own tastes.
This easy caramel sauce is essentially foolproof. It was as quick and easy as the recipe made it sound. At 15 minutes of cooling, mine was still a little on the thin side. I used it over apples for dessert about 30 minutes into cooling. This would be delicious on pie or over ice cream. I did find myself wishing there was a little more complexity to the flavor, but that wasn’t what this recipe purported to be.
HUNGRY FOR MORE?
If you make this recipe, snap a photo and hashtag it #LeitesCulinaria. We'd love to see your creations on Instagram, Facebook, and Twitter.
I love this recipe! I added cinnamon and vanilla to the sauce. To recreate the new Starbucks Cinnamon Shortbread latte, I added water, 2% milk and instant Starbucks Columbian coffee to this sauce and it tastes so yum! I wish I had a milk frother to make the drink so it has the latte feel.
Javeria, wonderful! I’m delighted we were able to help you find your personal Holy Grail of taste!
I love caramel sauce and I don’t consider myself skillful in the kitchen, but I decided to give this recipe a try. It turned out perfectly!!
Magnificent! Am so thrilled to hear that! We so appreciate your trust in our recipe and in taking the time to share your success with us!
When this recipe was posted, I knew I had to find something wonderful to adore this with and this is what I came up with….pan seared zucchini bread in butter, a scoop of pumpkin ice cream, this fabulous sauce and fresh whipped cream. My guests were speechless and legless.
Greg, my fine sir, it sounds as divine as you.
Sorry to be pedantic, but isn’t this really a butterscotch sauce? In my very limited brain you get caramel by, well, caramelizing white sugar and butterscotch by cooking brown sugar in butter or cream until it dissolves. I know, a caramel by any other names still tastes sweet…
Bob, you’re quite correct. And shame on us for perpetuating a falsehood. We saw this recipe in the book with it’s current title of Easy Caramel Sauce and we knew it was butterscotch—which of course is far less tricky to make—but since testers’ loved the taste and professed it to be far more caramel-like than butterscotch-like, we decided to let the title remain. We appreciate your attention to detail and apologize.
This is basically what I have made for years to serve over my Christmas pudding along with vanilla ice cream, except that I use maple syrup instead of honey, being Canadian and all….
Oooooooh, that sounds phenomenal, potterhill. Simply phenomenal.
I made a similar recipe last week & added some pumpkin pie spices – delicious for apple dipping.
Lovely idear, Martha in KS!