This stuffed mushrooms recipe, a favorite starter of Italian trattorias in the 1970s, is a delicious classic that’s worthy, I feel, of a place in this book. As a former vegetarian, I would be happy to be offered this dish to replace meat at any meal.–Katie Caldesi
LC Everyone’s Favorite Fun Guy Note
This unconventional take on everyone’s favorite fun guy may not be quite what you’re expecting. They’re ginormous stuffed fungi, not the little pop-in-your-mouth appetizers that are everybody’s favorite party favor. This is a knife-and-fork, first-course rendition that’s even better. Trust us. But if you’ve got your hearts—and memories—set on those wee cherubic stuffed mushrooms, go ahead and sub button or cremini mushrooms, just for old time’s sake. There are directions for those old-time stuffed mushrooms variation just beneath the recipe.
- Quick Glance
- 15 M
- 30 M
- Serves 6
IngredientsEmail Grocery List
Stuffed Mushroom Variations
- Blue Cheese-Stuffed Mushrooms
- Omit the mint and Parmesan and reduce the bread crumbs to 2 tablespoons. Add 2 3/4 ounces crumbled blue cheese, such as Gorgonzola, in place of the Parmesan.
- Bite-Size Stuffed Mushrooms
- Substitute 15 or so button or cremini mushrooms for the portobello mushrooms. You will not need to use all the chopped mushroom stems.
Recipe Testers Reviews
When I was growing up, stuffed mushrooms always indicated a holiday or celebration of some sort because this was the only time they were made for the family. For years I assumed they were difficult and arduous to make, thus explaining their elusiveness. It turns out they’re easy to prepare, especially in this recipe since the stuffing step is greatly simplified by using large portobello mushrooms instead of small button mushrooms. It was greatly satisfying to have more then a one-bite morsel, and cutting the mushrooms with a knife and fork elevated the dish to a meal rather then an appetizer. In my prep, I did all the chopping by hand, but I don't see why you couldn’t use a food processor. I would give the herbs and garlic a whirl, process again with the mushroom stems, then finish it up with the oil and crumbs. I also thought 15 minutes wasn’t long enough to dry out the mushrooms the way I prefer them. Mature 'bellos can be quite watery when roasted, so increase the time to 25 minutes if you like a meatier texture. The flavor was delicious, and we will be eating these far more often than when I was growing up.
I'm always on the lookout for easy appetizers with a twist. This stuffed mushrooms recipe absolutely fit the bill. And when they’re prepped in advance, you could even bake 'em ahead of time and serve ‘em at room temperature. I used little cremini mushrooms (maybe 1 1/2 inches in diameter). I made the stuffing with panko breadcrumbs mixed with coarsely ground almonds. It worked perfectly, giving a little crunch to the stuffing. I especially liked the mint in the stuffing, which gave a nice, fresh taste to the whole affair. I had to bake the mushrooms for 22 minutes to get them nicely browned (I’ll maybe bake them at 375°F the next time). This recipe is definitely a keeper.
Thanks for reminding us of the 1970s! We loved stuffed mushrooms then, and this recipe gives us an updated version to enjoy. I used 1 pound button mushrooms to provide a smaller one-bite option as opposed to portobello mushrooms. I liked using the mushroom stalks rather than tossing them out (which I wouldn't do, anyways) as it just adds more mushroom flavor to each bite. I added 1 tablespoon olive oil to the bread crumb mixture to bind it and make it hold together a little better before stuffing into the mushrooms. The herbs, cheese, and garlic combined beautifully. We tried the Parmesan mixture first, and a few days later, I made the Gorgonzola variation. We loved them both equally! I guess I'll just have to make a double portion each time. A delicious revisiting of a classic.
There was a 24-ounce package of button mushrooms sitting in the refrigerator, nagging at me for buying them and then abandoning them, so I decided to try them in this recipe. They were a little larger than usual, bigger than the one-bite, pop-in-your-mouth size suggested as a variation, which made them good candidates for being stuffed. I think I would have had trouble getting the stuffing into real small mushrooms without it spilling all over. These were 2 to 3 bites each. I can’t recall using mint in stuffed mushrooms before, but the mint really did something special with these. I’d definitely make these again using portobellos and maybe even increasing the amount of mint a little. Having the wide open top of portobellos would give a different effect than stuffing the smaller opening of a button mushroom. The mushrooms were very moist and, if anything, maybe a bit too juicy. Having the stuffing exposed rather than largely encased might resolve that issue.
Because I was pressed for time, I used store-bought bread crumbs rather than making some. The recipe doesn’t specify the type, but I think fresh crumbs, maybe lightly toasted and buttered, would add another dimension to this recipe.
When I first read through this stuffed mushrooms recipe, the first thing I thought is that there was no way that the filling would "stuff" anything since there didn't seem to be much of it. I was wrong. These aren't your run-of-the-mill, stuffed-to-the-gills (no pun intended) stuffed mushrooms. These are flavorful roasted stuffed mushrooms that have incredible flavor from the cheese, herbs, and olive oil. The meatiness of the mushrooms make this a great vegetarian option to accompany dinner or as dinner with a salad. On the second round of these, I used blue cheese. They’re both equally good, but I think I prefer the Parmesan version just because you can eat more without the flavor becoming overpowering. I highly recommend these.
Instead of being heavily packed with bread crumbs and cheese, these stuffed mushrooms are elegantly topped with just enough aromatics so as to not overpower the wonderful earthy mushroom flavor. Leftovers were just as enjoyable at room temperature. I thought they would make a wonderful side to grilled steaks.
This is a quick and easy stuffed mushroom recipe. I made this with button mushrooms, although I couldn't find any bite-size mushrooms. The smallest I could find were more like a two- to three-bite size. We had these as a nibble to enjoy while we were making a salad. I can also see them being a nice side dish. I’m going to make them tonight and serve them alongside a rib eye. It makes me hungry just thinking about them.
This stuffed mushrooms recipe was a big hit with friends! I went with the suggestion of using button mushrooms instead of portobellos. I also opted for the Gorgonzola variation. I used just under a pound medium mushrooms. I didn’t use all the stalks because I could tell it was going to make way more stuffing than there was room in the mushrooms. I still had more stuffing than room in the mushroom, but I packed it all in anyway. It was fine to have a little extra spill out. It was a quick recipe to put together, and they hold up fine for a couple of hours without refrigeration prior to baking. I baked them for about 15 minutes until they were lightly browned on top and the cheese was soft. The sharpness of the cheese was tempered by the earthiness of the mushrooms. The garlic was a nice addition. It was a great little appetizer!
This stuffed mushrooms recipe is simple to prepare and quite tasty. The stuffing is easy to do ahead of time and makes a nice presentation. Although I used my own fresh mint, the three of us who tasted these stuffed mushrooms agreed that we didn't taste the mint. So perhaps that could be left out. On the other hand, fresh thyme might make a nice substitution. About 13 minutes was plenty for the portobello mushrooms I used. I let them rest for a couple of minutes, which allowed the weeping to settle before plating and serving them.