Just when you think you’ve got it, when you think you’ve finally mastered the differences between scones, cream biscuits, fairy cakes, cupcakes, and muffins, along comes this recipe. Sorry, folks. If these weren’t one of our most popular items, one that many have asked us to share, we wouldn’t be putting you through this torture.
These are tossed together like biscuits, but rather than putting you through the paces of biscuit making, this “shaggy mess” dough is chucked first into a muffin pan and then directly into the oven. Only butter is used versus a combination of butter and lard. As a result, these have a crunchy exterior and a tender but slightly dense, crumbly interior.
They are fantastic as is, but you can also slather them with sweet, creamy butter and your favorite jam, and rest assured, you won’t care about any confusion they might have caused.
Alabama Muffin Biscuits
Ingredients
- 3 3/4 cups all-purpose flour
- 6 tablespoons granulated sugar
- 1 generous tablespoon baking powder
- 1 1/2 teaspoons kosher salt
- 1/2 teaspoon baking soda
- 2 sticks (8 oz) unsalted butter, cold, diced, plus more for the muffin tin
- 1 1/2 cups buttermilk, (either low-fat or full-fat)
Instructions
- Preheat the oven to 350°F (176°C). Butter a muffin tin containing 6 jumbo or 12 standard muffin cups.
- In the bowl of an electric mixer, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder, salt, and baking soda on low speed until evenly distributed. Add the butter, 1 tablespoon at a time, and continue to mix on low just until the mixture is crumbly and there are pea-sized clumps scattered throughout. Slowly pour in the buttermilk and stir just until the dough looks evenly moistened. (It might seem counterintuitive, but the trick is to NOT stir until the dough comes together into a ball or you will end up with a tough muffin. What you want to see in the bowl are various-size lumps of butter and wet flour with some lingering bits of dry flour.)
- Using a spoon or rubber spatula, gently stir up from the bottom of the bowl to incorporate any larger pockets of dry ingredients that remain into the batter. Using an ice-cream scoop, a large spoon, or even your hands, divide the dough evenly among the muffin cups. Since this dough remains loose and crumbly, you’ll need to press it into the scoop or in your fist and glom into the cups. If you’re concerned things still look dry and powdery, top each muffin with a little butter, which will, in a sense, baste the muffin while it bakes. And let’s face it, since when did more butter ever make anything worse?
- Bake for 25 to 30 minutes for smaller muffin biscuits, 30 to 35 minutes for large muffin biscuits. More important than the actual timing is the visual appearance—the tops of the muffin biscuits should turn a darkish golden brown and look ruggedly lumpy and, if you touch the tops, they should feel firm. Cool the muffin biscuits in the tin on a wire rack for 5 minutes then tip them onto the rack to cool or, if you just can't help yourselves, to consume immediately.
Nutrition
Nutrition information is automatically calculated, so should only be used as an approximation.
Recipe Testers’ Reviews
We absolutely devoured these while they were warm from the oven. They were buttery and super tender. As they cooled, they got that crunchy exterior with a crumbly interior. But be forewarned, these muffins are enormous! Even in a standard muffin tin, these suckers have quite the muffin top (as will we once we finish them). Super dangerous, if you ask me! My husband rated these muffin biscuits “make-again good.”
Are they a biscuit or are they a muffin? Who cares when they have both awesome flavor and texture! Not to mention, they’re a dream to make in the mixer. The directions are clear and helpful. For my preferred taste, I may consider cutting back on the amount of sugar. However, nobody else complained. Outstanding—a real keeper!
I’ve never made a muffin biscuit before and I must say that I’m in love with this recipe. It was very easy to assemble and bake.
I made it in a standard-issue 12-cup muffin tin, baked it for 20 minutes, and had the most flaky soft muffin biscuits. I’ll definitely make this a staple in my home. Like any biscuit it’s a tad messy to assemble, but the payout in the end is well worth the mess.
Wow. These were pretty amazing. (But with nearly 1 1/2 tablespoons of butter and a 1/2 tablespoon of sugar in each muffin if you make a dozen, what do you expect?) They turned out exactly like the description provided: “crunchy exterior and a tender but slightly dense, crumbly interior.” I made these for breakfast, so they were eaten with jam and scrambled eggs, but I’d definitely make these again for a soup dinner. I might cut back a tad on the sugar to 4 1/2 or 5 tablespoons, if I were to make any change. My unadventurous toddler even knew this wasn’t worth passing up and devoured hers—a clear sign that it’s a winner. 🙂
At first I was skeptical, but by the end, I was completely and utterly convinced that these “muffins” rock! What a clever idea to just smoosh that dough into muffin tins instead of having to keep faffing with the whole rolling out process. I wasn’t sure about using the mixer, as I always do biscuits by hand, but following the directions exactly produced a terribly tender crumb that held together yet pulled apart perfectly. The muffins weren’t tough or rubbery.
When you first start dumping all the dry ingredients into the mixer and then adding the butter, it all seems quite simple. When you start to add the buttermilk (do try and get the real stuff, not the stuff made into buttermilk by adding chemicals; it’s so much better!) you keep asking yourself whether or not you’re doing it correctly, wanting to heed the warning about overmixing. I found the instructions clear and concise and the dough exactly as described. I piled the mix into 6 large muffin cups—thought I’d try big ones as I’m always making the small ones—with an ice-cream scoop and gently pushed them into the cups. They filled the cups completely and then puffed up nicely with a slightly lumpy, browned, gorgeous crust. I must say they were really delightful. Flaky, light, and oh so sweet. A shmear of butter and you’re away. I do think these would make a great biscuit for breakfast or alongside soups and stews. Dead easy and ever so impressive.
I’m baked goods–challenged and I’m always looking for baking recipes that make me look like a superstar instead of a total dud. So when I say this recipe rocks, believe me, it does. It works as the author intended, which is a shaggy, mostly mixed dough you press into a muffin tin and then top with a slice of butter. I made 6 extra-large muffins using an ice-cream scoop to measure with, which worked out perfectly. Baking time was spot-on, which rendered golden crisp muffins with a moist and slatherable (yep, a new word) interior crumb. Even though this recipe calls for 2 sticks of butter, you can’t go wrong spreading some additional on the baked biscuit muffin and then topping it with your favorite preserves.
The intro to this recipe promises a crunchy exterior and a tender but slightly dense, crumbly interior. The recipe delivers on all fronts, but the intro forgot to mention the rich, buttery flavor of these muffin biscuits. I’ve nothing but good things to say about the awesome textural contrast, with my favorite part being the super crisp, crunchy outside. The muffins held up great to the bitter orange marmalade I served them with. I did have to bake them about 10 minutes longer than the recipe specified to get a good color on the outside.
I’m not lying when I say that I might’ve dreamed about these muffin biscuits last night, they were so delectable! I made them in a jumbo muffin tin and they turned out crunchy on the top and light and buttery on the inside. A perfect biscuit recipe, in my opinion. I didn’t use an electric mixer though, just a large mixing bowl with a fork. Also, I used low-fat buttermilk, which worked well. And 35 minutes for the large muffin cups was just the right amount of time. I like the fact that you bake them as muffins in terms of the shape, but they’re actually a biscuit. That makes for a very nice presentation and easier cleanup. We ate these delicious muffin biscuits alongside soup last night, but these would also be great for breakfast with some strawberry jam…or maybe honey…or maybe with a slice of delicious ham on them instead. Oh the possibilities….
I now officially have TWO favorite biscuit recipes. If that isn’t happiness, I don’t know what is. These Alabama Muffin Biscuits are delicious and have a great texture: golden and crisp on top and moist and perfectly baked on the inside.
Just like with the Buttermilk Drop Biscuits, recipe—the other favorite of mine on LC—not having to roll out the dough allows you to whip these up in no time at all. Butter or jam would be a no-brainer, but I served mine with Smoky Chipotle Vegetarian Chili. The gentle sweetness of the biscuits was great with the chili.
This recipe is a keeper for me. Rarely do I make a recipe that hubby, son, and I all love, but this was one. None of us usually care for biscuits with sugar in them, but this was a huge exception. We treated them as a dessert.
I chose to make the jumbo muffins. Son put butter and raspberry jam on his and said it was really good. Hubby put honey and butter on half and molasses and butter on the other half and declared both ways a hit. I just put a little butter on mine and it satisfied my sweet tooth and was delicious with a cup of coffee. I used a large ice-cream scoop to transfer my dough to the muffin tin and they baked up perfectly in the suggested 30 minutes for jumbo muffins.
This crumbly and tender hybrid of a biscuit and a muffin can be thrown together quickly without fuss. They do have a shaggy appearance (I thought the tops of mine looked a bit like mini cauliflowers), but they taste much better than they look. These are great with butter and/or jam.
The instruction to bake until darkish golden brown is more important than the exact minute count. I made standard-size muffins, which I took out after baking between 30 and 35 minutes, since they smelled as though they were done and the timer said so, too. They were just light golden on top at this point and still a little doughy in the center. After reheating for subsequent meals until darker golden brown, they were done just right. I also followed the suggestion to put a little butter on top of each muffin before baking, as I was concerned about there still being spots of dry ingredients.
First, I’m not a biscuit maker. I don’t particularly care for biscuits. I think they’re dry and tasteless. But the description enticed me to make these biscuits/muffins. The recipe didn’t have fancy ingredients and was well written.
It took about 15 minutes to mix the ingredients, grease the muffin pan, and pop them in the oven. I ate the first biscuit/muffin straight to determine if I actually liked the product. The answer is a resounding yes! They were heavenly—sort of crumbly and sweet. The second one I slathered with butter and homemade amaretto cherry jam. Delish! The third one I just drizzled honey onto. Again, perfection. This recipe is a keeper.
I was intrigued by the name of this recipe—Alabama Biscuit Muffins. How could you make a biscuit into a muffin or vice versa? With this recipe you can. The recipe was easy to make and easier to eat. The muffin biscuits weren’t flaky like a biscuit but incredibly tender (8 ounces of butter plus buttermilk will do that!). Everyone loved them.
I was concerned about the 6 tablespoons of sugar but the sugar enhanced the flavor. The only thing I’d change is the generous tablespoon of baking powder. Is that a rounded tablespoon, 4 teaspoons, or more? I used a slightly rounded tablespoon but I think the recipe would work with a measured tablespoon. They baked for the full 30 minutes for the smaller muffins. My testers loved them and I’ll certainly make them again.
I can’t even begin to count how many biscuit recipes I’ve tested for LC over the years. Sometimes I think it’s because I’m continually trying to overcome my fear of making a tough, flat biscuit. This recipe does a great job of walking you through what you should be looking for as you mix the ingredients. It also eliminates the messy, potentially “harmful” process of rolling out the dough by using an ice-cream scoop to divvy up the biscuits.
More like a muffin with a biscuit top, these are a bit too sweet to accompany dinner or even eggs and bacon but rather are best eaten with butter and jam and a hot cup of tea. I do like how easy they are to put together. I baked them in a jumbo muffin tin and each compartment was piled dangerously high with dough, but alas, the “buffin” or “miscuit” stayed put and didn’t sully my oven.
I made these tonight for my sister and her husband and 4 boys, and they were a hit! I made the standard 12 muffins, and we had to bake them much longer, but of course that may be due to my sisters oven. My sister and I decided that these would make an excellent base for our strawberry shortcake. We usually use the recipe from Saveur, but I think we will be using this recipe from now on. I already pinned this to my “Things I Am Gonna Make” board, just because more people seem to follow that board, but I will most certainly be moving it to my “Tried and True” board, which is the real board everyone should be following!!
Jenn, thank you, there’s no higher compliment or expression of gratitude than what you just typed! Soooo glad you’ve had the same sort of surprised reaction to these curious little creations as most everyone we know who’s tried them. The baking time my be due to your sister’s oven, yes, or perhaps your muffins were packed especially tightly into the muffin tins? At any rate, woohoo and thank you!
OK, I’m intrigued. First because I’ve never heard of a biscuit muffin, and second because my father is from Alabama (born and raised), and I don’t think he’s heard of them, either. I’ll have to ask him, but with all the biscuit conversations we’ve had over the years, I’d be shocked if he’s aware of them and failed to mention it. He’s a traditionalist, so I’ll have to experiment on him and see if he can be swayed. Yet, if Marla’s family has been making them this way since the 1920s…I’d say that also qualifies as “traditional”! Biscuits (by whatever name) in my future, I think.
Let us know how it goes with your father, Allison! I suspect that even if he’s not willing to call them biscuits, he’ll still want to eat a few. Or perhaps he’s known about them all along, and we’ve just blown the cover right off Alabama’s best-kept biscuit secret…
My family has been making these “biscuits” this way since 1925! I always thought these were biscuits until I had actual “biscuits” and was sorely disappointed. I will take “Alabama muffins” any day over biscuits. And if you really want to gild the lilly, add 2 tablespoons of sugar to the dough, divide the dough in half, and pat it into a buttered 8-inch cake pan. Bake for 30 minutes at 400 degrees, then cut into cake-type slices, slice horizontally, and slather with butter. Pour sugared strawberries over the biscuit and top with whipped cream. Oooh-wee! Outta this world good!
Marla, it’s always the oldest, most traditional recipes that seem to end up as favorites, isn’t it? Many, many thanks for your tip, we intend to try that sweet biscuit approach—and soon!